9 ms·
Ireland to ban new petrol and diesel vehicles from 2030
- crististm 7y agoBureaucratic mandate of technology is probably an important step in making people think not just of themselves.
- ForHackernews 7y agoGood. Measures like this are finally starting to approach the level of urgency required to have any realistic chance of averting the worst climate disasters. Obviously Ireland is a small country and won't have much impact alone, but at least it's dawning on some policymakers that this isn't a problem for "the next generation".
- fouronnes3 7y agoI agree this is good. But 11 years feels to long, I wish it were sooner. Remember this is only the sale, not usage.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoCars is but one small measure of their pretty comprehensive - and challenging - 2030 plan. Not sure they could go much quicker.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- oaiey 7y agoThat is something Germany should have done years ago. They have an industry to shift.
- martin_a 7y agoWon't happen. Automobile companies are so deep into our politicians, you sometimes see them looking out from the throat. For example the federal state of Niedersachsen has more than 20% of the shares of Volkswagen. They will not do anything that might harm VW.
- icebraining 7y agoIncreasingly, not switching to EVs will harm VW, regardless of what German states do.
- paganel 7y agoAfter Dieselgate VW has been the most committed major auto-maker when it comes to EVs, problem is there have been some hiccups [1] [1] https://www.consumeraffairs.com/news/audi-recalls-model-year-2019-e-trons-061719.html https://www.consumeraffairs.com/news/audi-recalls-model-year...
- agumonkey 7y agoGerman brands have acknowledged it a bit, enough to make some cars and try the mainstream market too. I know Porsche also made a version with gears so they can retain their high speed property.
- clouddrover 7y agoVolkswagen is investing 80 billion euros in EVs: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-volkswagen-electric-insight-idUSKCN1PV0K4 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-volkswagen-electric-insig...
- martin_a 7y agoYeah, but only lately. They should have started 10 years ago. Now it's probably too late. Not only for VW but all the others, too.
- clouddrover 7y ago
- Mrdarknezz 7y agoWon't really make any environmental difference since they'll have to produce more energy. Since germany utilizes gas and coal you will basically shift to that from petrol since they shutdown their nuclear power plant
- geff82 7y agoLast time I looked we are gradually shifting to completely renewable energies. It might yet take some time, but we will get there (hoping that we do not elect dumb politicians).
- Mrdarknezz 7y agoWell this wouldn't be a problem if you didn't shutdown your nuclear power plants. Now Germany is polluting more than ever.
- arpa 7y agoBut but but atomkraft, nein, danke. I swear, these people are exactly like PETA, exept they are dealing real damage to the planet.
- vk23 7y agoRadioactive waste is doing real damage to the planet. After decades of evaluation storage facilities germany has no option that is considered safe. We have a responsibility towards the following generations. This includes not warming the planet beyond no return and not polluting it with deadly waste. Both can be achieved with a shift towards renewable energy sources.
- Mrdarknezz 7y agoRenewable energy sources needs to be supported by power plants that can produce constantly. The only clean option is nuclear and hydro. Sweden has developed a safe storage which is used to stored used fuel.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoI suspect this is much easier for a government to demand when they don't have a car industry to support.
- StreamBright 7y agoFirst I think we need an offering that is at least as good as the original you are trying to replace. How long can the best electric car go with one charge? Germany is a bit bigger than Ireland and you might want to drive 600 km in one go. Not saying I do not agree with you I am just saying in certain cases we are not there yet. The other question is about electric cars: what is the source of energy? Germany owns 7 out of the biggest CO2 production facilities in Europe. https://www.statista.com/chart/17582/megatonnes-of-co2-equivalent-in-the-eu/ https://www.statista.com/chart/17582/megatonnes-of-co2-equiv...
- Paraesthetic 7y agoYay so we can switch to batteries that produce more carbon emissions in their production than the fuel the vehicle is spitting out. Ultimately just make the problem worse if you think about it.
- new299 7y agoDo you have a source? And are you saying that production of electric cars produces significantly more emissions than petrol?
- tristanperry 7y agohttps://www.greencarfuture.com/electric/2018/12/12/are-evs-harmful-for-environment.html#1-emissions-from-building-the-electric-car https://www.greencarfuture.com/electric/2018/12/12/are-evs-h... The actual production of an EV _can_ result in more emissions (along the whole supply chain) than petrol cars, yes. Although the vast majority of car manufacturers (and supply companies) are geared up for producing petrol cars and not EVs, so it's no real surprise that _right now_ electric cars aren't as efficient to build. The more that electric cars are produced, and the more that Li-ion/solid-state batteries are developed, the better the picture will be at the building stage.
