3 ms·
Chemistry never had good theoretical classical theory like physics had. Theories have been just rules of thumb or heuristics based on experiments. Theoreti
by nabla9 7y ago
Chemistry never had good theoretical classical theory like physics had. Theories have been just rules of thumb or heuristics based on experiments.
Theoretically all chemistry is quantum physics with nucleons, electrons and photons (quantum chemistry). You need to numerically simulate what happens in reactions and it's very expensive.
- derefr 7y agoPredicting reactions is hard. But why is predicting the physical—rather than chemical—properties of simple inorganic molecules like this one hard? Presumably, trying to figure out how light interacts with a molecule is an easier problem than, say, protein folding, no?
- saagarjha 7y agoNo, because there’s a bunch of quantum goop that gets really complicated and your eyes not going to be able to replicate your theoretical 100% pure result anyways.
- rout39574 7y agoWhat does properties mean, to you? For the sweetness test, the property is the way the compound (or its breakdown constituents, or the compounds whose formation it catalyzes) reacts to our bodies. So you're trying to figure out how our tastebuds work, in response to a novel stimulus.
- derefr 7y agoThe fact of whether or not a chemical reaction takes place in a certain context is a chemical property of a substance. Any fact about a substance on its own, not interacting with other molecules (or at least interacting with them a way that causes no chemical reactions to take place, e.g. being cooled by convection of Neon gas, or scratching in a Moh’s hardness test, or piezoelectric effects), is a physical property. Sweetness is, as you’ve defined it, a chemical property, so it’s not one of the things I was talking about being “easy” to predict. But pigmentation is a physical property, as it is a reaction between a molecule and inbound photons†. Likewise, the output of a “pigmentation calculation”—if we know of one—should just be more photons. Wavefunction in, wavefunction out. We know how photons work. We know how our eyes perceive them. As long as we have a framework for figuring out how a material physically manipulates the photons absorbed by it, we should be able to calculate the pigmentation of every simple molecule by brute force. —— † The pigmented molecule can be in the chemical form or physical state that gives it that pigment very ephemerally, due to e.g. a clock reaction. But at any given instant in time, we can say “the molecule is in this state, so what function does it apply to inbound photons now.” Note also that I’m defining pigmentation here, not total appearance, so this ignores any fluorescence, phosphorescence, triboluminescence, Cherenkov radiation, etc. that the molecule also emits and which we perceive as light. All those purely-physical processes are able to be admitted into this model without actually making it untenable, but it becomes harder to understand, since it becomes a Feynman diagram thing, rather than simple transformation over wavefunctions.
- nabla9 7y agoLight interaction is physical reaction of photons with electrons and it depends on how the electron cloud is distributed. All the vibrations and complex geometries make it really hard to calculate exact solutions. Even that is not always enough. Gold has appears yellow because 5d orbital's distance from nucleus increases and 6s orbital's distance decreases due to relativistic effects. You need relativistic quantum chemistry to figure that out.
- derefr 7y agoSure, it’s challenging math (if you’re doing pure analysis rather than a numerical computation), but that doesn’t imply that it’s NP-complex math, does it? Getting all the details in such a model right seems to be the same kind of problem as getting a weather-prediction model right—in that, as you add factors, all your predictions asymptotically approach correctness, with smaller and smaller preturbations. Those preturbations might cause one or two elements “local” to some part of the configuration-space to be misclassified; but remember, here, that the point is to get a predictive screening test, one that hopefully gives more false positives than false negatives. Any time it says “this molecule might look cool if you made it”, we can just make it and see; and then, if it looks different than we were expecting, we can refine the model with the additional details that make that novel molecule also appear correctly in it.
- nabla9 7y agoThe current upper limit is molecules with 40 electrons or so with 1-2 kJ/mol errors. After that the accuracy decreases dramatically. YInMn molecule has way more electrons that can be solved numerically. Indium atom alone has more than 40.