13 ms·
Canadian permafrost thaws 70 years earlier than predicted
- anigbrowl 7y agoThis is the associated paper, sorry for the paywall. https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1029/2019GL082187 https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1029/2019...
- sp332 7y agoAccording to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Representative_Concentration_Pathway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Representative_Concentration_P..., RCP 4.5 predicts a maximum of 2.6 degrees warming by 2100. But we're currently on pace to most likely hit 3.3 degrees by then, so it doesn't seem odd that we're ahead of that pace. https://climateactiontracker.org/global/cat-thermometer/ https://climateactiontracker.org/global/cat-thermometer/
- williesleg 7y agoAnd of course the mainstream media is hating on Tesla and solar energy. Cuomo won't even let them run in NY
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- challenger22 7y agoI see a screaming face in the article's top picture. A gaping maw of horror!
- pfisch 7y agoMaybe I don't understand the ramifications of this, but it kind of sounds like we missed the offramp where we just stop burning carbon. Shouldn't we just be moving to something drastic like a massive sun shade project ASAP?
- SketchySeaBeast 7y ago> Shouldn't we just be moving to something drastic like a massive sun shade project ASAP? Doesn't that particular option seem like it'd be adding on extra unknown consequences? I wonder how that'd effect our natural CO2 scrubbers.
- andromeduck 7y agoWe could have had nuclear but nope too scary!
- tasty_freeze 7y agoWe do have nuclear, and have had it for decades. Concerns about what to do with the waste are indeed an issue, but the bigger problems is nuclear hasn't been cost competitive with coal and more recently natural gas. It is complex trade-off and just blaming it on NIBMY sentiment is not really engaging the issue.
- FartyMcFarter 7y ago> We do have nuclear, and have had it for decades. Not enough. Some countries that had it even ran from it recently (like Germany).
- jjoonathan 7y agoIf we hadn't stopped building nuclear in the 80s and had merely kept up the pace, we'd be 50% nuclear (instead of 20%) today. If we had continued the accelerating pace, we'd be 100% nuclear. Today. Not in 2050, today. Compare to solar, which only recently broke the 1% mark. Nuclear has gone from very cost-competitive (5c/kWh) to not at all cost-competitive (alternatively: "financially risky," often shortened to "risky" in a disingenuous attempt to imply something else) because we gave NIMBYs and self-styled environmentalists a free pass to introduce arbitrary delays into the construction process, and they did, and it was very effective at raising the price / financial risk. That is what people mean when they say that we decided to stop building nuclear.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- tasty_freeze 7y agoPlease don't take this as snark -- I'm dead serious. There are climate change deniers who will point to this as support of their position. "See, those climate scientists' predictions are always wrong." The fact is the IPCC is well aware of the political headwinds it faces and its reports are conservative -- they have always underestimated the likely outcome because it is hard enough to get sign-off on even that, plus the consequences of overstating it is harmed credibility.
- ForHackernews 7y ago"The Adorable Optimism of the IPCC" - https://www.rifters.com/crawl/?p=8433 https://www.rifters.com/crawl/?p=8433 It’s been a couple of weeks now since the IPCC report came out. You know what it says. If the whole damn species pulls together in a concerted effort “without historical precedent”— if we start right now, and never let up on the throttle— we just might be able to swing the needle back from Catastrophe to mere Disaster. If we cut carbon emissions by half over the next decade, eliminate them entirely by 2050; if the species cuts its meat and dairy consumption by 90%; if we invent new unicorn technologies for sucking carbon back out of the atmosphere (or scale up extant prototype tech by a factor of two million in two years) — if we commit to these and other equally Herculean tasks, then we might just barely be able to keep global temperature from rising more than 1.5°C.[1] We’ll only lose 70-90% of the word’s remaining coral reefs (which are already down by about 50%, let’s not forget). Only 350 million more urban dwellers will be exposed to severe drought and “deadly heat” events. Only 130-140 million will be inundated. Global fire frequency will only increase by 38%. Fish stocks in low latitudes will be irreparably hammered, but it might be possible to save the higher-latitude populations. We’ll only lose a third of the permafrost. You get the idea. We have twelve years to show results.
- microcolonel 7y agoThey didn't actually say that, they said the thing that's in their report. They work hard on that, and paraphrasing it clumsily into millennial prose doesn't help anything.
