4 ms·
Why bother innovating when its not needed? Expensive bicycles are in the same market as fancy watches. Its all just wealth signalling. Nobody needs 10% lighter
by rasz 7y ago
Why bother innovating when its not needed? Expensive bicycles are in the same market as fancy watches. Its all just wealth signalling. Nobody needs 10% lighter frames, or 5% more aerodynamic shapes. If you want to drive faster or burn less energy you go electric, If you want health benefits you buy the shittiest heaviest bike you can find and pedal harder.
- CydeWeys 7y agoDon't get a shitty bike if you want exercise. Shitty bikes are unpleasant to ride, making the experience not fun, and discouraging you from doing more (and longer duration) riding. Also, safety is important, and shitty bikes are less safe.
- bluntfang 7y agoThis response to the person ahead of you makes me think you either don't know much about bikes or you missed their point. I think we all agree, buy something shitty and you get shit, especially with things you put between you and the earth. A medium quality bike, which costs an order of magnitude less than a "fancy" bike, will do literally everyone who isn't a cat 1-2 racer fine, objectively. Price difference is $1-5k for a mid range vs $10-20k for top of the line. I don't think anyone is advocating for $300 walmart bikes here.
- CydeWeys 7y agoI don't understand your objections, nor do I see how you can infer that I don't know much about bikes. Yes, the person I was replying to was advocating for department store quality bikes. I don't see how you can interpret it any other way. He literally said "shittiest heaviest bike you can find", not "$1-5k medium quality bike".
- gameswithgo 7y agoYou could win the tour de france doing the road stages on a medium quality bike. (if you put good tires on it). Also given your price range, some of the objectively best bikes (meets weight minimum, good aerodynamics) are in the $5k range, and the more expensive ones are worse but have big name value!
- gamblor956 7y agoThat's definitely not true...at the level of the TDF, every gram of excess weight matters, and there's a vast weight difference between a cheap $5k bike and a "fancy" $20k bike. If you're not at the TDF level, there's no point in spending more than $2k on a bike since the difference in weight won't matter.
- paulcole 7y agoIf every gram matters why do they wear those little hats under their helmets?
- 7952 7y agoActually the rules restrict minimum weight and they often have to add ballast. And reducing weight does have diminished returns at some point, particularly on flatter sections. I think the weight obsession is more aimed at selling to amateurs than making pros faster.
- cycomanic 7y ago
- rasz 7y ago$300 actually buys you a fancy walmart bike, the really bottom quality uncomfortable ones hover around $100.
- DC-3 7y agoNicer bikes are more pleasurable to ride; they make the activity more enjoyable. What's signalling about that?
- timwaagh 7y agothese are racing bikes meant for racing. A racer might want 5% more aero, because that's the difference between winning that race or not.
- rasz 7y agoThis $3-5K https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/speedx/speedx-unicorn-smart-road-bike-with-built-in-power https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/speedx/speedx-unicorn-s... was a racing bike?
- timwaagh 7y agoI'd say so. although it markets 'comfort' as well as stiffness and low frameweight, i dont expect it to be super comfy. might be it's more aimed at granfondo riders (which are still timed events) or group riders racing for signposts with their buddies though.