6 ms·
"Options for recipients to forward, copy, print, or download this email's contents will be disabled." I simply don't understand how they think they can get awa
by dheera 7y ago
"Options for recipients to forward, copy, print, or download this email's contents will be disabled."
I simply don't understand how they think they can get away with this foolishness. I can forward, copy, print, or download ANYTHING that passes over my ethernet cables. Your silly UI will ultimately never stop me from wiresharking my own cables in my own home and doing whatever the hell I want with any bits of information that enter my space.
All it does is fool a bunch of less-tech-savvy people into a false sense of security.
- willbw 7y agoExactly. Especially on a desktop operating system. On iOS at least you can have applications give notification over things like screenshotting i.e. Wickr, but if you are on desktop it's stupidly easy to retransmit or download the contents of an email. Maybe Gmail is just admitting that this is the reality (which it is).
- gruez 7y ago>Your silly UI will ultimately never stop me from wiresharking my own cables Or for the less technically inclined, opening the email on your phone/tablet and put it in a photocopier.
- Shebanator 7y agoSure, but that is equally true for products like protonmail that use end-to-end encryption and for those that don't do any encryption at all.
- mulmen 7y agoe2e encryption solves a totally different problem. If you don't trust the intended recipient of a message don't send it. e2e helps make sure nobody else receives the message. Google is making an entirely different claim about controlling the actions of a third party. It's fundamentally impossible to do what Google is claiming.
- pwodhouse 7y agoWhat is Google claiming that you think is impossible?
- mulmen 7y agoThat the recipient can't "forward, copy, download, or print" the message and that the message expiration will prevent the recipient from viewing the message.
- anyfoo 7y agoFrom what you have pasted, it seems that they just claim to disable those options in their UI?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- paulcole 7y agoWon't the light from the copier reflect off the screen and ruin the image? When I was in college (early 2000s) a local company sold notes/study guides for different courses. But they were printed in black text on dark green paper to prevent photocopying and sharing. Good idea on their part but I used my digital camera to take photos of the pages and cranked up the details to make them look like blackish text on whiteish paper. Ended up selling them to all my friends.
- dheera 7y agoSo open the e-mail on a Kindle, or put an antiglare screen in front of your phone, or just take a picture of one phone with another phone if the screenshot button doesn't work. I do remember some app not "letting" me screenshot something with stock Android, which I felt to be a violation of my freedom. Obviously in my case just use a modified Android ROM without the silly anti-screenshotting logic, or screenshot it with adb over USB, but for the less-technically inclined, take a picture of the phone.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> I do remember some app not "letting" me screenshot something with stock Android, which I felt to be a violation of my freedom. Bank apps tend to do that. When I first hit this issue, it also felt like a violation of my freedom, and it was also very annoying because I badly needed to make that screenshot.
- UnFleshedOne 7y agoI think bank apps do this less to stop you from making screenshots, and more to stop that new Candy Clash app you just installed from making that screenshot.
- anoncake 7y agoThat's what sandboxing is for.
- a254613e 7y agoWhy is it hard to understand? Because your average user will not "wireshark their own cables", and those who do will use different methods of secure communication. You'd be surprised how many users are unable to bypass various extremely simple restrictions - and this is the target market for these features. On top of that self deleting email will make it also a bit harder to prove that the screenshot is real - unless you get a court order to get the senders outbox folder from google and the data still exists there.
- consp 7y ago> On top of that self deleting email will make it also a bit harder to prove that the screenshot is real Except it isn't deleted from your send folder.
- zerkten 7y agoHow do you know this? Enterprises have archival/deletion policies automatically applied and emails you forward to outside parties are often tracked in legal hold platforms. It's not unusual for whole sales organizations in particular industries have all emails archived under legal hold requirements (whether sent or received.) Another set of organizations will purge all of the same email older than than a certain date. None of these measures are particularly hard to defeat for a bright user, but many of the risks at the company-level are mitigated. This is mostly to solve challenges with regulation or company certification, but it can make a real difference when someone is handling a privacy incident.