- acqq 7y ago
- hodgesrm 7y agoI was up at Camp Muir on Mt. Rainier for the first time in 29 years last weekend. It's located at 10,000 feet and is surrounded by glaciers. The temperature was around 60F in the sun. We're getting temps in May/June that were rarely seen in August in previous decades. The impressive thing is how quickly the glaciers are receding. The Nisqually glacier, which used to be down near 4000 feet in the 1970s is about a mile shorter. The ablation boundaries on many of the glaciers appear to be high up the mountain (like around 12,000 feet), which means they are going to shrink quite a bit more. I didn't expect this but there's a possibility that many of the Mt. Rainier glaciers will be gone in the next 30 years. This is a massive change to ecosystems from sea level up to the highest peaks.
- pier25 7y agoConsidering climate lag (see below) it's almost certain most glaciers on Earth will be gone in 30 years. There is a delay of a couple of decades between emissions and effects on the climate. This means we are now seeing the effects from the emissions from the 70s and early 80s. The problem is that we have emitted more GHG in the last 40 years than the previous 150 years since the industrial revolution started. We have a huge climate bill to pay even if we magically stopped all emissions today.
- hodgesrm 7y agoThe glaciers on Cascade mountains are relatively small but on Mt. Rainier it's extremely unlikely they will disappear in 30 years. The Emmons and Tahoma for example are large and start at 14,000 feet. They will continue to have accumulation zones for many decades. Plus it takes a while for ice to melt even with heat waves, even at lower elevations and even if the temperature rise accelerates. That said it's not unreasonable to suggest that glaciers with an accumulation zone below say 8-9,000 feet will be toast. That takes out most glaciers in the Cascades outside of the volcanoes and a few peaks in the North Cascades. I was just eyeballing things based on having spent a lot of time on the mountain, but this conclusion seems to be supported by recent geological work. [1, 2] [1] https://gsa.confex.com/gsa/2017AM/webprogram/Paper299694.html https://gsa.confex.com/gsa/2017AM/webprogram/Paper299694.htm... [2] https://glaciers.nichols.edu/north-cascade-glacier-retreat/ https://glaciers.nichols.edu/north-cascade-glacier-retreat/
- theothermkn 7y agoThis phenomenon is curious, in a morbid sort of way. There is literally no way to stop it; we are, as Noam Chomsky fears, a lethal mutation. We developed the ability to create industrial and economic activity on such a scale, and with such sophistication, that we've overcome the planet's ability to cope, but we have no mechanism in place that seems remotely capable of remedying that situation without a global catastrophe of unimaginable scale. There are no brakes. There's nothing you can say to any leader, politician, or pleb that can shock them into action. CO2 at 400+ ppm? Shrug. Global temperature rise nearing the acceptable limit for 100 years from now happening in much less than half that time? Shrug. Permafrost melting 70 years ahead of schedule? Yawn. Not only is there no system in place that can fix this now, no system can arise that would have any hope of slowing it, or even slowing its acceleration. Get used to it. This isn't a movie. There are no heroes. You're all dead. And you have no idea.
- newsbinator 7y ago> There's nothing you can say to any leader, politician, or pleb that can shock them into action. Humans weren't designed to feel terror at numbers. Most leaders, politicians and plebs have thus far experienced the disaster as nice winters and slightly more news about tornados in tornado-prone places. You'll find people taking action only when the sky is falling (i.e. when it's too late to take action).
- crispinb 7y ago> there's nothing you can say to any leader, politician, or pleb that can shock them into action The notion that a bright ape, with social cognition designed for small group interaction, could scale its decision-making abilities to manage a global civilisation, was always a mere superstition.
- polyfractal 7y agoIt's especially tragic because any attempt to fix the situation implicitly crushes nations that are presently bootstrapping themselves into industrialization. E.g. major "developed" countries got a free ride on cheap, dirty fossil fuels. But now the climate is going to shit, and if by some miracle they managed to get themselves to carbon-negative (lol sure), you'd also have to prevent other developing nations from going down the cheap/dirty fossil fuel route themselves. Which is crazy when you think about it. How's that going to work? Is the US and the EU going to give up half their GDP subsidizing clean energy in foreign nations to prevent further carbon release? Subjugate those countries to forcibly prevent them from industrializing? It's truly a tragedy of the commons writ large. Short of some breakthrough in carbon sequestration or cold fusion or whatever, we're pretty screwed no matter how you look at it :(
- ngngngng 7y ago[Deleting because I don't want to perpetuate apparently debunked climate change myths, sorry, I honestly hadn't seen it debunked.] Dang, my most downvoted comment was asking an honest question about climate change.
