4 ms·
I don't really understand the title. Before I call clickbait, how did this destroy the world? Sure, house prices will fall in the predicted impact zone, people
by lucb1e 7y ago
I don't really understand the title. Before I call clickbait, how did this destroy the world? Sure, house prices will fall in the predicted impact zone, people will panic and create shortages of essentials in a much wider region, and the worldwide economy is set back by a decade or two. But destroying the world before impact? What?
- jaysonelliot 7y agoIt really is clickbait. Nowhere in the article does it talk about "destroying the world." You'd suppose they were referring to some kind of near-miss from a massive body causing, I don't know, gravitational forces or something. What it's actually saying is that there would be a lot of panic in the run-up to an impact, so that even a relatively small event could cause oil prices to spike and real estate values to drop in the impact area. Hardly anything at all like the headline suggests.
- jandrese 7y agoWorse than the possible destruction of life is the destruction of money.
- gojomo 7y agoIt is an abusive title; 'disrupt' rather than 'destroy' would better match the events envisioned. (I wonder if the source book from which this was adapted, 'Fire in the Sky', includes other more-detailed scenarios of pre-impact destruction?)
- T-A 7y agoIndeed. It's doubly silly, because there is a class of asteroid impact scenarios to which it could actually apply. In the 2015 PDC exercise [1] the asteroid is also split in two by the first deflection attempt (that happens a lot in these exercises, see also 2017 and 2019) and the new bulls-eye is in India. So India plans a nuclear deflection attempt, but China vows to stop it, by intercepting it if necessary, because the second deflection attempt could result in the asteroid hitting China instead. Meanwhile Iran, also in the new risk corridor, but not in the old one, threatens retaliation against the countries behind the first deflection attempt if it's hit: the Great Satan (aka the US), EU, Russia and China. Bottom line: a recurring worry in these asteroid deflection scenarios is that whoever changes the trajectory becomes responsible for hitting whatever ends up being hit, and if that happens to be a nuclear-armed country, the consequence could be WWIII. [1] https://cneos.jpl.nasa.gov/pd/cs/pdc15/ https://cneos.jpl.nasa.gov/pd/cs/pdc15/