3 ms·

I can see a use case. I'm Whatsapp-ing my son who is a student, and he tells me he needs money. A button pops up onto the screen saying "Give Michael $50". I

by abraae 7y ago

I can see a use case. I'm Whatsapp-ing my son who is a student, and he tells me he needs money. A button pops up onto the screen saying "Give Michael $50". I click the button and the transaction is done. With our marketing hats on we like to talk about what we can do with "one click". I've personally never seen a one click system in my life - this could actually be one, and for one of the most fundamental and valuable human activities - paying someone.

srfilipek 7y ago
> A button pops up onto the screen saying "Give Michael $50". You don't need a cryptocurrency for that...
- abraae 7y ago
  Nope you don't, it's just a tool allowing the world's biggest Bank ever to open its doors.
jshaqaw 7y ago
Don’t we already have Venmo for this?
- TheHypnotist 7y ago
  Yes - but as far as I know you would have to go into the Venmo app, and I think that's the difference. Quick Edit - I think Apple Pay can function this way via FB messenger?
  - dfischer 7y ago
    You can do this today in both messenger and messages yeah.
scrawfor 7y ago
I'm sure there is a market for that functionality. But is it something you'd really want? Would there be limits on how much you could request from someone? Would bots spam everyone on earth requesting $50? Do you have to maintain a list of who can and cannot request money from you? It just seems like there would be a lot of headaches with that system.
- abraae 7y ago
  > Would there be limits on how much you could request from someone? Why? Are there limits on accessing your own bank accounts IRL? > Would bots spam everyone on earth requesting $50? No. Facebook would not allow that to happen. They control their user base with a tight fist when it affects their own revenue (user privacy less so). > Do you have to maintain a list of who can and cannot request money from you? It just seems like there would be a lot of headaches with that system. Why bother? Yes it could be uncool behaviour to request money from people, especially if the request had some social pressure around it. But people can (and do) already behave in uncool ways on Facebook and the world goes on. The potential revenue from being a money pipe would motivate Facebook to effectively deal with all of these problems.

by abraae 7y ago

srfilipek 7y ago

> A button pops up onto the screen saying "Give Michael $50". You don't need a cryptocurrency for that...

abraae 7y ago
Nope you don't, it's just a tool allowing the world's biggest Bank ever to open its doors.

jshaqaw 7y ago

Don’t we already have Venmo for this?

TheHypnotist 7y ago
Yes - but as far as I know you would have to go into the Venmo app, and I think that's the difference. Quick Edit - I think Apple Pay can function this way via FB messenger?
- dfischer 7y ago
  You can do this today in both messenger and messages yeah.

scrawfor 7y ago

I'm sure there is a market for that functionality. But is it something you'd really want? Would there be limits on how much you could request from someone? Would bots spam everyone on earth requesting $50? Do you have to maintain a list of who can and cannot request money from you? It just seems like there would be a lot of headaches with that system.

abraae 7y ago
> Would there be limits on how much you could request from someone? Why? Are there limits on accessing your own bank accounts IRL? > Would bots spam everyone on earth requesting $50? No. Facebook would not allow that to happen. They control their user base with a tight fist when it affects their own revenue (user privacy less so). > Do you have to maintain a list of who can and cannot request money from you? It just seems like there would be a lot of headaches with that system. Why bother? Yes it could be uncool behaviour to request money from people, especially if the request had some social pressure around it. But people can (and do) already behave in uncool ways on Facebook and the world goes on. The potential revenue from being a money pipe would motivate Facebook to effectively deal with all of these problems.