3 ms·
I don't have the real story, but there was a lot of cross-pollination between smalltalk and lisp. It can be challenging to determine which things originated wh
by aidenn0 7y ago
I don't have the real story, but there was a lot of cross-pollination between smalltalk and lisp. It can be challenging to determine which things originated where sometimes.
IMO a lot of it is just that all of the ingredients for a modern desktop were there for anyone with 10s of thousands of dollars of hardware, so there was both cross-pollination as well as parallel evolution of ideas.
The invention of the sewing machine is kind of like this; there was a point at which we were very close to being able to make a sewing machine, and several people solved a subset of the problems; the union of that subset gave us a sewing machine, so singling out a single inventor is somewhat non-sensical.
Most lisp machines were specifically targeted at developers while smalltalk at Xerox was more targeted at office productivity. Interestingly enough Xerox hired the BBN team that made lisp machines, and the Xerox star was made to run lisp as well.
- flavio81 7y ago>I don't have the real story, but there was a lot of cross-pollination between smalltalk and lisp. Smalltalk was influenced by Lisp, and in turn, Smalltalk influenced the subsequent Lisp systems; that's where OOP support appeared in Lisp, first with LOOPS and MIT Flavors, ultimately with CLOS on ANSI Common Lisp. Common Lisp also is "image-based development", just like Smalltalk. This is a direct ST influence.
- lispm 7y ago> Common Lisp also is "image-based development", just like Smalltalk. This is a direct ST influence. Lisp from the early 60s used already images. It went from there to Smalltalk.
- flavio81 7y agoOops... I believe you, but, do you have some reference? I would assume this came after Lisp 1.5, right?
- lispm 7y agoLisp 1 in 1960. http://bitsavers.org/pdf/mit/rle_lisp/LISP_I_Programmers_Manual_Mar60.pdf http://bitsavers.org/pdf/mit/rle_lisp/LISP_I_Programmers_Man... Page 66f: SET card writes a memory image to a tape and TST card reads a memory image from tape.
- lispm 7y ago> Most lisp machines were specifically targeted at developers A bunch of Lisp Machines were directed at production, not developers. From Symbolics there were special models for that and also smaller "delivery system" versions of the operating system. For example American Express had a bunch of Lisp Machines as checking complex credit card transaction, Lucent had Lisp Machine nodes in a network switch, NASA had Lisp Machines monitoring video camera streams of rockets from Space Shuttle launches, Symbolics sold many graphics systems to TV studios, etc. > while smalltalk at Xerox was more targeted at office productivity. Is that true? Xerox had an office system running on the same hardware, but written in Mesa - unrelated to Smalltalk. Xerox had the CIA as a main customer for the Smalltalk machines, using an application called 'Analyst'... https://ethw.org/Oral-History:Adele_Goldberg https://ethw.org/Oral-History:Adele_Goldberg 'But our big commercial involvement was with the CIA.' > Interestingly enough Xerox hired the BBN team that made lisp machines, and the Xerox star was made to run lisp as well. BBN made a Lisp in the 60s, from where some developers went to Xerox in 1972/73. Before Lisp Machines existed. BBN Lisp was renamed Interlisp and was supported by both companies. Xerox developed Interlisp-D for Lisp Machines and BBN put Interlisp on an internal research computer.