8 ms·
Little Free Pantry
- hprotagonist 7y agoAccess to dry goods and food to people who lack them is certainly a good thing. I would like to suggest that it's an even better thing when it's done personally and actively. You learn who your neighbors are, for a start, and there's even a chance you'll bind yourself tighter to your community!
- fnord77 7y agohow do you prevent assholes vandalizing these or people taking the items and reselling them? (in SF people get stuff from the food bank and then sell it on the sidewalks around mid-market)
- perfmode 7y agosometimes you've gotta place your trust in the goodness of others. and when you're proven wrong, trust and trust again. furthermore, such violations of trust are helpful indicators of the types of structural issues present in one's community. sure. there might be places in crisis where such a system wouldn't be able to get enough traction to function. in such a place, one should turn one's attention to the big picture.
- Baeocystin 7y agoYou can't, and it gets trashed. We had just such an honor system set up by well-meaning folks here in Gilroy, and it lasted for all of a few weeks before the first time everything was taken and the box trashed and smeared with feces. The majority of the people who needed to use the box did so respectfully and properly. There is a huge need, particularly here in the bay area of California, where the number of people forced into homelessness has exploded over the past several years. The problem with systems like this is that they have no oversight, the bad apples find them and take/destroy with glee, and it doesn't take many of those folks to ruin it for everyone else.
- Broken_Hippo 7y agoYou prevent vandalism to these boxes the same as you prevent vandalism of anything else on the street: You really don't. Most folks won't do that sort of thing. As far as reselling items: Prevention is simple. Make a safety net, make sure folks have housing, and make sure there is medically backed addiction help out there. It won't solve all of it, but it surely raises the bar as folks won't be so desperate to rob a bunch of tiny pantries instead of a store. Other sorts of prevention just punishes people struggling, both the one selling and the one buying. Edit: Also, stores selling illegal goods should be prevented now. SUrely we have the tools if not the manpower.
- klyrs 7y agoThe thing about charity is that people often need money more than food. People who haven't ever been poor, or been significantly close to poor people, often don't understand the differences in cost/benefit analysis between themselves and poor people [0]. So you hear concepts like "I'd give them a $5 sandwich but not a dollar because they'll blow it on drugs." Which is basically the ethos behind food banks. So you end up with food rich, cash poor homeless folks It's actually okay that panhandlers sell food on the street. They're exchanging a plentiful commodity for a liquid asset. They need money to live, not just food. And dollars per hour, sadly, drugs are about the cheapest form of entertainment our society has to offer. [0] https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/11/your-brain-on-poverty-why-poor-people-seem-to-make-bad-decisions/281780/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2013/11/your-br...
- sjmulder 7y agoWe have one of these in our neighborhood and it's quite actively used. There's a Facebook group for it which does cultivate a sense of togetherness. Sometimes people take all the things but it's rare.
- ineedasername 7y agoEven the people that take all of the things... maybe they need them, so I wouldn't judge someone harshly for it.
- keyle 7y agoThis is a great venture with such a simple message. When you consider how much a supermarket throws out, it would make a lot of sense to place one 'strategically' near a supermarket. Maybe an employee will take it to heart and supply it.
- b5 7y agoIn an ideal world, they would be allowed to do that. As it stands, that would potentially be a quick way for them to lose their job. When I last worked in a supermarket (just over three years ago) taking home or giving away food that was destined for the bin was treated as theft. You could be fired for it if your manager felt that way inclined. Several months before I started, several people at another store lost their jobs for just that. Instead of throwing out the bake-goods, they'd been giving them out in small amounts to people who were struggling. Sometimes it was a handful of bread-rolls, other times it would be croissants or muffins. There was no loss to the company because the food had been written off anyway. Still -- it was treated as theft, and they were fired. The company would prefer the food was wasted than it feed people.
- michaelmior 7y agoWhile I certainly agree that it is a shame that food perfectly good food which is going to be thrown away can't go to feed those who need it, I think it's a bit of an oversimplification to say companies want food to be wasted rather than feed people. There are many other issues: liability if someone gets sick, employees intentionally preparing too much food to ensure extras leftover, etc. I'm not saying these issues are more important than keeping people fed, but I do think addressing these sorts of things would go a long way to make policies allowing food to be given away more practical.
- Miner49er 7y ago> There are many other issues: liability if someone gets sick, employees intentionally preparing too much food to ensure extras leftover, etc. Pretty sure the liability thing is just a convenient excuse. In the US we have the Bill Emerson Good Samaritan Food Donation Act, which protects food donors from being sued. I bet most other countries have something similar. Additionaly, nobody has ever been sued over donated food in the US.
- bobbyd3 7y agoThis is a great website and a very worthy cause. Several of the LFP's in my community I had no idea even existed...the search feature is awesome.
