3 ms·
> Although the car was three miles away from the planned exit when the spoofing attack began, the car reacted as if the exit was just 500 feet away—abruptly slo
by rasz 7y ago
> Although the car was three miles away from the planned exit when the spoofing attack began, the car reacted as if the exit was just 500 feet away—abruptly slowing down, activating the right turn signal, and making a sharp turn off the main road.
Designer fail, why is navigation system explicitly trusting GPS signal while the car has multiple sources suitable for dead reckoning(1)? ABS sensors alone (distance) would tell you something was wrong (being teleported 2.5 miles forward), then you have accelerometers, compass, cameras supposedly able to recognize side roads. Tesla needs to work on their kalman filter implementation.
1) Etak https://patents.justia.com/patent/5948043 https://patents.justia.com/patent/5948043 dead reckoning patents expired by now.
- Waterluvian 7y agoI think you're a bit mixed up. The higher layer that manages strategy was tricked to make the lower layer safely exit at the wrong exit. At least that's my reading of it.
- antsar 7y agoI think 'rasz is suggesting that a well-designed higher layer should cross-check its various inputs before doing stupid things. If GPS says we moved but tire rotation says we didn't, well, maybe don't blindly trust the GPS?
- rasz 7y agoThats not even all that high level, as per Etak patent: "Based on the previous position of the object, the GPS derived position, the velocity, the DOP(dilution of precision) and the continuity of satellites for which data is received, the system determines whether the GPS data is reliable."
- rasz 7y agoCar made a sudden decision based on spoofed data from a single sensor despite abundant alternative sources. Article also mentions being able to manipulate victims suspension. Again you have tons of sensors reading road is glass smooth and straight but you listen to one unauthenticated source telling you its a bumpy dirt back alley - who are you going to believe?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- banana_giraffe 7y agoWhile I agree with you, you then need to worry about the opposite problem: Car drives onto ferry, GPS signal is lost, car drives off to ferry, dead reckoning figures the car is lost in the water, GPS is regained placing the car very much somewhere else. Do you trust dead reckoning or the GPS? In this case, you trust the GPS, one assumes, since dead reckoning places you in the middle of a body of water, though there And this isn't a made up scenario. My car fights this every weekday. It's always entertaining to watch it figure this out as the GPS recovers badly and it starts to place me inside buildings in an area with poor GPS coverage.