3 ms·
There seems to be a very distinct difference between employee classes. Management and high value tech employees are treated very well while moderators, gig work
by luckylion 7y ago
There seems to be a very distinct difference between employee classes. Management and high value tech employees are treated very well while moderators, gig workers etc are treated as "human resources", quite literally.
It seems to me that they put companies like Cognizant between them and the exploited workers to deflect criticism as "we didn't know, we've been told by our partners that everything is great".
And on a technical level: if true, how can it be that FB needs the same videos and pictures to be moderated over and over? Are they not using any form of content id? Is developing such a system more expensive than running content moderation sites and then swiftly firing the burnt out moderators?
At what point do you become complicit if you're working for Facebook?
- jsgo 7y agoThe only problems I see are that someone could potentially upload a lower resolution version of the video a moderator has seen and then perhaps bypass the content id system (I don't know how tolerant they tend to be for situations as that). There's also the aspect of if we make it search out for distinct frames (like "scene change" type things), there's the possibility that some safe things could become auto-moderated which would be another controversy. Perhaps if they could locate start/stop times for inappropriate elements of the source video and then check for videos containing any of those in a later uploaded video, but then instead of asking human moderators to discern "is this video good or bad" we're now forcing them to get timestamps of when bad elements take place which would force them to really watch the video. Dunno, I'm of the belief that it's just not an easily solved problem. I hope I'm wrong and they can toss money at the problem to fix it, but I genuinely don't know how they could.
- luckylion 7y agoEven with lower resolutions, fingerprinting (on a frame level) should still work relatively well, shouldn't it? If you get a certain level of confidence on each frame - if you have 80% of the frames with 80% confidence to be the same as $someVideo, that ought to be good enough overall to not get false positives but catch repeat views - how many 30s videos will randomly share 80% of their frames with a 90s video of an animal being abused? I assume that most of these videos aren't manipulated by professionals to escape a ban by looking completely different (which actually would make it a different video), but that they are mirrored, cut, have extra material appended or, as you suggested, have their resolution changed. I'd guess that videos are easier to ID than, say, image data, because you have plenty of material to work with. Are there well-organized troll armies attacking Facebook? Because trying to sneak a video in that shows an animal being abused and doing sophisticated changes to evade detection sounds weird on a platform where there isn't even (as far as I know) monetary gain connected to posting a video (as it might be on YT or for Email spam).
- xamuel 7y ago>how many 30s videos will randomly share 80% of their frames with a 90s video of an animal being abused? If a powerful actor wants the 30s video removed, and knows it would be removed if it shared 80% of its frames with a 90s video of an animal being abused, then it would not be technically difficult to engineer such a 90s video.
- luckylion 7y agoYeah, but that works once or twice, and then the defense catches on. Sure, it's not a perfect solution, but rather like spam filters, it gets you pretty close. Also, I don't assume that powerful actors are the issue here - they'll likely just call their contacts at a high price law firm and they in turn call FB to remove some video.
- xamuel 7y ago>And then the defense catches on And has to redo everything. It's whack-a-mole. Doesn't have to be powerful actors really, either. There are many less powerful actors who would love to get selected things removed from YouTube. This isn't the same as spam mail filters, because you generally don't know what sort of emails other people are sending each other. If you did, you could deliberately try to manipulate filters to flag your competitors' emails as spam.
- luckylion 7y ago> If you did, you could deliberately try to manipulate filters to flag your competitors' emails as spam. You could, it's just hard and generally not worth it. The same, I believe, goes for video manipulation. Sounds like hash collisions. Possible, sure, but not something you run on your cell in 30s.
- xamuel 7y agoIt's eye opening when you realize how cut-throat competition can be when it comes to blackhat SEO etc. If you've discovered some longtail goldmine and you're the #2 result when people search for it and it's making you money, you have a big incentive to do anything it takes to nuke the #1 result. And before you say "You'll get caught and banned", obviously you do the nuking with a sockpuppet account. That's blackhat 101.