- simmer 7y agoVariability in the sun’s output has long been accounted for in climate modeling.
- mikeash 7y agoIf you aren’t a denier then why are you repeating a classic, thoroughly debunked denier talking point? https://skepticalscience.com/global-warming-on-mars.htm https://skepticalscience.com/global-warming-on-mars.htm
- archey1 7y agoMaybe they honestly didn't know? Hell, I didn't even know about global warming on Mars until OPs comment..
- mikeash 7y agoIt’s possible, but beyond a certain point it becomes difficult to extend the benefit of the doubt.
- ngngngng 7y agoGreat write-up, I really appreciate it. Don't worry, I won't ask any more honest questions about climate change ever again.
- ska 7y agoI don't mean this in a snarky way at all; if you are interested it is easy enough to educate yourself on the basics. "Read first, question later" is a good approach to this sort of thing, really, as it isn't asking for other peoples effort on the easy stuff.
- magwa101 7y agoWe'll adapt, but the global ecosystem is dying. It'll be cows, cats, dogs, pigs, chickens, us and stories of animals.
- HugoDaniel 7y agoYeah we will adapt, but not fast enough.
- 734129837261 7y agoWe will. We always do. There is no reason to assume we won't. The wealthy westerners will not notice because of air conditioning and endless bottled water. The less wealthy ones will suffer the heat a bit more. The poor ones will be taken care of. Third world nations will suffer. Some might die. Maybe many. But humanity will adapt. We might lose a few hundred million in the next few decades until their folks find new places to live, and we westerners will suffer an influx of refugees, and we'll be just fine once again. The population of the planet will continue growing to about 20 billion during the worst of the climate change. And we'll be without ice caps. And we'll be fine.
- bdamm 7y agoWe'll be "fine" if you consider endless resource-based regional conflicts, along with the political upheaval, mass starvation, boosted extremism, and the large scale conflicts that will arise as a result, "fine". We'll be "fine" in the sense that "some human DNA will still be operating in 1000 years". That is a very low bar for human achievement to aim for, and for my children's sake, I hope we do better than that.
- HelloMcFly 7y agoThis is perhaps the worst, most hubris-filled comment I've ever read on this site. That's not hyperbole, I mean that literally. It is this certainty that fills me with despair for the future. Forgive me if I'm not willing to get into a lengthy debate on the merits of your comment, if that's your starting point then it's hard to believe it's worth the effort.
- Fede_V 7y agoGlobal warming is the single scariest existential threat our species has ever faced, and we aren't doing nearly enough to tackle it. Our future descendants will heap scorn and curses on our generation, and we deserve every bit of it. Every politician that refuses to do what is necessary or finds it convenient to play stupid language games about 'settled science' is doing incalculable harm. As citizens, I encourage everyone to reducing their carbon footprint as much as possible (yes, that means that your life gets comfortable) and voting exclusively on how credible a politician is on tackling global warming. If you are a wealthy person and aren't buying carbon offsets for all your emissions, you are a bad person.
- hi5eyes 7y agowe were doomed and fucked by the 80s been reading into deep adaptation lately, kinda cool kinda pointless
- graeme 7y agoHalf of co2 emissions have happened since then. Emissions are at the highest they've ever been. We, presently, are deciding to do this and continue it.
- hi5eyes 7y agothere are locked in cycles that are going to cause 2 degrees and more in warming regardless of if we stop emissions completely right this second. it only goes up every year nbd
- radicalbyte 7y agoWe're clearly going to have to so something to cool the planet down, but the transition to renewable energy is just so effective that you'd want to do it purely from the financial and health benefits.
- LinuxBender 7y agoI've seen a few sites that suggest much of this is based on our orbit [1]. If that is true, then the oceans may be about to dump ludicrous amounts of Co2. Hopefully we can find a way to turn that into fuel. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=milankovitch+cycles https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=milankovitch+cy...
