3 ms·
And how is that bringing us back to "preindustrial CO2 levels"? There are some more contributers to CO2 than plants. Also, cars? Also, energy storage? Also no
by hutzlibu 7y ago
And how is that bringing us back to "preindustrial CO2 levels"?
There are some more contributers to CO2 than plants.
Also, cars?
Also, energy storage?
Also non scaleable of wind?
...
So yes, it was just napkin math. Not helpful.
- adrianN 7y agoPrimary energy consumption includes all forms of energy. Electricity, but also fuel, heating, etc. If you make it fully renewable the country becomes pretty much carbon neutral, save for things like metallurgical coal. Energy storage raises cost a bit, but not too much, depending on the quality of the electric grid. You don't very much storage if your grid is good because it's always windy somewhere. Excess energy can be converted to Methane via power-to-gas and stored in the existing strategic gas storage facilities. Better informed people than me wrote long papers about this, and also looked into scalability issues. It's a bit hard to reproduce in HN comments.
- hutzlibu 7y agoTrust me, I am informed on that topic. And I am all for a green Energy base. And there are countless other options than just methan or hydrogen for storing energy around or in develepoment. But it is still hard and expensive. Did you factor in redesigning of the energy grid? Renewables need much more flex .. the current system is designed for huge plants, giving constant energy, not many small ones fluctating. Did you factor in, replacing all gasoline engine in cars? Did you factor in designing and replacing airplane engines? (And with what, running then on hydrogen? maybe. Would be awesome, but the tech does not exist yet) And even if we achieve 100 renewable ... there are still lots of industrial processes that release CO2, like concrete production, that reaching preindustrial CO2 levels is a very, very hard and therefore expensive challenge. So maybe be careful with your claims.