3 ms·
It is a tough problem to solve. Many middle schoolers' lives live on Instagram and snapchat, and getting COPPA to protect 13-15 would only introduce operational
by judge2020 7y ago
It is a tough problem to solve. Many middle schoolers' lives live on Instagram and snapchat, and getting COPPA to protect 13-15 would only introduce operational problems for the existing users. Twitter already has this problem for when you change your birthday to something that shows you signed up before you were 13, and just recently started getting those accounts un-locked (which means they didn't even immediately delete the data of those used-to-be-12 year olds)[0].
Perhaps the above would depend on the text of the bill, ie. existing 13-15 year olds can continue to use the services without interruption. That would be up to the lawmakers.
And, as per the article, lying about the child's age is a norm to get them on the internet as early as 10 or 11. I have a few friends who were fine telling their children to lie about their age to get them on instagram and snapchat. As a service there's not much you can do about this unless you require every sign-up to go through the COPPA parent verification process (where the most popular method is credit card verification), so COPPA being changed to "you can be penalized if they're under 13 even if they say they're over that age" wouldn't be a solution.
0: https://techcrunch.com/2019/05/14/after-year-long-lockout-twitter-is-finally-giving-people-their-accounts-back/ https://techcrunch.com/2019/05/14/after-year-long-lockout-tw...
- rock_hard 7y agoMy sister created herself a Facebook account when she was 6. And remembering my childhood self, there is nothing that would have stopped me from getting one. Being a parent now myself also in fact would probably even assist my kids to get whatever accounts they want...better to have it happen under my supervision than in secret. As always, lawmakers are a little out of touch with reality
- Consultant32452 7y agoLawmakers aren't out of touch with reality. The only reality is they want to be seen as "doing something." That something being effective isn't a very high priority in most cases.
- falcolas 7y agoYou, a parent who would provide supervision, are not representative of all parents. As such, the “village” must step in and ensure that children with parents who are not like you are not exploited for the lack of supervision. Also, there’s nothing banning Facebook from offering under-13 children accounts, other than their own lack of options for offering non-tracking/non-advertised accounts for those children.
- WrtCdEvrydy 7y ago> options for offering non-tracking/non-advertised accounts for those children LOL, that's the future of privacy, setting your age to below 13.