- scandox 7y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_aspects_of_the_electric_car#Environmental_impact_of_manufacturing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_aspects_of_the_e... It appears to be quite a nuanced picture.
- tonyedgecombe 7y agoThat table is interesting, it looks like we get the same benefits from switching to PHEV as going to full electric. I've always been slightly sceptical about the claims, just because the costs are so high. If you assume money is a reasonable proxy for energy then the high acquisition costs imply more emissions.
- rottencupcakes 7y agoWhile I doubt this will go into effect, this is simply bad policy. The economic shocks that will accompany a hard ban make no sense when compared to the option of a gradual phase out (gradually increase fuel taxes? gradually increase taxes on the sale of new petrol vehicles?)
- icebraining 7y agoI think announcing a ban is part of a phase out policy. The problem with relying just on gradual mechanisms is the "boiling frog" effect acting against you. A drastic announcement spurs people out of complacency. By the time you get to the deadline, the ban might not even be needed.
- Reason077 7y agoThe ban is on new vehicles. ie: New vehicles sold after 2030 must be zero emission. Not that all existing petrol and diesel vehicles must suddenly be scrapped. Vehicles tend to last about 15 years, so even with a ban coming into effect in 2030, it'd likely be around 2045 before the vast majority of fossil burners are off the street. That's pretty gradual.
- Svip 7y agoGovernment investment in charging infrastructure, increasing fuel prices/registration fees on ICE vehicles, etc., those are approachable and realistic options, and things we can do right now. I personally believe, that come 2026, car manufacturers will sound the alarm, that they simply won't be able to produce enough EVs come 2030 to meet demand. The policy will then likely get postponed till 2040, and so on for a couple of decades.
- vixen99 7y agoYes. Some realism on the subject!
- bloak 7y agoAgreed. I'd tax the fuel, personally, because if you taxed the sale of "new" vehicles then people would soon find a way of getting vehicles that are practically but not officially "new".
- tomohawk 7y agoGentlemen! Start your virtue signalling! Seriously, though, have they even found enough proven reserves of cobalt to make enough batteries to do this?
- Dobbs 7y agoWhy is everything virtue signalling? Maybe these things are to force the conversation to shift. If it proves unteneable we can extend deadlines etc. These bans are causing companies to take non-ice vehicles more seriously. It is making cities think about public transport more seriously. I'm pretty sure at this point anyone who uses "virtue signalling" seriously should automatically written off, because it is basically saying "I don't like that you are doing something which may be positive".
- eeZah7Ux 7y agoThis "virtue signalling" BS is used to claim that extreme cynicism and selfishness is the expected human behavior and that any concern about the survival of humanity is seen as suspicious. An irrational and psychopathic talking point if you ask me, yet it's sad how its use often goes unnoticed.
- tomohawk 7y agoGive me a break, dude! We're talking about politicians making a law that is more than 10 years out. This is the very definition of virtue signalling. If battery powered cars were so awesome, the law would not be needed.
- Dobbs 7y agoThe world doesn't change overnight. To do things like transition ICE to Electric you have to take time to do allow companies to ramp up production, research, and put into place transition plans. ICE vehicles have lots of externalised costs. Costs that aren't payed by the manufacturer or the consumer. Gas taxes in theory can partially internalise the costs, but put the cost entirely on the consumer and little on the manufacturer. This is a push to internalise the costs at the source. Not virtue signaling. Again the entire idea of virtual signaling is bunk. It is getting mad at someone for doing anything positive. It is a mindless insult to attempt to invalidate your opponent.
- dev_north_east 7y agoYeah, not buying it until I see the plans on how they're going to increase the national grid to power this.
- Reason077 7y agoI'm not familiar with Ireland's grid, but if it's anything like Britain, there is already more than enough capacity to power a fully electric vehicle fleet, provided a significant portion of charging happens at off-peak times. This is something that has been studied in some depth in the UK: https://theenergyst.com/millions-electric-vehicles-sooner-predicted-no-sweat-says-national-grid/ https://theenergyst.com/millions-electric-vehicles-sooner-pr... https://www.nationalgrid.com/group/case-studies/electric-dreams-future-evs https://www.nationalgrid.com/group/case-studies/electric-dre...
