2 ms·
Thanks for looking at it. :) My experience thus far is using a (somewhat modified) Shapeoko 3, so personally I only have a very basic practical understanding o
by justinclift 7y ago
Thanks for looking at it. :)
My experience thus far is using a (somewhat modified) Shapeoko 3, so personally I only have a very basic practical understanding of using fixtures.
Most of my stuff was cutting MDF, for engineering prototypes though. Haven't done much with alum or anything tougher (yet), thus the limited fixturing experience. ;)
> It's an interesting project. If the market is large enough it might make sense for someone to pay for the design and fabrication of the tooling to offer these parts at a lower price.
Yeah, similar thought. They look to have added a forum (without any posts yet):
https://opensourceleg.com/forums/forum/ankle-knee-control-systems/ https://opensourceleg.com/forums/forum/ankle-knee-control-sy...
Asking the above there (eg have they considered potential changes to reduce manufacturing cost?), would probably get it in front of the right people.
Any interest in pinging them? If not, I'll can do it and share the response (etc). :)
- justinclift 7y agoPinged them manually via email, as their forums don't have a functional log in yet (being working on apparently). Discussion around improving the manufacturability seem welcome: :) ********************************************** We'd definitely love to have some DFM help! You're right that we weren't really thinking too much about that when we designed it; mostly, we wanted it to be as lightweight and high performance as possible. But it'd be great to have you or others help on the DFM side of things, especially if you're more familiar with how exactly machining costs are calculated, and what steps / features can be modified for the greatest improvement in cost. -Elliott Elliott J Rouse PhD Assistant Professor Director, Neurobionics Lab Department of Mechanical Engineering Core Faculty, Robotics Institute University of Michigan **********************************************
- justinclift 7y agoTheir forum is working now: https://opensourceleg.com/forums/topic/reducing-the-cost-of-manufacturing-for-the-mechanical-structure/ https://opensourceleg.com/forums/topic/reducing-the-cost-of-...
- robomartin 7y agoJust posted offering to help.
- robomartin 7y agoBeing that it sounds like a worthwhile project I can see about getting involved in some manner. I have to take a look at the models in greater detail and think about it a bit. My general thinking at the moment is that the design might have to undergo substantial changes in order to optimize for manufacturing cost. This is also one of the reasons for which you don't jump into making production tooling right away, you have to go through a few iterations before you actually know what you want to build in quantity, even if that is a few dozen units. A smart approach would create "production safe" tooling, meaning, tooling that can adapt to a reasonable degree to design changes without requiring completely new tooling design. This process requires close communication between design and manufacturing. I'll visit their forum as soon as I have some time to dig in. Regarding machines like Shapeoko. These are very nice and make a lot of sense for the right type of work. We have Haas CNC equipment. Once you start to worry about tolerances, finish, speed, repeatability and other factors there is no substitute for 7,000 lbs of industry-standard machinery.
- justinclift 7y ago> Regarding machines like Shapeoko. These are very nice and make a lot of sense for the right type of work. Once you start to worry about tolerances, finish, speed, repeatability and other factors there is no substitute for 7,000 lbs of industry-standard machinery. Oh no doubt at all. My PoV there is that a person with adequate clue can upgrade and calibrate a Shapeoko3 to be suitable for projects like this. Would it take tonnes of time and effort... sure. Would it be a production run...? Super unlikely. :) It's the kind of thing that - for a project like this - you'd do it for an amputee friend, relative, etc. eg doable, with the right motivation
- robomartin 7y agoI have to admit not having any time on a Shapeoko (or any other tabletop router for that matter). I've always had access to manual or CNC industrial grade machines. I've seen some impressive work done on Shapeoko and other small machines. While this is possible, the issues are always the same: tolerances, repeatability, finish and tooling. Without the mass to dampen vibrations it is impossible to produce smooth and accurate cuts. It is enough that aluminum is like rubber at cutting pressures. Now we add a machine with a structure, materials and mechanics that can visibly deflect a few thousands with finger pressure and the end result is predictable. That's not to say they are not useful. They are. Definitely. For the right kind of part and project they are fantastic. At $1,000 to $2,000 they are hard to beat. Frankly, the right way to use something like a Shapeoko for a project like this is to design the parts for the process. In other words, knowing about the limitations of the machine, design parts that will fit these constraints in the first place. That said, a machine like this is a million times better than a Shapeoko could ever be, no matter how much it might be modified. https://www.ebay.com/itm/LAGUN-FTV-1-VERTICAL-KNEE-MILL-w-Allen-Bradley-CNC-Control-42-x9-Table/143227630306?hash=item21590832e2:g:LEkAAOSwpWRcwN~T https://www.ebay.com/itm/LAGUN-FTV-1-VERTICAL-KNEE-MILL-w-Al... I owned several similar machines --all purchased used for $1,500 to about $5,000 max-- before I could afford to buy my first $100K VMC (vertical machining center). These "knee mills" as they are known, can make quality parts all day long with accuracy and excellent finish. They can make nearly anything you care to throw at them. I still have one today (sometimes it's easier to work on a part on one of these than to fire-up a large machine for a few cuts). They also fit very well in a garage workshop.