4 ms·
I'd argue for something around $20k-30k/year. Don't index it to the median income; index it to the cost of living in around 80% of cities (ignoring outliers lik
by JoshTriplett 7y ago
I'd argue for something around $20k-30k/year. Don't index it to the median income; index it to the cost of living in around 80% of cities (ignoring outliers like Silicon Valley and Manhattan). High enough that you can absolutely live on it, including housing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- EpicEng 7y agoIgnoring the trillions of dollars that would cost, what makes you believe that housing costs wouldn't inflate dramatically? Supply isn't magically going to boom and people all of a sudden have more spending power.
- JoshTriplett 7y ago> Ignoring the trillions of dollars that would cost (Most reasonable proposals I've seen for UBI include an assumption, stated or unstated, of drastically reduced administrative costs and costs of numerous other more specific programs for both aid and employment. And that also ignores other secondary effects. For the moment, let's treat that as a tangent, please, though.) > Supply isn't magically going to boom Not overnight, no. And not without some fixes in housing regulation. (That's also another reason to avoid indexing it to ridiculously-high-cost-of-living areas.) But in general there's no fundamental reason supply can't increase to match demand. Also, right now supply has a massive constraint created by "proximity to work". If people have a lot more flexibility about where and how they work, the economics of "where do people live" changes drastically.
- chr1 7y agoIt may be better to index it to the percentage of total income tax paid by everybody to prevent feedback loops, when higher ubi increases cost of living, increasing ubi and eventually driving the whole economy off the cliff. Something like a tax return but calculated not as a percentage of the persons tax but of mean tax. It can start as a very small percentage at the start (1% ~ 1K/year) and then grow as other social payments are folded into it.
- gizmo686 7y agoThat still produces a feedback loop. When the economy goes down, people recieve less UBI and therefore spend less, slowing down the economy more. Over the short/medium term, ww want UBI inversly correlated to total income tax (which I would expect is correlated with total economic health), so it can serve a dual purpose as an economic stimulus. Setting the UBI should be a matter of monetery policy set by the Fed, within parameters set by Congress.
- chr1 7y agoIf economy goes down and you keep printing money not backed by anything, the value of the money goes down and you end up with hyperinflation like in Venezuela or Zimbabwe. So that's a very useful feedback loop: if too many people decide that they want to do art instead of driving trucks, the total income tax will go down, decreasing ubi and making more people to work. If someone invents self driving trucks and starts to get huge profits, ubi goes up, helping the drivers to live while they learn new useful skill.
- gizmo686 7y agoOver the long term, maybe. Over the short term, recessions are still not going to be caused by changes in aggregate behavior; they will continue to be caused by business cycles, so we want to have counter-cyclic forces.
- chr1 7y agoI believe with fixed 20k UBI, that is increasing when income tax decreases, the hyperinflation would happen very quickly (1-2 year) much quicker than the business cycles. But even if i am wrong it is better to start with small and conservative UBI scheme to be safe.