- cabaalis 7y ago> The vista had dissolved into an undulating sea of hummocks - waist-high depressions and ponds known as thermokarst. Vegetation, once sparse, had begun to flourish in the shelter provided from the constant wind. I understand the threat. I'm curious why the change described above though isn't somewhat welcome. It would seem that--at least temporarily--areas that are habitable now will become inhospitable, while areas that are not habitable now will be more welcoming.
- Upvoter33 7y agohere's one reason: when you move north, the amount of sun you get during different times of the year changes a lot. Some crops won't naturally be able to move north.
- gbrown 7y agoIn short, corresponding methane emissions.
- twp 7y agoCrops grow in soil. Soil is not just land area. It has an entire history that made it the fertile earth that it is today. You don't get fertile earth by taking permafrost and warming it.
- bloopernova 7y agoI weep for the life my 19 year old stepdaughter will have.
- bdamm 7y agoCurrent 19 year olds have not much to worry about. Remember it's 2-4 deg C by the end of the century along with a sea level rise of perhaps 1m. It's her grandchildren that are truly going to suffer. Of course, nobody knows how long the current status quo can last in the face of climate change.
- anigbrowl 7y agoThis whole story is about melting permafrost that wasn't expected to that until close to the year 2100 but which is instead happening now. Evidence is accumulating that such things are happening faster than anticipated, perhaps considerably faster. Also, you're really not thinking even your own remarks through. If a person is 19 now, they could conceivably be alive by the end of the century.
- bloopernova 7y agoI think you are wildly incorrect, but I hope that you are right.
- cardamomo 7y agoThe oft-quoted opening of David Wallace-Wells's "The Uninhabitable Earth" comes to mind. Reviews have generally only included his first sentence: "It is worse, much worse, than you think." Here is his entire opening paragraph: > It is worse, much worse, than you think. The slowness of climate change is a fairy tale, perhaps as pernicious as the one that says it isn't happening at all, and comes to us bundled with several others in an anthology of comforting delusions: that global warming is an Arctic saga, unfolding remotely; that it is strictly a matter of sea level and coastlines, not an enveloping crisis sparing no place and leaving no life undeformed; that it is a crisis of the "natural" world, not the human one; that those two are distinct, and that we live today somehow outside or beyond or at the very least defended against nature, not inescapably within and literally overwhelmed by it; that wealth can be a shield against the ravages of warming; that the burning of fossil fuels is the price of continued economic growth; that growth, and the technology it produces, will allow us to engineer our way out of environmental disaster; that there is any analogue to the scale or scope of this threat, in the long span of human history, that might give us confidence in staring it down.
- overthemoon 7y agoCurious about what he means by "that wealth can be a shield against the ravages of warming". That is--I can see a case for the wealth of a nation not being a shield for every citizen, but I wonder whether the very rich could weather climate change for a long time. But I suppose that's not the same thing as being totally unaffected.
- graeme 7y agoWealth is a claim on the output of society. It's very hard to store wealth outside of society. Actual stored wealth: * precious metal and fossil fuels, etc * seeds, canned goods, grain reserves * Buildings, wells, physical infrastructure on the land * tools etc that last through time Money is only useful to the extent it can buy things. If civilization collapses, then that's a destruction of wealth. If output merely diminishes, that's also a destruction of wealth. It will still be better to be rich than to be poor, but even the rich depend on what society produces.
- akeck 7y agoHow reasonable is the Clathrate Gun hypothesis? https://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis https://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis
- baxtr 7y agoScary...
- NikkiA 7y agoIt's already happened, methane has been bubbling from the arctic seabed since 2012. Noone that can do anything cares. https://www.nasa.gov/topics/earth/features/earth20120422.html https://www.nasa.gov/topics/earth/features/earth20120422.htm...
- pier25 7y agoIt's already happening and every time they estimate how much methane is trapped in the ice and permafrost that number becomes bigger.
- perfunctory 7y ago> The team used a modified propeller plane to visit exceptionally remote sites, including an abandoned Cold War-era radar base more than 300 km from the nearest human settlement. > Diving through a lucky break in the clouds, Romanovsky and his colleagues said they were confronted with a landscape that was unrecognizable from the pristine Arctic terrain they had encountered during initial visits a decade or so earlier. Too bad we can't just use satellite images for this kind of research. Somehow satellite images are available for hedge funds to calculate the oil supply [0], but not for climate research. It's a shame. [0] https://www.wired.com/2015/03/orbital-insight/ https://www.wired.com/2015/03/orbital-insight/
- CapricornNoble 7y agoCanada, Siberia.....both of these areas have been relatively untouched/unexploited due to the permafrost issue and generally inhospitable weather. But they represent a HUGE portion of the global land area.... So why aren't we looking at climate change as opening up vast tracts of the northern hemisphere to settlement and exploitation?
