2 ms·
I'm a little confused on this risk factor: Use the same QR to provision multiple TOTP applications Poor understanding of what/where their second factor
by jandrese 7y ago
I'm a little confused on this risk factor:
Use the same QR to provision multiple TOTP applications
Poor understanding of what/where their second factor is.
Documentation: Tell users to only provision one device
What is the risk here? If I have two phones and only one of them on me at a time, why is it dangerous to configure my authentication app on both phones so it's available regardless of which one is in my pocket?
- irishsultan 7y agoBecause if you do not know where your other phone is then you do not know who has access. The same issue exists with a single device as well, but to a lesser degree, because it's less likely to be out of your control.
- jandrese 7y agoIt's in a locked box. And I'm not too concerned about someone breaking my phone security, and then the TOTP app security to get at my second factor. If I'm being targeted that hard they're probably just planning to kidnap me and hit me over the head till I login to my accounts anyway.
- DownGoat 7y agoIt better to add two different devices with different secrets to the account, than both sharing the same secret. This reduces the chances that something goes wrong when a device is lost, or removed. The user can the remove the other device with much less risk of locking themselves out of the account. It also might provide some info in the cases where a secret is leaked, as it can be tracked to the specific device. There is no real security risk of the devices having the same secret, or in adding a backup device. It is really a usability thing, the biggest pain point a user will experience with TOTP is when they are switching phones, or when they lose one. Decreasing the friction here can greatly improve the security of the system.
- jandrese 7y agoIf the service supports that then it's fine. A lot of services only support a single TOTP key per account though. There's a small risk in provisioning multiple TOTP keys on one account too. Each one reduces the search space for a brute force attack. Add in allowances for drifting clocks and a lack of account lockout for missed attempts and you might open up the window just enough for a brute force attack to be successful.
- phillipseamore 7y agoI always use the same QR code to provision more than one OTP app on my (1) phone, since I've had some of them fail on me after updates or OS upgrades.