3 ms·
If you want to save lives, you are wasting your time with medicine. http://hanson.gmu.edu/CutMed.htm http://hanson.gmu.edu/CutMed.htm To save lives and improv
by yummyfajitas 18y ago
If you want to save lives, you are wasting your time with medicine.
http://hanson.gmu.edu/CutMed.htm http://hanson.gmu.edu/CutMed.htm
To save lives and improve the quality of life, you'd be better off providing EVERY American with access to a gym.
Exercise adds 15 years to your life. It's pretty difficult to show statistically that marginal medical treatments (medical treatments that people purchase if they are cheap, but not if they are expensive) do anything.
- Retric 18y agoEarly healthcare tends to reap huge benefits. AKA prevent someone dieing at birth and you add ~70 years. Older patents and random accidents reduce the possible gains. The second cheapest group to save is emergency room patents where minimal treatment can have dramatic effects. Exercise falls into the next group where huge investments in time reap huge long term benefits. (Someone making 50$/hour * 3 hours a week * 50 weeks a year = 7500$ / year.) A 5$ per month medicine is a lot cheaper than exercise so it's long term benefits don't need to be on the same magnitude to be vary worthwhile.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoWell first, the link I provided discusses marginal medicine, or medicine people choose not to buy if it will cost THEM lots of money. Emergency care tends not to be marginal. As for the opportunity cost of exercise, it is only $2850 (average wage is about $38,000/year, http://www.ssa.gov/OACT/COLA/AWI.html http://www.ssa.gov/OACT/COLA/AWI.html) if people substitute exercise for productive work. It's not obvious that that is what would happen. I suspect most people would substitute exercise for TV. Lots of people watch 3 hours of TV per day. Squeezing out 3 hours/week would be easy. For gods sake, 9.9 million people sit on their asses watching The Biggest Loser (a weight loss game show). People can exercise more.
- iamelgringo 18y agoIf you want to save lives, you are wasting your time with medicine. http://hanson.gmu.edu/CutMed.htm http://hanson.gmu.edu/CutMed.htm To save lives and improve the quality of life, you'd be better off providing EVERY American with access to a gym. I whole heartedly disagree. Why then do you suppose that people who live in the Third World (where I grew up) tend to die younger and die of easily curable/preventable diseases? Is it because they got more exercise working in the sugar cane fields swinging a machete for 16 hours? I've read other studies that show that if you exercise 1-2 hours, 3 times a week, you end up living 5-7 years longer, but then, the extra 5-7 years that you live, you've spent in the gym exercising. The article you quoted has a fundamental flaw in that it assumes that we can simply reduce an ICU stay at the end of life by 1-2 days. When a person is in the ICU, it's not quite so clear that a person is only going to live 1-2 days and then die. People want their family in ICU, because they want that person to have any and every chance at living. Certainly he raises some good points about cost effective health care. No on would disagree that a bunch of low cost primary health clinics are going to be a much cheaper way to treat people than an ER or ICU. But, dismissing ER or ICU treatment as unnecessary is absurd.
- yummyfajitas 18y ago>Why then do you suppose that people who live in the Third World (where I grew up) tend to die younger and die of easily curable/preventable diseases? The vast majority of those diseases are prevented in the developed world by non-medical means. A doctor didn't prevent me from dying of malaria, DDT eliminated malaria in the US before I was born. Doctors didn't cure my cholera, other people flushing preventing me from being exposed to it. The NY/NJ water utilities prevented me from being exposed to water-born diseases and my refrigerator/consistent food supply protected me from spoiled food. >The article you quoted has a fundamental flaw in that it assumes that we can simply reduce an ICU stay at the end of life by 1-2 days. When a person is in the ICU, it's not quite so clear that a person is only going to live 1-2 days and then die. People want their family in ICU, because they want that person to have any and every chance at living. True, which is why the ICU study alone isn't conclusive. However, the RAND health insurance experiment (discussed in the article) doesn't have that flaw. Randomly chosen people consumed different levels of health care, and few statistically significant differences were observed.
- iamelgringo 18y agoThe vast majority of those diseases are prevented in the developed world by non-medical means. A doctor didn't prevent me from dying of malaria, DDT eliminated malaria in the US before I was born. Doctors didn't cure my cholera, other people flushing preventing me from being exposed to it. The NY/NJ water utilities prevented me from being exposed to water-born diseases and my refrigerator/consistent food supply protected me from spoiled food. Malaria is still one of the top killers of people world wide, which is why the Gates foundation is funding vaccine research. There are 300 million people world wide infected with malaria, and 1.5 million people die from malaria each year. How's that DDT working for them? I'm an ER nurse by trade, and I pick up old medical textbooks in antique shops whenever I can. There are usually entire chapters on Polio, Tetanus, Tularemia etc... These are diseases that we just don't see any more. Why? Because of vaccines and antibiotics. My uncle, (now a surgeon) almost died in the 40's from a ruptured appendix. Know what saved his life? The new miracle drug that had just come on the market: Sulfa antibiotics. I haven't seen a person die from a ruptured appendix in years. Why? Because of antibiotics and surgery. People used to die from infectious diseases all the time, and they do in the Third World as well. Yes, prevention and basic sanitation help a lot, but that's not the only answer. Pneumonia used to be a major killer. It's not anymore. Why? Antibiotics and oxygen. I was born with a cleft lip. I had two surgeries on my lip before I was 1 month old. My parents took me down to Honduras where they worked in a rural village running a school. People in the village were shocked that there was something that could actually fix cleft lips. There were a number of people in that village and surrounding countryside who lived decades with a cleft lip, not knowing that a surgeon could change their lives. To say that medicine doesn't help people is absolutely absurd.