5 ms·
I wasn't aware the Soviet Union allowed rich investors to buy up chunks of the housing supply and rent them out as hotels without a business license, while also
by rchaud 7y ago
I wasn't aware the Soviet Union allowed rich investors to buy up chunks of the housing supply and rent them out as hotels without a business license, while also bypassing the numerous regulations that hotels have to abide by.
- dgellow 7y agoIf you’re talking about Airbnb, as far as I know what you’re describing is not allowed in Berlin.
- rchaud 7y agoThe ban was lifted in May 2018: https://www.citylab.com/life/2018/03/berlin-airbnb-vacation-rental-regulation-law/556397/ https://www.citylab.com/life/2018/03/berlin-airbnb-vacation-...
- dgellow 7y agoInteresting, thank you for the information. Though, from your link: > It nonetheless imposes some pretty firm conditions on vacation rentals and makes the penalties for ignoring them far more stringent. All landlords seeking to rent out their home will only be allowed to do so if they get a general permit from their borough, even if they intend only to rent their property out for occasional short stays. While landlords applying for a permit at their primary residency will likely be approved, second home owners may face a more rigorous process. Landlords who leave an apartment untenanted, meanwhile, will need a special permit from the borough to do so after three months of vacancy without having a permanent tenant registered, cutting the current vacancy grace period in half. Most strikingly, the maximum penalty for breaking the rules has been multiplied by five, to a potential fine of €500,000 ($617,000).
- jupp0r 7y agoNo, they just declared housing to be affordable (in the $20/month ballpark region) and people had to apply 10 years in advance to move to a larger apartment. This is my parent's experience in east Germany, should be similar to Soviet Union.
- vtail 7y agoIt was! Also, in early 1990s we had food shortages and long lines in stores for basically everything (in Moscow! things were much worse in the regions), which was a direct result of the government controlling the economy for many years through directives and completely ignoring the basic laws of economy. Sadly, the examples of economies of Soviet Union, and Cuba, and Venezuela, and North Korea etc. are somehow not sufficient enough for people to realize the danger of such control.
- jupp0r 7y agoExactly, it was really good if you happened to live in an appropriate apartment already, but was an absolute nightmare if you wanted to move. The same will happen (to a much lesser extent) in Berlin now.
- 2tab 7y agoThe curios thing about these anecdotes is that as dysfunctional as somewhere like the Soviet Union was, getting a affordable apartment in only 10 years would be a great deal for many today. In many metro areas property values have increased more the savings from the median income, meaning that the application, or aspiration, of the majority of people is going in reverse.
- andrewmutz 7y agoIt would be a shame to have to pass on any job that required relocation for 10 years.
- atemerev 7y agoThe apartment was subsidized, but not free. Unless you were a part of Nomenklatura (the ruling class government officials), you could probably hope for a 40 sq.m (430 feet) apartment somewhere in Khruschyovka (a poorly built 5 floors block housing) at the outskirts of your city. After 15 years of hard work. Perhaps it is better than nothing, however, living in Soviet Union's surrealistic "economy" was not worth that.
- 7y ago
- ashtonian 7y agoEven if it was sooooo what? people are able to leverage the property and earn more money on it, because it's worth more because somebody is going to pay it. Of course they are going to do that one way or another despite regulation. And they should they are creating more for the economy. If you can't afford to live/work somewhere that's life ? Why on Earth should somebody else subsidize your costs to live there. That being said I'm sure there are some anti competitive laws/regulations creating problems but the solution is not more bad regulations.
- krastanov 7y agoThat logic leads to monopolies or oligarchies or corporations/rich people "owning" the democracy. Those with resources can easily stop those without resources from ever competing with them in a free market, unless there are regulations.
- baddox 7y agoIf that is the problem, could it be that regulating that would be a better solution?
- jaredklewis 7y agoWell, if that’s the issue, as a non German who doesn’t understand the situation or surrounding political environment very well, wouldn’t a much better solution then be to crack down on illegal hotel businesses? Seems like this law is only going to make things worse: the rent freeze will make renting even less appealing to owners, only increasing their desire to run their property as a hotel. No?
- galvin 7y agoRent seeking behaviour causes prices to rise making the market inaccessible to homebuyers. Making property less attractive as an investment should help curb this tendency.
- bubblewrap 7y agoPeople being willing to pay high prices to live in Berlin is what causes prices to rise. It has been a popular place to live in for a while. Rent freeze will limit available housing and lower the quality of it.
- jaredklewis 7y agoSure that argument makes some sense, but my comment was in response to the claim that the main issue is illegal hotel businesses. If that is the case, If don't see how this law can't make that problem worse. If it is attractive to investors to run illegal hotels now, it will only become more attractive to do so once they are unable to raise rents on normal tenants.
- odiroot 7y ago> crack down on illegal hotel businesses? They have already done it and recovered less than 3000 flats. Again, illegal hotels are not a real problem in this city.
- odiroot 7y agoThis is not a real problem in Berlin, not at any scale that it matters. Berlin receives 30.000+ new people every year and builds only ~1/3 of the necessary flats. It just cannot work this way.