5 ms·
I think it's better if people make their own portraits with their ideas.
by pg 18y ago
I think it's better if people make their own portraits with their ideas.
- epi0Bauqu 18y agoThat's exactly the problem I am describing. They are making their own portraits, but they aren't sticking to their usernames, at least for me. A visual icon would help. It could be small, 25x25 as someone suggested.
- Alex3917 18y agoEven if you were to add pictures, the place to do it would be on the user's profile page and not next to the posts.
- epi0Bauqu 18y agoI disagree, but that would certainly be a good start. I disagree because then I would have to click each time to see it, and that is an extra step. With some small icon on the page, I'd develop the history in an osmosis-like manner.
- andreyf 18y ago25x25 is pretty big. I think it would be clever to make it 15x15 or 10x10...
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- jgrahamc 18y agoHow about just 1x1? Using the standard RGB color space there are 16,777,216. I doubt HN will have that many users so everyone gets their own color :-)
- boredguy8 18y ago...or 10 x 1. Even with only 32 colors per pixel, that's over a quadrillion color combinations.
- noahlt 18y agoI think pg's "portrait" was a metaphor.
- epi0Bauqu 18y agoOf course it was a metaphor, and I continued it. I wasn't being literal. I'm saying if you did look at the set of comments of a person, you would see the "portrait." But that isn't happening, since at least in my mind, over time that set of comments isn't being associated with that username.
- stcredzero 18y agoMaybe you could write a Greasemonkey script? You could have randomly generated avatars like Miis. Then you could also assign an image for specific posters that you feel are better indicative of their personalities.
- epi0Bauqu 18y agoWhere would you get the images? Just generate them randomly?
- petercooper 18y agoIdenticons: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identicon http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identicon
- rplevy 18y agoThe only problem with identicons I have seen is that the algorithm used causes a majority of them to look like swastikas. But that seems like an easy thing to fix. Most of the identicons are quite pretty (including a large number of swastikas), but most people still associate swastikas with naziism.
- petercooper 18y agoSwastikas aside, I don't personally feel they're a good solution. They can be useful in semi-anonymous situations to determine one person from another (or an impostor posing as someone else), but I don't find them even vaguely recognizable from one another in the most case. They're very easily confusable.
- bct 18y agoNot only did the Nazis ruin an ancient symbol, they ruined rotational symmetry.
- stcredzero 18y ago
- kashif 18y agoI agree. I think we can all give links to our blogs, or make a community on facebook. Actually, I am just going to do that and submit a link for those who are interested.
- epi0Bauqu 18y agoThen why have usernames (displayed) at all? Why is a picture so different than a username in terms of degrading the painting of a "portrait" of ideas? You could drop them altogether or replace them with a random string (generated each page view).
- jcl 18y agoThe way the user names are colored, it looks like we barely have them at all: The post text is in black, and the other information is in gray. I frequently find myself reading the text before I read who wrote it... which I think is just fine. It sends the message that the content is more important than the poster.
- justindz 18y agoLeaving usernames out entirely would make it harder to gain reputation which would probably reduce the amount of incoming content. The reputation aspect tied to a name, the cult of personality, is part of what keeps this thing churning. Imagine watching the NBA on TV with no names on the jerseys and all the faces blurred out. Writing style without names would be (in some but not all cases) like trying to identify players by their shoes, tattoos or morphology (read: mostly freakish tallness).
- whacked_new 18y agoThis is an interesting observation. I don't watch basketball, but usually when I watch sports, I watch for skill, and don't really care who is performing it. If you see a brilliant shot it doesn't matter who did it, so the names and faces might as well be blurred out. That it would be unpleasant to the watcher if the names and faces were blurred out, implies that the celebrity nature of the activity holds much importance. Haha, just saying, FWIW, because your comment was interesting.
- simen 18y agoI can't remember who, but someone observed that (according to them) the reason people will emotionally invest in teams, players, artists etc., instead of just cheering for whoever performs best at any given time, is that they like to bet something. There's a risk if you have a favorite team or player and they might lose, because then you lose: so, there's some excitement to be had not just over the play but also the ultimate result. How this relates to the present topic I don't know; hell, I'm not even sure this hypothesis is correct. I just think it's interesting.