4 ms·
There was a really embarrassing early fork, resulting in Ethereum and Ethereum Classic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethereum#The_DAO_event https://en.wikipedi
by sp332 7y ago
There was a really embarrassing early fork, resulting in Ethereum and Ethereum Classic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethereum#The_DAO_event https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethereum#The_DAO_event This means you can't 100% trust that your smart contracts will be honored because Ethereum miners have (now repeatedly) shown a willingness to revert them.
- Diti 7y agoAlmost as much embarrassing as the Bitcoin revert IMHO – https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Value_overflow_incident https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Value_overflow_incident
- rlt 7y agoEh, they were very different. From a technical perspective I'm not sure which bug is worse (FWIW the Bitcoin one happened 1 year after it launched and 5 years before Ethereum launched), but the justification for forking Ethereum was weaker and more controversial. Ethereum was forked to revert the loss of funds (about 3% the current supply of ETH I think) of users of a specific (but popular) buggy contract. Ethereum itself would have survived without the fork. The Bitcoin bug enabled an attacker to create ~184 billion Bitcoin, resulting in something like 50,000% inflation. Not reverting that would absolutely have killed Bitcoin.
- shazow 7y ago> FWIW the Bitcoin one happened 1 year after it launched and 5 years before Ethereum launched FWIW the Ethereum one also happened 1 year after it launched.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- dsco 7y agoThey've also shown an unwillingness to fork other hacks, such as the Parity one: https://blog.zeppelin.solutions/on-the-parity-wallet-multisig-hack-405a8c12e8f7 https://blog.zeppelin.solutions/on-the-parity-wallet-multisi... I do understand that reverting is somewhat against fundamental blockchain ideals, but on the other hand – you could always just continue using Ethereum classic – if you're a more principled blockchain enthusiast. Also the use of the word "embarassing" makes me wonder if you truly understand what massive efforts it takes to create something as ambitious as Ethereum without running into some critical bugs.
- sp332 7y agoEthereum Classic is now a separate currency. It's trading at only $8.46 USD right now.
- kalleboo 7y ago> Also the use of the word "embarassing" makes me wonder if you truly understand what massive efforts it takes to create something as ambitious as Ethereum without running into some critical bugs. What made the fork controversial was that it wasn't a bug in Ethereum itself (Bitcoin also had a fork due to a code bug and that was wholly uncontroversial), but rather a bug in a single contract. Bugs in contracts will always happen, since, well, it's code. Code has bugs. What's makes it funny is that the investment terms page explaining the contract was extremely clear that the contract code itself were the only terms that mattered, not any "intent". Everyone who invested agreed to the bug, even if they didn't know about it.
- derefr 7y agoAnd yet Ethereum Classic [where nothing was reverted] ended up with a lower valuation than mainline Ethereum [where the DAO coin loss was reverted], showing that some path-dependent mix of {users, developers, investors} prefer a system with governance to one with immutability.