6 ms·
Misleading headline. They spoofed GPS and caused the car to safely exit the highway at a different exit than planned. This is hardly an emergency. A human might
by modeless 7y ago
Misleading headline. They spoofed GPS and caused the car to safely exit the highway at a different exit than planned. This is hardly an emergency. A human might easily make the same mistake if their GPS was spoofed.
I don't trust Autopilot myself, I've had too many phantom braking incidents. But GPS spoofing is not a good reason to criticize Autopilot.
- judge2020 7y agoSay FSD comes online or NOA is enabled for city streets. A driver without their attention on the road might not notice the mistake, and a dedicated attacker could navigate the car wherever they wanted and do malicious things (attack the car, harm the passengers, etc). Sure, it's not a big problem now, but it could be a problem when the Tesla self-driving fleet comes online and it drives you to a back alleyway to get mugged and/or killed.
- modeless 7y agoA driver might also trust their phone's instructions with the same consequences. We know people often trust their GPS over road signs.
- jaimex2 7y agoYep. Its been done to death by security theatre "researchers", there's even an xkcd on it: https://xkcd.com/1958/ https://xkcd.com/1958/
- torpfactory 7y agoWe have a whole ecosystem of ride sharing apps that IMO are even more ripe for nefarious activities. If your Uber or Lyft driver wanted to hurt you, they very well could. This is such a low likelihood risk that it's barely work talking about.
- function_seven 7y agoAll that sounds pretty implausible. Sure, it's all technically possible, but it's a more complicated way of attacking a target. For one, the attacker would have to know in advance that you'll a) be actively navigating at the time, and (b) what your programmed route is (they have to know what to spoof). Then, they'll need to get their radio gear together, wait for you to come near, enable the spoofing contraption, hope you don't notice that the car just made an error and pulled into a dark alley instead of 42nd Street, and ambush you. Not gonna happen for a simple mugging. If you're a specific target, then sure, but your days are probably already numbered.
- the_duke 7y agoIt's not just the headline. The whole article is written with a FUD spin. The actual information about the results is presented in a very cryptic fashion , making it easy for news outlets to write "OMG Tesla hacked" articles, and circulating their name and their product in the process. This is exactly the reason why I despise PR.
- slg 7y agoYou have to get pretty deep into the article to get to these two lines: >Any product or service that uses the public GPS broadcast system can be affected by GPS spoofing... this research doesn’t demonstrate any Tesla-specific vulnerabilities >The effect of GPS spoofing on Tesla cars is minimal and does not pose a safety risk It would of course be better if Tesla vehicles weren't vulnerable to this type of attack, but the headline and much of the article has potential to be very misleading to someone who doesn't completely understand what is going on here. EDIT: I stand by the general point of this comment. However I did miss the context of the quotes I included here. See nirvdrum's comment and my reply.
- aeternus 7y agoTesla vehicles can likely be made less vulnerable to this attack than even human drivers navigating via cell-phone GPS since Tesla has inertial measurement units. They are likely 'trusting' GPS signal over IMU currently, but that could be changed via software. Or at least alert if the signals disagree.
- frereubu 7y agoYou don't even need GPS spoofing for drivers to get it wrong: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/south_west/6646331.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/wales/south_west/6646331.stm
- nirvdrum 7y agoI'm not sure those two lines really support your conclusion. They may, but they're both taken from Tesla's response to a previous test performed with the Model S. If you read further on, the researchers take issue with Tesla's response, particularly the part about it not posing a safety risk: > The fact that spoofing causes unforeseen results like unintentional acceleration and deceleration, as we’ve shown, clearly demonstrates that GNSS spoofing raises a safety issue that must be addressed
- slg 7y agoYou are right that I was mistakenly quoting a quote. I was skimming the article and was thrown off by the inconsistent formatting. Some of the multi-paragraph quotes are indented to identify them as block quotes. The sections I was quoting from just had a quotation mark at the start then three paragraphs later another quotation mark to end the quote.
- JKCalhoun 7y agoHow about a future headline: "Tesla Freighter spoofed to abandoned warehouse, thieves make off with $2M in goods from self-driving semi." Brave new world coming…
- SilasX 7y agoSo? That just means the car won't crash before you trick it into driving into its convenient ambush spot.
- teleclimber 7y agoLast paragraph: > Yonatan Zur, Regulus Cyber CEO and Co-Founder, [...]: “We designed a product to protect vehicles from GNSS spoofing because we believe it is a real threat. We have ongoing research regarding this threat as we believe it’s an issue that needs solving. So they're selling the cure to an ailment they insist is a very big problem. I'm not saying GPS spoofing isn't a problem, just that this is hardly unbiased research.
- brokenmachine 7y ago>I don't trust Autopilot myself, I've had too many phantom braking incidents. What happens when that happens? Did you come to a complete stop?
- modeless 7y agoNo, basically it'll just slow down 20-30 MPH abruptly and unpredictably. It tends to make the person behind you mad, and could certainly cause a rear end collision if someone wasn't paying attention. I also wouldn't trust it in any situation where lane lines are ambiguous, incompletely erased, or just unusual. I have about 50% success navigating freeway ramps and interchanges around here, and even when it is successful it drives slowly and erratically, again making other drivers mad. I've basically given up on that feature, and I also don't use it at speeds above 45 MPH. I'm hopeful that the more powerful "HW3" Tesla neural net computer will allow them to basically redo the whole thing for "fully self driving". If they're just planning on running what they've got now but faster, then they are not going to be successful. Finally, although I am bullish on the no lidar approach, I am skeptical that their current camera setup is good enough. They really need more coverage and more resolution, and probably more compute than even HW3 provides. But improving the cameras in newer cars would mean giving up on "fully self driving" for existing cars, and that would be disastrous for them given the promises Elon has made and the millions of dollars of "fully self driving" features already sold.
- brokenmachine 7y ago>giving up on "fully self driving" for existing cars, and that would be disastrous for them given the promises Elon has made and the millions of dollars of "fully self driving" features already sold. That surprises me. Has Tesla really promised "fully self driving" for existing cars?
- modeless 7y agoOh, most definitely. You can go to tesla.com right now and configure your very own Model 3 with the "Full Self-Driving Capability" option for $6,000, and they've been selling that option for years.