6 ms·
So you reference Snowden then pretend dragnet surveillance doesn't exist? If you are on the internet the NSA is spying on you and everyone else. This is not a
by mulmen 7y ago
So you reference Snowden then pretend dragnet surveillance doesn't exist?
If you are on the internet the NSA is spying on you and everyone else.
This is not an improvement because it makes guarantees that simply aren't true. These compromises are made to further Google's bottom line, not protect users. Don't pretend this is some kind of incremental improvement. It's a marketing gimmick.
- dewey 7y ago> If you are on the internet the NSA is spying on you and everyone else. There's a difference between passively collecting and actively targeting.
- crazypyro 7y agoRight, but the switch is flipped from passive collection to active targeting in secret court hearings* and if they already have been passively collecting, you could go from no concern to being actively targeted without ever knowing. They couldn't do this if they weren't drag-netting. *FISA courts have 11 denied requests and over 34,000 approved.
- bongobongo 7y ago11 denied requests? Those prosecutors must have been sloppy. Usually you don’t see denials because prosecutors know well enough not to waste the court’s time.
- lern_too_spel 7y ago> If you are on the internet the NSA is spying on you and everyone else. Citation needed. > This is not an improvement because it makes guarantees that simply aren't true. No, ProtonMail pretended it made guarantees that it doesn't make. Just like the exact same Exchange/Outlook feature that people have used for years, this is to prevent accidental copying of emails and their contents.
- bitexploder 7y agoIs a citation really needed about the NSA collecting basically all the data on the Internet? This is "common knowledge" in information security circles. Go look up the battles the EFF has fought with the NSA about their data collection practices. The NSA is continually building giant data warehouses everywhere... they probably have more data centers than any other organization in existence. They collect all the data.
- slips 7y agoIt's pretty common for people to throw out "citation needed" when they don't want to believe or admit something, but can't plausibly deny it. Sort of the same way people use the term "fallacy" these days.
- Fnoord 7y agoIMO "Citation needed" is a quick way to say "do you have a source for me?", and "fallacy" (hardly used without also mentioning the specific fallacy) is a quicker way to say "I recognized logic flaw X in your argument". You are free to see harm in these statements but telling me they are always meant as harmful as you mentioned is your own negative reflection. Not mine or ours, we are free to have our own interpretation as well.
- bitexploder 7y agoI think citation needed carries a connotation of “I don’t believe this is true.” It is just a lazy way to converse if you are engaged in a genial conversation in good faith. “This is new to me, can you share some references?” I appreciate we can be technical and to the point, but given the context, I felt my response was appropriate.
- Fnoord 7y agoI do understand you interpret it as "I don't believe this is true" but my explanation "do you have a source for me?" is also a likely explanation. If I then apply the HN rules where the reader must assume good faith and interpret posts in the most positive way, I'm leaning towards assuming "do you have a source for me?"
- inlined 7y agoThough since the Snowden leak Google really upped their game. Everything internally is encrypted in transit and at rest. Even when you use Google Cloud you automatically get encryption at rest.
- mulmen 7y agoShould we be proud of them for that? What does it have to do with Snowden? They can still read my emails.
- inlined 7y agoIt would take a very concerted effort. There are multiple levels of encryption and the best practice is that only verified builds can run in production and only non-humans are ACLd to access security keys. Any attempt to do so would be limited to a very small group of people, trivially logged, caught by AI for inappropriate behavior, and cause a firing.
- mulmen 7y agoRight but Google owns the encryption, which means I have to assume they are reading the messages. They changed their policy once, they can change it again.
- hrwo3123 7y ago+1 The comment underplays the surveillance by using the benign mask to protect its sinister causes. Surveillance has been used to gain economic advantages (as was widely reported), and more importantly geopolitical leverage. For instance, India, a nation run by English-speaking elites has conducted all the affairs of the nation on Google''s servers - such bumbling idiots, normal as they are, are the targets of such a PR campaign. "Oh, you're don't have to worry about it. You're not a terrorist.."