- socrateslee 7y agotwo questions: 1. how the pantries get cleaned? 2. how to deal with expired foods?
- abootstrapper 7y agoI assume the property owner who installs the pantry maintains it and its contents.
- 0xbadcafebee 7y agoThese might be illegal in major Florida cities, as it is illegal to feed the homeless.
- asark 7y agoI mean, if it's a give-a-can-take-a-can for when a neighbor doesn't have some black beans and needs them for a recipe, but sometimes those darn homeless people just happen to "rob" it? Or is food not under lock and key illegal?
- benj111 7y agoWhat? Really? What if they want to buy something in a shop, is that illegal? What happens if you have a homeless friend and you invite them round for dinner? Or is it like pigeons, you just get signs in the park saying 'don't feed the homeless' Speaking as a European, this just sounds bizarre.
- inferiorhuman 7y agohttps://www.gainesville.com/news/20171225/cities-volunteers-clash-over-feeding-homeless-in-public https://www.gainesville.com/news/20171225/cities-volunteers-...
- fredsted 7y agoLooks like that site blocks non-American IPs.
- executesorder66 7y agoSouth African IP here. Works for me.
- benj111 7y agoI cant read this either, is there a TLDR?
- elil17 7y agoThis model totally ignores the fact that the people with the resources to give food live no where near the people who need food the most
- abootstrapper 7y agoWrong. In medium to large cities, the homeless are everywhere. They're in our neighborhoods, they're on our way to work, they're outside our office.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoHomeless people mostly don't want or need items like flour and sugar. They typically lack a means to cook. They generally need hot meals and snacks that can be consumed promptly. They have little to no storage capacity and carrying things everywhere is exhausting. They do not appear to be the intended recipients of the types of goods made available in this manner.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- elil17 7y agoBut there’s already a system in place for giving food to people who obviously need it: just giving it to them
- abootstrapper 7y agoThat has nothing to do with what you said or my reply. I wasn’t arguing for or against little pantry. But to your brand new point, can there not be more than one system to give to the needy? Maybe you don’t want to carry can goods with you to work, maybe you don’t want to interact with strangers, maybe you want to help people at times you’re not physically in front of them. It sounds like you have a bone to pick with this concept but you lack a compelling reason to argue against it. Here, I’ll share my reasons for not installing one at my house. The wild animals will want it, the heat here is extreme and will cook its contents, and I don’t want strangers loitering in front of my house. Still it’s an interesting concept. It might work well for some people is some areas.
- groundCode 7y agoThis is nice. In the UK some supermarkets have a food bank you can donate to as you leave. I usually donate food to those. This is a bit more personal. Although I’m lucky enough to live in a neighbourhood where it doesn’t seem like people are wanting for food. I suppose you never know when someone is having a rough few months though and this is a nice way to foster some relationships.
- Freak_NL 7y agoOne of those shown on the front page is in the Netherlands, but access to dry foods isn't usually the problem for the target users here, because they already qualify for access to our system of foodbanks. Dutch supermarkets donate a substantial amount of dry goods and fresh produce to foodbanks. If you want to make a difference, set up a recurring donation to your local foodbank instead, or volunteer to help. People in financial need already go there, so you can help them by not making them run around town to a bunch of free little pantries, and help them avoid the shame of using that pantry in your neighbourhood being watched by all your neighbours. This feels like one of those initiatives that benefit the provider more than the intended recipient.
- skrebbel 7y agoBut how will your neighbours know that you're donating to the food bank?
- Broken_Hippo 7y agoBy helping to advertise donations to the food banks. Of course, this means putting signs in your yard/window or actually talking to neighbors.
- Waterluvian 7y agoThis is a really intriguing idea. But whoever designed that has never spent a summer with the kind of raccoons we have up here.
- mattferderer 7y agoI've been told, at least in the US, that we have more than enough food at food banks. It's much more of a distribution problem. Things like these help a bit. It's also interesting to see that places are investigating direct shipments to homes as well. I don't have any sources but discussions with local food banks. I was told over a year ago that west coast states have started testing it. I think both these ideas can help different groups of hungry people. Those with an address & those without.
- peterwwillis 7y agoThe simplest, most direct assistance would be if somebody got a bike with a carrier trailer, and just rode through nearby food deserts delivering care packages to people with food insecurity. People often can't leave their homes (can't get a sitter, don't have a bike or car, are disabled/elderly, etc) and this moves the assistance out of wealthy neighborhoods and into the ones that have difficulty getting food. They could drop leaflets in mailboxes that people could check off if they need food, and then you could go back and collect the leaflets, and know who to deliver to. Or make the leaflets prepaid postage to just return via the mail.
- mattferderer 7y agoPeople do that but with a truck in many areas of the country. I'm not sure how the food delivery works in all parts of the country, but I believe you would sign up yourself or a family member to receive a collection. Note, many people won't signup themselves.