- pas 7y agohttps://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis https://www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clathrate_gun_hypothesis
- UnFleshedOne 7y agoI'm sure there is a lot of land under permafrost, but make sure you are not unduly impressed by how it looks like on a mercator projection.
- CapricornNoble 7y agoCanada's three federal territories (Yukon, Nanuvut, Northwest Territory) have a total land area of 3,535,263 km^2 That's about 3x Texas + California combined. That's not even counting the northern half (give or take) of Canada's other provinces. Russia's Sakha Republic is ~3 million km2 by itself. If Sakha were a country of its own, it would still be in the Top10 by area (#8), just below India. It's not just how they look on a map, these are potentially hugely underutilized tracts of land. All I'm saying is instead of the constant doom-and-gloom prognostications, let's figure out how we can maximize the efficient utilization of this land that MIGHT actually benefit from improved accessibility under warmer conditions.
- ryanobjc 7y agoBecause the land sucks. It just sucks. Tundra when thawed isn't some magical land. It's all swamp basically. GOOD LUCK with 100' deep bogs all over the place!
- CapricornNoble 7y ago
- anigbrowl 7y agoRelevant: meltwater on sea ice in NW Greenland https://twitter.com/RasmusTonboe/status/1139504201615237120 https://twitter.com/RasmusTonboe/status/1139504201615237120 Also this Australian briefing document on the existential risks of climate change: https://docs.wixstatic.com/ugd/148cb0_b2c0c79dc4344b279bcf2365336ff23b.pdf https://docs.wixstatic.com/ugd/148cb0_b2c0c79dc4344b279bcf23... I'm a bit of a doomer on this topic but 25 years arguing about it doesn't seem to have yielded much action.
- thtthings 7y agoOur planet needs to be viewed as and felt as a living entity. There needs to be a shift so we care for every living entity. Every plant, animal, human. Our values need to shift from material pursuits and those as a benchmark for happiness and success to how we treat one another and also other living beings. Is there a website i can go to and check earth's health as a whole? Like we can check our own health. It would be good to have a place that lists our planets health against a bunch of vital signs
- jordanbeiber 7y agoI have my ideas that this is what we should use AI for - basically a technocracy where any decision is entered in to a computer that does the crunching. Degree of sustainability vs gain and have the computer say "no" if it's just not viable. If it says "yes" have a vote and let it be decided. Just dreaming.
- cwkoss 7y agoIt seems that global methane levels have been increasing drastically in the past decade, I wish more discussion of global warming focused on the effects of fracking and use of natural gas. https://www.methanelevels.org/ https://www.methanelevels.org/
- nosleeptill 7y agoIt's already too late. It's unfortunate that we didn't understand what was happening 100 years ago, if we did we might have been able to do something about it, but as it stands right now, we can't even slow down what's already been set into motion. The earth is now changing, it's not just the climate, and the earth changes will drive the climate, the feedback loop has started. Unless someone can invent a technology in the next 5 years to pull the excess greenhouse gases from the upper atmosphere and take us back to pre-1825 levels and keep us there going forward, this is a lost game. It's like standing on top of the Empire State building and watching a balling ball go over the edge, we are at the point where the majority of the ball's mass has gone past the balancing point. We are close enough to recognize that it's happening but too far away to stop it from falling.
- omegaworks 7y ago>It's already too late. The next stage of climate denialism is climate nihilism. It is not too late to mitigate some of the effects on our societies. At the very minimum we need the political will to reallocate resources so that we stop accelerating the process and start structuring safety nets for vulnerable communities.
- yeahitslikethat 7y agoPeople want to be ever more comfortable. Bigger houses. Faster cars. Newer phones. We've known this was coming since someone wrote a story about Adam and Eve over-consuming.
- fooblitzky 7y agoExactly right. Every tenth of a degree of warming averted is going to make a big difference to someone down the line.
- sowenjub 7y agoWe did understand a 100 years ago. Graham Bell was one of those who warned us.