- michaelt 7y agoThat's not what your links say. The first link says nine million electric vehicles might require 4GW or 8GW of extra generation capacity (depending on smart technology) But there are 38 million vehicles registered in the UK [1]; and even the optimistic 4GW is greater than the power output of the proposed Hinkley Point C nuclear reactor [2]. If 9 million vehicles need 4-8GW of generation capacity, 38 million would need 17-34GW, i.e. 6.5 to 13 nuclear power stations' worth (or the equivalent in wind or solar) [1] https://www.racfoundation.org/motoring-faqs/mobility#a1 https://www.racfoundation.org/motoring-faqs/mobility#a1 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinkley_Point_C_nuclear_power_station https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinkley_Point_C_nuclear_power_...
- Reason077 7y agoAll of the National Grid forecast scenarios assume >30M electric vehicles in 2050. You might be confusing the peak power demand (in GW) with the total energy consumption (measured in GWh/TWh). Clearly if everyone charged their vehicles at peak times there'd be problems meeting demand. But that's not the case: EV charging is a flexible demand, and with "smart" chargers and incentives in place to encourage off-peak/overnight charging, demand peaks can be managed. Here's the link to the full Future Energy Scenarios document where you can dig in to the figures in great detail: http://fes.nationalgrid.com/fes-document/ http://fes.nationalgrid.com/fes-document/
- boilsquid 7y agoThis is only a proposed policy, it is not a law, it hasn't even been voted on by parliament.
- jesusthatsgreat 7y agoAnd with elected representatives like this, I wouldn't be putting money on this becoming law any time soon: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f2e-gOeN3DM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f2e-gOeN3DM or if it does become law, expect it to become a rolling target that gets kicked down the road rather than a fixed one.
- rsynnott 7y agoThat's Danny Haely-Rae; he's an idiot, yes, but not in the ruling party and generally politically irrelevant. This agreement is government policy and will very likely become law.
- geff82 7y agoFor Ireland this makes total sense. It is a small country on an island, so 99% of the cars do not travel the distances we do in larger countries/continents. Almost every electric car in production in 2019 can cover any city pair in Ireland. Looks like a smart move to me.
- douglasfshearer 7y ago> "The weighted average trip distance is 9.4 miles. Vehicles owned by urban households averaged 8.5 miles and rural vehicles averaged 12.1 miles." [0] In the U.S, a considerably larger country than Ireland, greater-than-EV-range journeys are outliers. The same purchasing decisions that are applied to vehicle capacity will get applied to range. People don't own large vans for the once-in-a-decade they move house with all their furniture. Owning an EV that can do 200 miles might be the norm, but the regular journeys are <10% of that. [0] http://www.solarjourneyusa.com/EVdistanceAnalysis7.php http://www.solarjourneyusa.com/EVdistanceAnalysis7.php
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- wongarsu 7y agoAverage journeys are incredibly short, but also not really relevant. If I get a car that can only travel my mean trip distance, half of my trips can't be traveled without refueling during the trip. Even the 95th percentile, as analysed by the linked article, isn't very useful. A car covering 95% of trips still can't make 1/20 trips. The car needs to cover at least 99% of trips, making me refuel only during 1 out of 100 trips. Some people will even demand covering 99.9% of trips. The borders of an island simply cutting off the long tail of trip distances does a lot to reduce required range.
- erik_seaberg 7y agoIt's not the length of a single trip, it's total travel between chargers. Even if you're lucky enough to have a locked private garage, that might be a full day of commuting and errands.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ToddBonzalez 7y agoThe first thing which needs to change: "Coal and peat continue to be used for power generation. In 2017 coal and peat accounted for 49% of carbon emissions from electricity generation, despite only accounting for 19% of electricity generated.The result of this is that the carbon intensity of the Irish electricity was the fourth highest in the EU in 2016, despite all our progress on using renewable energy." https://www.seai.ie/resources/seai-statistics/key-statistics/electricity/ https://www.seai.ie/resources/seai-statistics/key-statistics...
- Arbalest 7y agoPeat? Seriously? Peat in Tasmania (Australia) is protected, because it occurs in national parks. This suggests it is a big deal for biodiversity. Yet apparently people are burning it for energy...