- derefr 7y agoConsider for a moment: a company or school set up as an Enterprise Mobile Device Management provider, handing everyone out ChromeOS devices, setting up their GSuite domain so that nobody can connect to their GSuite GMail accounts except through the ChromeOS device (or an equivalent MDMed mobile device), and setting up an automatic, un-disable-able VPN on those devices for accessing Google domains. I think that’s the scenario Google had in mind when designing this feature. For enterprise users, where the enterprise controls the hardware, the policy-level controls actually have teeth, because people don’t have root over the devices in their possession. For everyone else, it’s not “real security”, but rather just a gateway drug to get you used to the workflow that “real security” would provide in an enterprise context. (Context: I used to work at IBM, and they had a very similar setup—company issued laptop, app that enforces MDM profile installation, VPN that checks with the app to ensure MDM is active before connecting, email servers only accessibly through said VPN, and, on top of all that, a policy-enforcing email app [IBM Notes] where you can delete already-sent things out of other enterprise-users’ inboxes, send expiring emails, etc.)
- lawfulcactus 7y agoIt's worth mentioning that all these measures can be fairly trivially defeated by the analog loophole[1]. I suppose it's harder to prove authenticity in that case, however. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analog_loophole https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analog_loophole
- afandian 7y agoAllow me to sell your organisation some VR goggles with iris-reading DRM protection. Your browser won't display on any other screen. And Google Services won't work in any other browser.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- rndgermandude 7y agoI can still remember the message (or at least important bits) and can write it down when at home or tell it to other people.
- devrand 7y agoAll DLP products are like this. They impose basic limitations that can easily be bypassed by anyone remotely technically inclined. I've come to the conclusion that these products are just to cover the low-hanging fruit situations of someone accidentally doing something that they shouldn't have. In other words, it's a UI integrated "DO NOT FORWARD" message from an e-mail.
- mc32 7y agoI think this is correct. This is to help management say that if if there is a policy and it’s violated that it can’t have been accidental because extra conscious steps have to be taken which violate policy. Making it easier to make people adhere to policy (and discipline as well).
- michaelmior 7y agoI'm surprised no one has come up with a browser extension yet that circumvents this. I'm guessing it would be fairly trivial to do so.
- kybernetikos 7y agoI'd be surprised if the built in print to pdf function doesn't already circumvent this.
- anjsimmo 7y agoGoogle (ab)uses the @media print CSS rule to hide the message content and replace it with "Printing is not allowed by the sender of this message." However, I've found you can print confidential emails if you comment-out/disable all the @media print rules using Firefox developer tools: https://grokprivacy.org/2018/06/24/archiving-self-destructing-gmail-with-firefox/ https://grokprivacy.org/2018/06/24/archiving-self-destructin...
- rndgermandude 7y agoThere is honestly no actual demand for something like that, I'd guess. Screenshots are easy, and your OS usually comes with a built-in tool. And how to use that tool (or find a tool) is a matter of typing "how do I screenshot on X" into google. And if even this is still too "technical" for a user, I have seen people take literal shots of their screens, with their phone camera or whatever.
- michaelmior 7y agoSure, but screenshots don't give you text. Sure you can re-type or use some OCR tool after the fact, but it's one extra step.
- jayd16 7y agoPeople still this Snapchat is secure. Frustratingly, you're not going to win this battle.
- sigmar 7y ago>Note: Although confidential mode helps prevent the recipients from accidentally sharing your email, it doesn't prevent recipients from taking screenshots or photos of your messages or attachments. Recipients who have malicious programs on their computer may still be able to copy or download your messages or attachments. If you click the "learn more" in gmail it says that ^. Gmail seems pretty upfront about what "confidentiality mode" does.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> Recipients who have malicious programs on their computer may still be able to copy or download your messages or attachments. I guess me exercising my right to do whatever I want with my bits on my computer is me having "malicious programs". What in the actual fsck.
- reroute1 7y agoIt's not saying exercising your rights is having malicious programs, they are not mutually exclusive and they didn't make that claim.
- a1369209993 7y agoRecipients who have malicious programs on their computer may still be able to copy or download your messages or attachments. Recipients who do not have malicious programs on their computer also may still be able to copy or download your messages or attachments.
