12 ms·
The rationale for lowering the age is universal suffrage, same argument as giving women the vote, giving those with no property the vote, giving those with no e
by tialaramex 7y ago
The rationale for lowering the age is universal suffrage, same argument as giving women the vote, giving those with no property the vote, giving those with no education the vote. Share the responsibility for the terrible decisions.
Historically those with the vote have often pretended that they vote wisely and newcomers could not be depended upon to do likewise. There is no evidence for this proposition, Trump appealed perfectly well to retirees, to men, to those who owned country estates, and only lost marginally among the well-educated. If there is wisdom, it's not the domain of the existing electorate.
As to why it shouldn't coincide with emancipation, government policy doesn't wait until you're emancipated, everything from whether the air you breathe is toxic to whether you have to do gym class is a matter of government policy, why not give those affected a say?
- mc32 7y agoBecause until emancipation your well-being is looked after by others who do have this right. Until you are emancipated, one is essentially selfish (taking in, rather than being contributory and adding value). I.e. you don’t have as much skin in the game. You don’t have to have property to contribute, you don’t have to be a man to contribute. It’s clear those aspects were anachronistic and failed to reflect reality. At the same time a 25 year old who has no desire to move out from a parents or guardians home has less argument to a right to vote than a 16 year old who’s pulling a job, going to school and helping siblings financially or otherwise.