4 ms·
>Users aren’t reducing your internet speed any more than a new neighbor signing up for Comcast. The technical capability of their cable network is far faster th
by jchw 7y ago
>Users aren’t reducing your internet speed any more than a new neighbor signing up for Comcast. The technical capability of their cable network is far faster than the speed Comcast doles out to you, since you pay for a throttled speed tier. The xfinitywifi network users aren’t included in your throttled speed.
Is this actually true? I mean sure, DOCSIS 3.1 is capable of gigabit speeds in theory. But are the CPU and other resources on the modem/router actually _fully_ isolated? And coaxial cables that were laid decades ago, are they actually capable of reaching speeds fast enough to totally isolate you from bandwidth issues? Some people fail to hit their advertised speeds as is.
My guess is that the reality is, you do lose some performance and gain some latency if there's a lot of xfinitywifi traffic going through your router.
I am a Comcast customer, reluctantly, as pretty much any other Comcast customer, but I use my own hardware always. I don't like what Comcast is doing here, especially because they're not really telling you about it. Of course, as you would expect, you don't get any discount for what you are doing for them either, it's just part of life if you rent equipment, which eventually costs more than it saves anyways.
But even if you buy your own hardware, trying to feel in control can be very hard. I used to use a MikroTik hAPlite as a router, but it got hacked a couple of times, and many more vulnerabilities eventually turned me off of MikroTik products despite how nice they were to use. Then I moved to one of the actually-kinda-expensive Linksys AC2600 and boy did that stuff piss me off royally. On top of the annoying 'smart' features, including a click through EULA and requiring online registration to access my own router's configuration menu, it honestly performed terribly. Being in an apartment, I connect my desktop via WiFi, and this thing couldn't even keep a stable connection for that. Some devices wouldn't connect at all, and I never figured out why, after hours of looking through logs and troubleshooting; the hAPlite had no such issues.
So... I gave in. Surfboard SB82000 modem, Ubiquity Unifi AC and USG, and Cisco switches. It isn't cheap, and frankly it's completely ridiculous overkill. It's gotta be like, $500 worth of crap new, and it does require some additional setup, like having a machine setup to act as the controller. But, I rest a lot easier, and I have literally not had a single issue since configuring everything. Which is definitely more than I can say for any Comcast-installed equipment I've had to deal with. Good riddance.
I hope some day there's a 'sane' option for people who just want good performance, good security for home use cases, but right now I'm wondering if there will ever be anything aimed at consumers that isn't trying super hard to exploit the crap out of them. The situation with consumer internet equipment has left me very jaded, especially because I remember running DD-WRT on a WRT54G and having a great time.
Edit: It is worth noting that I never tried any of the whole home mesh WiFi solutions. I’ve heard good things, but apartments seem like unideal places to install them.
- ars 7y ago> Is this actually true? Yes, it is actually true. The speed of WiFi relative to coax is puny. There's no way WiFi can come close to taxing it. I suppose you are using a bit more WiFi spectrum, but your neighbors do that too.
- jchw 7y agoOh of course, WiFi alone isn’t enough, at least probably not until the next generation of WiFi. Consider also wired traffic, though. The xfinitywifi hotspot is hosted on modem/router devices of all sorts, including Comcast Business devices.
- ec109685 7y agoMesh wifi’s are a godsend. Happy Eero user since its Kickstarter.
- kalleboo 7y ago> I hope some day there's a 'sane' option for people who just want good performance, good security for home use cases That used to be the Apple AirPort range... Personally I eventually just ended up getting the router at the big box store with the biggest numbers. And it worked out fine. I get a wireless iperf result of 900 Mbit while in the same room, 300+ out in the living room. No stability issues (even with flakey chinese IoT crap on there). No intrusive features. It seems like the luck of the draw with consumer brands though. http://www.aterm.jp/product/atermstation/product/warpstar/wg2600hp3/ http://www.aterm.jp/product/atermstation/product/warpstar/wg...