4 ms·
Socialism left millions dead, with those remaining knowing freedom only as an abstract concept.
by mhh__ 7y ago
Socialism left millions dead, with those remaining knowing freedom only as an abstract concept.
- y4mi 7y agoThe same applies to religion if you consider our history. Every concept can be applied in a harmful way which profits the few and oppresses society.
- mhh__ 7y agoSocialism cannot not do that due to the abolition of the pricing mechanism in favour of political power
- DuskStar 7y ago> > Every concept can be applied in a harmful way which profits the few and oppresses society. > Socialism cannot not do that due to the abolition of the pricing mechanism in favour of political power I hope you're not serious, but in case you are... How can socialism not be used to oppress the many while enriching the few? You even included the mechanism - political power! You could argue that it doesn't have to, and I'd say that history does not give great odds on oppression not happening... But to say it can't do such a thing? That's insulting.
- throwaway1906 7y agoCapitalism is working really hard to leave all of us -- and everything else on the planet -- dead, all in the pursuit of making the richest 10% richer.
- mhh__ 7y agoMarket liberalisation has caused poverty to collapse around the world over the last 30 years
- foolrush 7y agoGrow up and look around the world. Socialized health care works //better// than what is in the USA. Socialized news production works //better// than what is in the USA. Socialized education works //better// than what is in the USA. Carry on parroting the Cold War ideology sold and peddled so that a percentage of a percentage point can continue to accelerate wealth hoarding at the expense of the majority’s health and well-being. This isn’t about emulating the USSR as you have been educated, but sane and vastly more just societies such as the multitude of other countries around the world.
- DuskStar 7y ago> Socialized health care works //better// than what is in the USA. > Socialized news production works //better// than what is in the USA. > Socialized education works //better// than what is in the USA. Citations and definitions very fucking needed for all of these. In order: > Socialized health care works //better// than what is in the USA. The best health care in the world is in the US, if you're wealthy enough. For some, that's working better. Even going by total population access, the US isn't exactly bad, though it may not be perfect. And we have socialized health care for large fractions of the population - does that not count? (the old, the poor, the military) > Socialized news production works //better// than what is in the USA. Are you sure about that? Are you really sure that handing production of the news over to the government can ever really be '//better//'? I'd say that such actions enable mass propaganda, among other things. Even if you get a better experience in the short term, IMO what you're doing is taking on some massive risks or offloading your news media to foreign countries. What country even has a socialized news system that you'd like to hold up as an example of working '//better//' than that of the US? > Socialized education works //better// than what is in the USA. Because the USA certainly doesn't ALREADY have socialized education? Pretty sure that we do, for K-12 at least. Which means you're talking about college, and the USA has a pretty damn good university system. The top schools are affordable for essentially everyone (look at the financial aid packages the Ivies advertise, for example) and generally regarded as some of the best schools in the world. So what are you looking for there? Mid tier and lower schools? That means mid tier and lower STUDENTS, and in a lot of the socialized education systems you'd probably hold up as examples they wouldn't be getting free college either.
- dang 7y agoPlease don't take HN threads further into generic ideological flamewar. It's boring, other than to the most zealous of the long tails on either side. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html