- Roritharr 7y agoI'm still firmly in the camp of people that want to start serious Geoengineering to fix this. WW2 or higher level efforts can get humanity very far if we commit ourselves. My biggest question is though, what are the goals? How many Watts do we have to remove from the planet per day to effectively cool it. How much CO² would actually need to be removed? If the DoD would get the Job of fighting climate change, i'd wonder what they'd come up with.
- pier25 7y agoEveryone here is focused on reducing emissions and such but quite frankly this is only a small part of the problem. Let's assume today, right now, humanity has found a miracle to produce zero emissions. First let's consider climate lag [1]. There is a 40ish year delay between emissions and effects on the climate. So this means we are now only seeing the effects from the emissions from the late 70s early 80s. Here's the worst part, we have emitted more GHG in the last 40 years than the previous 150 before that. So, we have a huge climate bill coming for us. Second, carbon will remain in the atmosphere for thousands of years[3]. Nobody knows how that will affect the planet but it's not going to be good. Third. Consider self sustaining climatic systems usually called feedbacks like methane [2]. The hotter it is, the more methane is released to the atmosphere, so it becomes hotter, so there is more methane in the atmosphere, etc. There are dozens of climatic feedbacks which only god knows when those will stop. I'm not writing this in a defeatist tone. Quite the contrary. We need to fucking wake up to the reality of this crisis. Humanity has to go all-in and pour all possible resources into clean energy, energy storage, and carbon sequestration. [1] https://skepticalscience.com/Climate-Change-The-40-Year-Delay-Between-Cause-and-Effect.html https://skepticalscience.com/Climate-Change-The-40-Year-Dela... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change_feedback https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climate_change_feedback [3] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2012/jan/16/greenhouse-gases-remain-air https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2012/jan/16/greenhou...
- majewsky 7y ago> Nobody knows how [atmospheric carbon] will affect the planet but it's not going to be good for us. FTFY. Life on this planet is probably going to stick around. What happens to human civilization is the more interesting question.
- pier25 7y agoYeah, life will find a way, even if it's just fungus and microbes.
- snowwrestler 7y agoSeems like there could be a pretty big gap between "life on this planet is probably going to stick around" and "good." Life made it through the Chicxulub impact but I doubt you would have called it good had you been on Earth at that time. I'm continually surprised at how often people counter warnings about global warming with comments to the effect that life, in general, will go on. That's a low bar! Way lower than you'd accept in any other context of your life, I'd bet.
- emanuensis 7y agoA form of geoengineering is seeding Fe and P into appropriate places (good currents) of the ocean. This kickstarts aquatic life and removes carbon fast ... and as a by product creates whole new fisheries. It is fast and cheap enough that small countries and multimillionaires (and up) can do it as a DIY solution to climate change ... so why has this not been done, forcefully? There seems to be tremendous social opprobrium! A ~proof of concept has already been done. ~proof of concept https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/5/24/18273198/climate-change-russ-george-unilateral-geoengineering https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/5/24/18273198/climate...
- acqq 7y agoFrom the text: "George argues that the project succeeded at capturing carbon too. There’s no available evidence to back him up — it’s exceptionally difficult to measure the carbon captured by experiments like these, and the results from more carefully controlled experiments are not promising."
- emanuensis 7y agoi would be interested in what/where those "controlled experiments" were... my understanding is that even experimenting is a no no in the field of geoengineering. Versus reflective schemes this actually "removes" carbon and is thus is a net gain, not merely a partial temporary cover. It also increases biota -- exactly the opposite of what humans tend to do, we are now in a major extinction event. Increasing biota on land is very hard and unlikely, but this easily increases it in the seas where it is badly needed. It is also easily titrated - one can stop/in/de/crease adding Iron and Phosphorus at any time.
- acqq 7y ago> Versus reflective schemes this actually "removes" carbon and is thus is a net gain That is exactly what is not confirmed. It’s just a belief of the proponents.
- 7y ago
- gdubs 7y agoI'm not saying a carbon tax will alone solve the problem, but I also don't think we stand a chance without one. We could have started solving this problem decades ago, and it would have cost a lot less. Time's running out.
- grwthckrmstr 7y agoEarth is a living organism and human activities are it's cancer. We can repurpose ourselves in order to save ourselves and the host organism. Or kill ourselves and the host, just like cancer. It's a choice we have to make as a world together.