2 ms·
> But it's been crickets so far. I'd love to hear a defense of this couple and their cause. I wouldn't offer a defense, because I'm not an anti-vaxxer, and I a
by mistermann 7y ago
> But it's been crickets so far. I'd love to hear a defense of this couple and their cause.
I wouldn't offer a defense, because I'm not an anti-vaxxer, and I am not supportive of this couple's actions, but there is plenty of material on this topic here for an interesting epistemological discussion.
Staying emotionally disengaged seems rather difficult for most people though. Vaccines are safe, full stop, is only true for particular definitions of the word safe, not all. The fact that people have died from from vaccinations should be enough to demonstrate this from an objective/logical perspective on a hacker website, but this is where human psychology comes into play. Hackers, while highly logical, are first and foremost human.
> Or -- is this so far outside the Overton window that folks are afraid to speak up?
Well, you wouldn't be able to have much of a conversation on HN or in most subreddits, because the inevitable downvotes would render the person playing devil's advocate unable to respond.
I also don't have much time today despite how much I enjoy such conversations, and I'm quite confident it would rapidly descend into a shitshow of a conversation demonstrating various peculiarities of the human psyche, which you'd think would be interesting to those with a hacker mindset, but there seems to be limits to people's curiosity - certain topics seem to be off limits (this article touches on this phenomenon: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/experiments-in-philosophy/200804/what-s-the-matter-little-brothersister-action https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/experiments-in-philo...).
Just as a hint, I would be starting with questions along the lines of:
How do we know vaccines are safe?
What exactly is the definition of the term "safe" in this context? Does safe possibly have somewhat distinct meanings at the micro-level vs the macro-level?
Are there any imperfections in the current vaccine delivery and monitoring system that might allow unrealized risk to go undetected.