5 ms·
I don't like to be the cynical one (hmm), but I'm not at all convinced. An awful lot of the "dialog" looks like it is generated content. Maybe not all of it, bu
by nl 16y ago
I don't like to be the cynical one (hmm), but I'm not at all convinced. An awful lot of the "dialog" looks like it is generated content. Maybe not all of it, but there is a lot that sets off alarms for me.
<Insert obligatory thread about Turing tests, Twitter, 4chan etc here I guess />
If I'm wrong, then please pretend you never read this, and DON'T THINK AUTO GENERATING CONTENT IS A GOOD IDEA!
- jackowayed 16y agoI go to Stanford. A lot of people were talking about likealittle within a couple weeks of its launch. Not startup nerds, people who found the product fun. Based on the number of mentions of it I hear about (including some people in my dorm posting >5 joking flirts in the course of 10 minutes while hanging out), I find the high number of posts and comments totally believable. College students love wasting time and love interacting. Also, I'm looking at the posts from my dorm, and I know for a fact that at least most of it is real.
- nl 16y agoIt doesn't surprise me that it works & gets interest, but I do wonder how they got over the cold start problem. I guess I'm just overly suspicious.
- barmstrong 16y agoSomething about it looked fake to me as well, but obviously it's difficult to tell.
- hugh3 16y agoWell I just looked at my campus and there's a recent post labelled "two hours ago" about a girl in a cafe just off campus. The problem? It's 5am on a Monday, and (while I haven't checked) I don't think that cafe is open at three. But hey, maybe it's a screwy datestamp.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- hyyypr 16y agoI think you're right about the generated content. I just found the exact same message in the princeton and queen's university boards (after hitting "more messages"). Maybe it's the same user who posted the same thing in different unis, but it seems unlikely...
- chr15 16y agoI agree, much of the activity does look "faked." It raises red flags when usernames like Boysenberry, Orange, Pineapple, Lemon, Tomato, Grape, Cranberry, Pepper are responding to all the posts. But IIRC the creators of reddit did the same thing when first launching. They faked activity by posting stories under different accounts. If LAL is faking activity, they could reach a tipping point and get the real users they need. Whether or not faking activity is ethical is a different question.
- HistoryInAction 16y agoThose aren't the usernames, those are the anonymous 'masks' that LAL puts on commenter activity to assign unique identity among comments.