13 ms·
If Yellow Vests movement taught us anything, is that you can ignore protests long term, even in the face of daily car fires.
by rasz 7y ago
If Yellow Vests movement taught us anything, is that you can ignore protests long term, even in the face of daily car fires.
- dmix 7y agoAt least until the next election. Where the next guy will make a ton of promises to fix things and then once the shine of a new politician wears off and the lack of actual results become obvious, it’s time for a new politician to fix things! I also wouldn’t use France for an analogy here. They protest over literally everything. The politicians there must learn quickly how to ignore them. This doesn’t happened often in Hong Kong, or most countries for that matter. But most countries aren’t facing such a dire future as HK. The Yellow Jacket people, while I support them, have no hardship comparable to facing extradition to China for political wrongthink.
- stcredzero 7y agoI also wouldn’t use France for an analogy here. They protest over literally everything. The politicians there must learn quickly how to ignore them. Sounds like some sites like YouTube should take a look at how politicians in France cope with protesters.
- rolltiide 7y ago> If Yellow Vests movement taught us anything, is that you can ignore protests long term, even in the face of daily car fires. Which should be obvious from passive observation and history, but a whole generation of people have been told they matter, and that their form of government is the inclusive ideal that supports that outcome.
- JumpCrisscross 7y ago> If Yellow Vests movement taught us anything, is that you can ignore protests long term Peaceful protest can be judged on four goals: "(1) the extent to which the relevant outgroup (e.g., policy makers) would be influenced by the collective action (intergroup concerns), (2) the extent to which relevant third parties would be influenced by the collective action (broader societal concerns), (3) the extent to which the collective action would be successful in building an oppositional movement (intragroup concerns), and (4) the extent to which the collective action would be successful in expressing one’s values (individual concerns)" [1]. The Yellow Vest protests resulted in direct action (1) when Macron backed down on the proposed fuel-tax increase [2]. Hong Kong isn't a full democracy and Beijing is ruled by a dictator. Direct influence is thus unrealistic. On influencing third parties (2), however, the protesters have leverage. By threatening Hong Kong's economy, they can swing the Legislative Council's tycoons [3]. International visibility, in turn, deters Beijing with the thread of sanctions and, potentially, military support (if not for Hong Kong, then Taiwan). On building an opposition movement (3), we're witnessing a permanent political change in Hong Kong. The LC recently removed opposition candidates with minimal fanfare [4]. That will be difficult to replicate. On (4), we again have a clear win in forging a Hong Kong identity built upon peaceful democratic solidarity. That shows brightly against Beijing's violent and autocratic alternative. (And has influence outside Hong Kong [5].) [1] http://eprints.qut.edu.au/3815/1/3815.pdf http://eprints.qut.edu.au/3815/1/3815.pdf [2] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-12-04/french-govt-to-suspend-fuel-tax-to-end-yellow-vests-protest https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2018-12-04/french-go... [3] https://www.msn.com/en-gb/money/news/as-hong-kong-erupted-over-extradition-bill-citys-tycoons-waited-and-worried/ar-AADdFQr https://www.msn.com/en-gb/money/news/as-hong-kong-erupted-ov... [4] https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/politics/article/3013437/opposition-lawmakers-hong-kong-occupy-legislative-chamber https://www.scmp.com/news/hong-kong/politics/article/3013437... [5] https://www.ft.com/content/2feba0a6-8eba-11e9-a24d-b42f641eca37 https://www.ft.com/content/2feba0a6-8eba-11e9-a24d-b42f641ec...
- csomar 7y agoNo you can't. However strong the dictatorship is. Hong Kong protest is 2million out of 7million. If you had the same proportions in France, you'd have 20millions. At 20m in France, the president will probably resign in 2-3 days. If not from the street pressure, then from his allies pressure.
- enraged_camel 7y agoI take it you are not familiar with the Arab Spring protests?
- barry-cotter 7y agoThe failed democratic revolutions that lead to massive loss of life in the countries where they fizzled out (Egypt), hundreds of thousands of deaths where the US supported them (Syria, Libya) and one democratic transition (Tunisia)? The Arab Spring was, in toto, a disaster. If you want to discourage revolutions by all means publicise it.
- enraged_camel 7y agoArab Spring was massively successful. It got the entire Arab world hopeful for, and talking about, democracy and self-determination. The fact that all the rebellions fizzled out or were violently put down is completely besides the point.
- TomMckenny 7y agoThe HK protesters have a specific addressable goal.