3 ms·
That is interesting. But I wonder how the model would be affected by, say, the mass availability of a significant longevity increase, brought about by some sor
by Nursie 7y ago
That is interesting.
But I wonder how the model would be affected by, say, the mass availability of a significant longevity increase, brought about by some sort of medical breakthrough?
- IAmEveryone 7y agoSince people would presumably not use that extra time to have more children (they aren’t time-limited now), the result would just be a linear increase in population. The important part here is the change from the exponential models of Malthus etc.
- jacquesm 7y ago> they aren’t time-limited now They mostly are actually. Barring the occasional exception there is a definite 20-40 or so age band where most females that have children will have them. This is in part because of society and custom and in part for very valid medical reasons, the chances of children having birth defects go up quite fast past the age of 35.
- tntn 7y agoI think that 'IAmEveryone likely means that people aren't lifetime-limited. Most people aren't reproducing after 40, but expected lifespan is much more than that so even if it doubled there wouldn't be more children.
- jacquesm 7y agoThere are several factors here: the age at which people realistically will still want children and the fact that they themselves will simply be alive for a longer time. Medical breakthroughs tend to affect the latter rather than the former more, though the fact that people live longer has an effect on the age at which they start with having children. In my grandparents generation it wasn't rare for 19 year olds to be married and to have their first child on the way, my parents generation had their children when approaching 30 (on average), and the present day generation has their first child later still. There is some correlation here with education levels and of course from country to country there are still huge differences but overall those seem to be the trends. So a significant longevity increase brought about by a medical breakthrough will likely cause people to have their children at an even later age (with all the associated risks, possibly resulting in much more screening), somewhat offsetting the effect of those people themselves being alive for longer. Social security would be a real problem, especially if the time that people could work productively would not increase at the same rate as the longevity.
- JulianMorrison 7y agoThat depends on the kind of longevity. - If it's "stay old longer" then yeah, that's a problem (most of our present advances are this since they don't address ageing, just save people from its consequences). - If it's "stay young longer (or indefinitely)" that will change a lot of assumptions. But it might also make people put off children until really late, like, "if you're less than 100 why are you even considering being a parent?"
- jacquesm 7y agoStay young longer is SF, stay old longer is already happening.
- pferde 7y ago"Stay young longer" is healthy lifestyle and a bit of personal responsibility.
- JulianMorrison 7y agoBasically the problem of ageing is a gradual accumulation of "damage" of assorted kinds. An ideal regimen of exercise and diet and non-stressful life and so forth can reduce the rate but not to zero. Thus, even healthy people get old and die. Actual therapies would go in and undo the damage, not stop it accumulating, but clean the existing damage down to a level where ageing symptoms would be reset back by decades. And could be repeated, leading to indefinite lifespans.
- pferde 7y agoYes, of course, I agree with you. However, the quote I was replying to had the word "longer", and not the word "forever" in it. And that's exactly what healthy lifestyle gives you - not miracles, but a definite increase in quality of life, and prolongation of the active part of it. The downvotes to my comment above amused me, there are apparently people in denial here. :)