4 ms·
Many humans can't do any of the things CS textbook AIs are supposed to do. For example: play Go or chess at all, never mind to a high level. Write good music.
by TheOtherHobbes 7y ago
Many humans can't do any of the things CS textbook AIs are supposed to do.
For example: play Go or chess at all, never mind to a high level. Write good music. Pass a Turing test. Drive at least as safely as average.
Maybe a third of the population is going to struggle with ticking off even one of those requirements. [1]
Someone who can do all of the above is comfortably in the top 5% of the human ability range.
Curiously, the usual list of goals looks suspiciously like the interest profile of a tenured CS academic.
Things humans do but AIs don't include:
Parsing complex social and personal interactions and maintaining maps of social and political relationships. Improvising solutions to problems using available resources. Converting word-of-thumb learning into memorable narratives - either as informal instruction, or as a formal symbol system. Communicating with nuance, parable, irony, humour, metaphor, and subtext.
Some humans can also parse complex domains and extract an explicit rule set from them - but that's a much less common skill.
Except for that last one - maybe - these all seem like they're much closer to the human version of intelligence than any goal based on a specific output.
[1] Even the driving, because many people can't drive at all, so it's not a 50% break at the average. And even the Turing test, because there are still a lot of humans with no Internet or computer experience, and they'd find the glass terminal experience very strange and unsettling.
- mannykannot 7y agoAnother thing that humans do but AIs don't: They recognize that they are doing everything on your list and wonder how they do it. This self-aware consciousness is something that goes beyond any particular skill.
- ben_w 7y agoI’m curious: has anyone actually tested how many humans “wonder how they do [a thing]”? What would such a test of the general population even look like?
- mannykannot 7y agoI am not aware of any such study - not that that means anything. If one assumes, as seems reasonable to me, that a person's theory of mind is based on at least a tacit assumption that other people function somewhat like oneself, then one might make the working assumption that experiments on a person's theory of mind [1] also reveal something about how they tacitly perceive themselves. If you want to know something about their explicit thoughts about their mental capabilities, one could start by asking them. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_mind#Empirical_investigation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_mind#Empirical_inves...
- z3phyr 7y agoThe root as I see is that Intelligence is still very loosely defined (or not defined at all). We cannot simulate something undefined. And I am not talking about philosophical or linguistic definitions, but strict mathematical definitions with proofs and experiments.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y ago>> Many humans can't do any of the things CS textbook AIs are supposed to do. I am not sure what you mean with "can't do". Could you please clarify? Further, could you describe how you would determine that a person "can't do" something? For example, how would you determine that a person "can't (do)" play chess or Go at all?
- mcphage 7y ago> how would you determine that a person "can't (do)" play chess or Go at all "Hey so-and-so, do you know how to play Chess?"
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoEdit: I don't that's the meaning of "can't do" that the OP had in mind. Why not let them clarify what they meant?