4 ms·
I understood circles. I spent two hours carefully categorizing everyone I added into the perfect Venn diagram. And then I realized that this was bonkers, and t
by pavel_lishin 7y ago
I understood circles. I spent two hours carefully categorizing everyone I added into the perfect Venn diagram.
And then I realized that this was bonkers, and that I never wanted to do it again.
- duxup 7y agoYeah it seemed like you could put a lot of work into managing your circles ... and it wasn't apparent that you would get get nothing out of it until you did it.
- ghaff 7y agoLike anything else you can overdo it. But, at a minimum, you will often want (somewhat overlapping) professional and personal groups. They made sense especially at a time when many people were realizing they didn't want all their social media to be one undifferentiated bucket.
- conductr 7y agoYa I never used it but assumed that was their way of trying to be Facebook LinkedIn and Twitter all at once. Problem being the world already had those services and by being separated the circle management is done for you.
- duxup 7y agoYeah asking a user to switch modes on the fly was pretty awkward.
- TremendousJudge 7y agoThe fact that they already existed separately is not a compelling argument by itself. As a counterexample, many people owned both mobile phones and music players in 2007, but the iPhone was a huge success anyway.
- conductr 7y agoI agree with your statement. But counter example is weak. It combined a backpack worth of physical devices, some of which you may have already owned or not. Phone, gps, camera, music, laptop, game console, etc. oh and btw now all those devices were internet connected automatically with no wires/WiFi. The value add was compelling. I never saw any value add at all for g+ much less a compelling one. My main point was, circles actually seemed like more work which is kind of the opposite of compelling. The outcomes of these 2 products tells me so. After all Things like Snapchat and instagram popped up due to compelling features. Newer iPhones are struggling due to uncompelling features and would be my counter counter example.
- waylandsmithers 7y agoKind of funny that among other things, nobody at Google realized that most married couples would never want to have to go through making their wedding reception seating chart again.
- duxup 7y agoAnalytical folks love to categorize, less so most people... even analytical folks sometimes.