5 ms·

Computer monitor causes scare at Newark airport

10 points by J3L2404 16y ago

Qz 16y ago
I tried packing one of my monitors inside checked luggage back when I was flying to/from college a lot. It didn't fit, and in retrospect I guess that was a good thing -- although this was 4-6 years ago when security personnel were slightly less insane.
kgermino 16y ago
I understand that we need to be careful take precautions and all that but come-on we closed down an entire terminal because somebody shipped a computer monitor? If a dog smells explosives, fine, shut down the airport, but just because a monitor releases some radiation (which it's supposed to do) doesn't mean we need to shut down an entire terminal while we wait for an all clear.
- tgflynn 16y ago
  This is the first time I've ever heard of a computer monitor emitting radiation when it's turned off (I'm assuming a monitor inside luggage would have no power source). CRT's emit some X-rays due to high-voltage vacuum tubes but only when they are on, and who uses CRT's anymore ? I'd be curious if anyone can explain why an unpowered monitor or a flat-screen monitor would emit ionizing radiation. A Google search for "computer monitor radiation" turned up no technically useful information on the first couple of screens.
  - dhughes 16y ago
    The article never stated it was a flatscreen or CRT monitor but if radiation was detected I'd say it must have been a CRT monitor. It may be the lead in the glass, lead is already slightly radioactive and being bombarded by x-ray probably doesn't improve that situation any.
    - tgflynn 16y ago
      I am quite confident that bombardment with X-rays of several keV has no effect on the natural background radiation of lead or any other material. Such effects require nuclear interactions with activation energies in the MeV range or greater.
deleted 16y ago
[deleted]
ceejayoz 16y ago
This sounds like a nice way to run a denial of service attack on the nation's airports.
- KeithMajhor 16y ago
  That's kind of ironic. I never considered over-zealous security as a vulnerability.
  - ceejayoz 16y ago
    Just wait until someone bombs a crowded airport security checkpoint some holiday weekend.

10 points by J3L2404 16y ago

Qz 16y ago

I tried packing one of my monitors inside checked luggage back when I was flying to/from college a lot. It didn't fit, and in retrospect I guess that was a good thing -- although this was 4-6 years ago when security personnel were slightly less insane.

kgermino 16y ago

I understand that we need to be careful take precautions and all that but come-on we closed down an entire terminal because somebody shipped a computer monitor? If a dog smells explosives, fine, shut down the airport, but just because a monitor releases some radiation (which it's supposed to do) doesn't mean we need to shut down an entire terminal while we wait for an all clear.

tgflynn 16y ago
This is the first time I've ever heard of a computer monitor emitting radiation when it's turned off (I'm assuming a monitor inside luggage would have no power source). CRT's emit some X-rays due to high-voltage vacuum tubes but only when they are on, and who uses CRT's anymore ? I'd be curious if anyone can explain why an unpowered monitor or a flat-screen monitor would emit ionizing radiation. A Google search for "computer monitor radiation" turned up no technically useful information on the first couple of screens.
- dhughes 16y ago
  The article never stated it was a flatscreen or CRT monitor but if radiation was detected I'd say it must have been a CRT monitor. It may be the lead in the glass, lead is already slightly radioactive and being bombarded by x-ray probably doesn't improve that situation any.
  - tgflynn 16y ago
    I am quite confident that bombardment with X-rays of several keV has no effect on the natural background radiation of lead or any other material. Such effects require nuclear interactions with activation energies in the MeV range or greater.

deleted 16y ago

[deleted]

ceejayoz 16y ago

This sounds like a nice way to run a denial of service attack on the nation's airports.

KeithMajhor 16y ago
That's kind of ironic. I never considered over-zealous security as a vulnerability.
- ceejayoz 16y ago
  Just wait until someone bombs a crowded airport security checkpoint some holiday weekend.