4 ms·
Most of these are not "selling", they're providing normal 'connected' functionality. For example, any app that uses a name and password to access a server, the
by Terretta 16y ago
Most of these are not "selling", they're providing normal 'connected' functionality. For example, any app that uses a name and password to access a server, they say is transmitting a password. Any app that you invoke "invite my friends", they say is transmitting your contacts.
Yes, for example, Angry Birds is doing these things. But it's by your request. The graphic doesn't show the data being "sold" or sent to marketers.
- brown9-2 16y agoAny idea why Angry Birds would be collecting your Location and giving it to Google and Flurry Analytics, according to this infographic? Does WSJ mean location as in your approximate locale (useful to understand where your users are coming from), or actual GPS coordinates? Their lack of specificity is a bit confusing.
- gommm 16y agoIt seems that for example for Angry bird they send the Latitude/Longitude http://blogs.wsj.com/wtk-mobile/2010/12/17/angry-birds/ http://blogs.wsj.com/wtk-mobile/2010/12/17/angry-birds/
- ergo98 16y agoAngry Birds only requests the following two permissions on Android- -Network Communications -System tools (prevent phone from sleeping) This doesn't include even coarse location, much less a fine GPS position. Unless they're cracking your system, they can't get more than a guessed geolocation of the IP address you're at. Nor can they access your contacts, read your personal details, steal your emails, read your phones identifier, etc. Looking at the WSJ story, they don't even include Angry Birds under Android in their analysis. It is, I think, fascinating that there were so many stories on here about Android apps "stealing your data", yet the iPhone market remained opaque, with so many holding some unsupported notion that a high level curation guaranteed good app behavior. In this case, despite the Android version being only ad supported, I have comfort that it can't possibly be doing what the iPhone app is doing.
- gyardley 16y agoPeople collect location for a lot of reasons - localizing content, planning local advertising purchases, selling in-app advertising to agencies who want to buy access to a particular audience, etc. Sometimes developers just want to understand where their users are coming from out of curiosity. Usually country and state fulfills the above purposes just fine. I've seen GPS coordinates sent off the device and then converted to country / state before the coordinates were discarded - that's how Pinch Media used to do it. Flurry typically just works with IP address, but when GPS is used, it does the rounding off on the device first so the only thing we're sent is already inaccurate.
- ddlatham 16y agoFlurry Analytics will show you how many users and sessions you have in each city / state / country.
- JonnieCache 16y agoI hope that this is in fact the case, and that the android angry birds isnt just gzipping my contacts db and pushing the whole lot out to an ad agency every time I load the program. I doubt that it is, I think even the most aggressive and intrusive ad agency would see that the potential bad press that could come from this would outweigh any marketing benefits. In actual fact, some contact data is sent out only when I use the "share with friends" function (which is never,) as you would expect? Right? Time for some wireshark action methinks...
- leif 16y ago> I hope that this is in fact the case, and that the android angry birds isnt just gzipping my contacts db and pushing the whole lot out to an ad agency every time I load the program. Christ, for the startup times I get, this is a decent explanation. =\
- mike-cardwell 16y agoIf I went to install Angry Birds on my Android phone and Android stated that it required access to my contacts lists, I would abort the install... Do you get any information like that when installing apps on the iPhone or do you have to trust that Apple makes a good decision for you? I'm not sure how the iPhone permissions stuff works, or if that level of granularity exists at all...?
- jonknee 16y agoThere is no notification of requested or used permissions in iOS. Android is definitely ahead of iOS in that department. Update: other than location when you're not Apple (e.g. iAds doesn't request permission even though it uses your location).
- InnocentB 16y agoI get requests when an application wants to make use of my location in iOS. Android has permissions requests beyond this, but I'm fairly confident iOS has at least the one.
- dshankar 16y agoYou're correct. UDID, for example, is part of that "normal connected functionality." Transmitting location, gender and all the other data specifically to advertisers is NOT part of normal functionality.