2 ms·
A browser extension won't have any effect on Instagram because the vast majority of users are on the mobile app. Besides, there's no reason for the BBC to star
by rchaud 7y ago
A browser extension won't have any effect on Instagram because the vast majority of users are on the mobile app.
Besides, there's no reason for the BBC to start providing technical advice. Are they supposed to provide instructions on how to install it on Chrome, Firefox, and Safari? And also explain why it doesn't exist on IE, and why it exists on desktop Chrome/Safari but not mobile Chrome/Safari? How about also explaining that things like Twitter embeds (which news sites are full of) won't appear with UO's default settings, effectively breaking the site's functionality?
What happens if the extension breaks down the line (might happen with future Chrome updates)? Is the editorial team supposed to have a reminder to go back to the article and update it?
- deogeo 7y agoI assumed my intent would be clear, but if you insist on nitpicking: The BBC could mention it's possible to block ads on the browser version of Instagram, with various browser extensions. Why you think this means they'd have to explain every possible technical detail of ad blocking, I have no idea.
- rchaud 7y agoBecause it's the BBC, they have certain editorial responsibilities. It's one thing if they started a content series around digital rights, where adblocking extensions could be discussed. But this is a standard issue news story, so it's not appropriate to editorialize. Look on the linked page for links to external sites. Beyond the Twitter embeds and cancerous Taboola/Outbrain advert links, there are none. For regular news stories, the BBC will rarely link out to non-BBC URLs unless it's to link the original investigation run by a different organization.
- deogeo 7y agoHow is mentioning the existence of ad-blockers, on a story about ads, editorializing? Meanwhile teaching you how to be a good consumer and set your ad preferences is 'neutral'?
- rchaud 7y agoFrom your original comment: > they could teach how to install uBlock Origin, instead of how to help corporate when their spying fails. That's quite a bit different from "mentioning the existence of", which would be reasonable IMO. In any case, the elephant in the room that's gone unmentioned so far, is that the BBC introduced Google Ads on the site a few years ago, so it's probably not a priority for them to explain to users how they can block ads.