4 ms·
Facebook decided to reinvent the wheel and make it closed source. IMHO this is a mistake and a bad idea for any wannabe blockchain platform. I am curious about
by jillesvangurp 7y ago
Facebook decided to reinvent the wheel and make it closed source. IMHO this is a mistake and a bad idea for any wannabe blockchain platform. I am curious about their motives for doing this. I'm guessing that it is simply that their plan is the same as that of any traditional payment solution: create a walled garden and profit through transaction fees. This requires a closed ecosystem.
In terms of design, this actually looks a lot like Ripple/Stellar. The difference being that those two are open source and anyone can run an independent validator. There's a growing number of those. And with IBM building world wire on top of Stellar together with a few dozen banks, here's now some traction for that platform at least.
It might still work for Facebook and I would not be surprised to learn that they took some of the Apache/MIT licensed code of either platform. but I'd say they'll have huge issues with people simply not trusting them with their money. They will also need links to other platforms via some exchanges. Again, Stellar comes to mind. It comes with an exchange and an ecosystem of fintech players already connected to that.
Facebook is of course not the only company planning to do their own coin. Telegram has similar plans and there are a gazillion of dapps on Ethereum and similar chains. Most of these seem to be struggling to find meaningful amounts of users. Unlocking crypto for the wider public is not something that anyone has accomplished yet. FB might pull this off given their large user base.