3 ms·
I have yet to see any evidence that UBI would accomplish any of the things its proponents think it will. The first unintended consequence I predict would be inc
by phkahler 7y ago
I have yet to see any evidence that UBI would accomplish any of the things its proponents think it will. The first unintended consequence I predict would be increases in rent, food, and other basic things. I believe a better solution to helping the lower end of the economic ladder would be things that reduce the basic cost of living.
- lostphilosopher 7y agoI'd be interested in an answer to this too. We've seen a similar phenomenon in college costs - more government loan money available, higher tuition, repeat. Why would UBI not result in a general uptick in costs that would mean the "purchasing power" of the consumer is the same? I think providing the basic services themselves would be more effective and efficient, even with the bureaucratic overhead.
- basch 7y agoIm sure Im wrong, but wouldnt it make sense to start with like "all rice, bean, potatoes, and broccoli consumption at the personal level is free" and start with a food stamp / ebt that buys unlimited of something very specific? It wouldnt be a currency thats worth trading to other people, landlords couldnt collect ebt credits in lieu of rent, because everyone would already have unlimited. Instead of subsidizing agriculture at the production side, you can combine farm subsidies, food stamps, and ubi into one consumer credit, designed to persuade people to consume mostly free food over luxury food. Whats the next thing it would make sense to subsidize for everyone without creating some kind of cyclical purchasing power loop?
- SubiculumCode 7y agoFor food, goods, and services, for much of the market there is both sufficient competition and means to increase supply, that I do not think prices can be raised unilaterally with an UBI. If you raise your prices, but I don't, I get your customers. Basic free market ideas. However, for rent, there is real scarcity in supply AND limited ability to raise production. I expect that UBI will be an inflation ratchet for rent, unless it is paired with a policy that somehow increases housing supply. UBI could help more inland cities become more attractive to business as their economies would grow with UBI, but have more land to build housing on.
- phkahler 7y agoI know someone who lives in subsidized housing. Rent is a percentage of income. Barring additional changes, that percentage of UBI would go directly to rent as a matter of law. That might be less of it than normal unregulated rents.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoWhy would it result in an increase in inflation? As economists say "inflation is a monetary phenomenon". So if you pay for UBI by printing money, then of course it would increase inflation. But Friedman's original proposal and most others pay for it by having the rich pay for the poor through taxes and the middle class pay for themselves. And on the demand side, the poor in America are generally obtaining food and housing somehow. The food's not nutritious and the housing might be a shelter, but only a small fraction of the homeless let alone the working poor are actually sleeping outside. On the housing side, proponents hope that UBI will encourage people to move out of the expensive areas where jobs are to areas that are cheaper to live in. So a good argument could be made that housing costs will go down. On the food side, food is a commodity. The price of a commodity is the marginal cost. So as long as the producer costs are similar between producers, demand has very little effect on the price of food.
- ac29 7y ago> But Friedman's original proposal and most others pay for it by having the rich pay for the poor through taxes and the middle class pay for themselves. It would increase inflation in this example not because the government is printing money, but because the source of the money (the "rich") are not in the market for low-end housing, but the recipients of the taxes are.
- davvolun 7y agoThere's a response to the parent comment that has real data on increasing the minimum wage. It's only two papers on one location, but until we see at least the same kind of thing on UBT, it's all wild speculation. I don't want to be in the location that passes UBT only to see it fail wildly, but we need that data. I would certainly argue an economy the size of the U.S. or China (as if...) shouldn't experiment without better data. Personally, I seriously doubt UBT will fail wildly, and I want to see it move forward, responsibly.