- sigmar 7y agoIt is using "malicious" to mean "intending to circumvent your intention to keep this email confidential." Is there a different word that could be substituted to maintain that meaning?
- a1369209993 7y ago
- FDSGSG 7y ago>All it does is fool a bunch of less-tech-savvy people into a false sense of security. Nonsense, it does a great job of discouraging people from forwarding, copying, printing or downloading the emails contents. Sure, it'll do nothing with a malicious recipient but incompetent recipients are vastly more common than malicious recipients.
- hitpointdrew 7y agoYou have to be a special kind of stupid to not be able to get around this "security".
- FDSGSG 7y agoWho cares? This isn't supposed to stop anyone from intentionally doing bad things, this is supposed to make people stop and think "Huh, maybe I'm just not supposed to forward this email" It's really bizarre that so many people on HN can't seem to understand this. Do you guys ever interact with other human beings?
- veidr 7y agoThat's an outlandish take, because it's entirely divorced from what Google is claiming. If they were saying, "this feature makes it clear to your employees that they shouldn't forward this email" then this entire HN thread would not exist.
- tdb7893 7y agoThis article is put out by a competitor. Also a significant portion of people on HN really don't like big tech companies (which is fair but besides the point here) so I would've been more surprised if there was nuances conversation about it here.
- erichurkman 7y agoI think of it less as stopping people from 'getting around' the 'security' and more an extra level of protection & awareness against accidental forwards or replies. It can't stop malicious actors, of course.
- brokenkebab 7y agoNo foolishness. Such features intended to enhance handling of sensitive data when users' laziness, or lack of understanding is the problem - and it works well in this way. Malicious recipient can do anything, of course, but usually you don't send your secrets to people you don't trust at all.
- sowbug 7y agoDude, come on. You do understand. The feature is like a fence in a yard. It separates the honest from the dishonest, forcing the clueless/negligent/reckless to pick a side. Nobody believes fences stop criminals, and nobody believes Gmail has ended the DRM arms race.
- kryogen1c 7y ago> Nobody believes fences stop criminals I agree with the thrust of your comment, but this isnt true. Measures like this do prevent some crime. When i didnt lock my car and someone stole the gift cards out of it, locking the doors would have prevented it. Just because the car is still stealable doesnt mean door locks are security theater. Putting an unlocked package cabinet for deliveries on your porch lowers incidences of theft without making it impossible.
- reaperducer 7y agoNobody believes fences stop criminals Then why is every military base surrounded by a fence?
- dang 7y agoCan you please edit out personal swipes from your HN comments? This post would be just fine without the first two bits. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- sowbug 7y agoThanks for the reminder, dang. You're right.
- tzs 7y ago> Your silly UI will ultimately never stop me from wiresharking my own cables in my own home and doing whatever the hell I want with any bits of information that enter my space. Their silly UI won't, but what about HTTPS? Won't wiresharking your own cables only get you the ciphertext from the HTTPS session which would be useless to you without the ephemeral key?
- Avamander 7y agoTLS MITM proxies are still doable with your own CA
- hirsin 7y agoIt's not the point. Most "information theft" is people not realizing that they shouldn't share the information. If someone is dedicated enough to exfiltrate information they'll just take a picture of the screen. But now it's really clear that that's what they're doing. Source - same discussion years ago at Microsoft when Windows introduced this at an OS level to prevent screenshots of confidential mail.
- Avamander 7y agoYou overestimate the average user :/
- la_barba 7y agoWell you can't claim anything as "secure" either because someone somewhere has a 0-day. It just depends on where you draw the line, and for what application you're using it.
- anjsimmo 7y agoAll that's needed is to disable a few browser options https://boingboing.net/2018/07/22/adversarial-interop.html https://boingboing.net/2018/07/22/adversarial-interop.html I actually tried the "wiresharking my own cables" approach, but because it's encrypted, you also need to dump the ephemeral encryption keys. There's a simple guide on how to do this here: https://jimshaver.net/2015/02/11/decrypting-tls-browser-traffic-with-wireshark-the-easy-way/ https://jimshaver.net/2015/02/11/decrypting-tls-browser-traf...