While I am in general rather critical of most methods employed by the US in recent years, in this case the situation is quite different. If you sign up for the

While I am in general rather critical of most methods employed by the US in recent years, in this case the situation is quite different. If you sign up for the US military and then as a soldier commit what may very well be seen as an act of treason, you can't really expect great treatment. Mind you, this is very, very different from what goes on in Guantanamo, for which there is no justification.