- arethuza 7y agoPeat is a reasonably common domestic fuel in parts of Ireland and Scotland - also the "peaty" taste in whisky traditionally comes from drying malted barley using peat fires. However, I agree that for a variety of reasons that peat should mostly be left where it is.
- smcl 7y agoIt is pretty polluting for the amount of energy you get out of it but I don't think it necessarily follows that because it occurs in national parks in Tasmania that it is important for biodiversity on the other side of the world in Ireland.
- ToddBonzalez 7y agoBogs can play a major role in capturing and storing carbon. I think it's safe to say that they play an important role in the ecosystem no matter which side of the planet they're on, and should remain unmolested.
- ocfnash 7y agoI'm Irish; many of us are ashamed of how we treat our bogs. We have tiny peat-burning power stations which: * Are extremely polluting * Destroy a unique ecosystem * Are loss-making all for the sake of "protecting" a few local jobs.
- badpun 7y agoI suspect a market for „used” imported cars with under 1000 miles will emerge to circumvent this law.
- Reason077 7y agoMost European countries will be working towards a ban around the same time, or shortly after. So there won't be a ready supply of such vehicles for Ireland to import. Besides, given the economic advantages of electric (especially if petrol taxes are gradually ramped up to discourage their use), there won't be much demand for combustion technology past 2030 anyway, except amongst vintage enthusiasts.
- badpun 7y agoDon’t we need to like more than double our current level of power production (+capacity of the power network) to be able to ditch ice cars? I wonder how more than doubling of the number of power plants is supposed to get funded. Is there some proposal that is grounded in technical and economical realities?
- Reason077 7y agoNo. In the UK it's around a 30% increase on current electricity demand by 2050 for a near-100% EV vehicle fleet. But as a significant portion of EV charging can be done off-peak/overnight, in terms of new generation capacity it's even less. This is something that has been studied in some depth by the UK's national grid: https://www.nationalgrid.com/group/case-studies/electric-dreams-future-evs https://www.nationalgrid.com/group/case-studies/electric-dre... https://theenergyst.com/millions-electric-vehicles-sooner-predicted-no-sweat-says-national-grid/ https://theenergyst.com/millions-electric-vehicles-sooner-pr...
- vetinari 7y agoWe also need to significantly upgrade transmission and distribution. That might be even more capital intensive, than building new production capacity.
- 7y ago
- PebblesHD 7y agoWhile I absolutely agree with the goal of reducing our species carbon production and associated impact on the environment, I have a more personal and selfish concern with these proposals. The only way I’m able to have a reasonably nice car with good handling and entertaining performance is by buying a used car from probably 10-15 years ago. The sorts of cars that have nice leather seats, a sunroof, maybe a v6 or smaller v8, think the 2004 Subaru Legacy. Given the rate of failure and failure modes inherent in current battery technology in things like Teslas and such this market simply wont exist leaving me with a choice between keeping a petrol powered nice car going with whatever tax and fuel increases are decided, or buying the absolute cheapest electric car available with whatever comforts, safety features and plain enjoyment I lose in the process just being part of the deal. I’m sort of disappointed that my personal hobby is going to disappear soon and what’s left for people like me will be the Hyundai i10 of electric cars forever more. I’d still prefer that to not having a planet to live on though...
- dev_north_east 7y agoPCPs for everyone! (joke, but seriously I think this is what they expect/want)
- hannob 7y ago> While I absolutely agree with the goal of reducing our species carbon production and associated impact on the environment, I have a more personal and selfish concern with these proposals. Congratulations for summarizing one of the main challenges of climate policy. Everyone's for it, except if it affects them personally.
- close04 7y agoThis is a real dilemma because it's not always about choice in any reasonable interpretation. Some people may need a car for their livelihood but simply cannot afford anything better than a polluting clunker. Sometimes it is about choices made unwittingly. Imagine people who buy an EV because they think it's the best way to do their part even if 99.999% of their usage fits perfectly for bicycle and public transport (increased efficiency + added benefits not strictly related to global warming). In the end everyone will draw the line sooner or later. The point is to drop the bar and making it easier for most to take action. But people who expect everyone to be able to do it (usually based on the "I did it so if you don't you're just selfish" thinking) aren't very reasonable.
- NeedMoreTea 7y agoI wonder how much was driven by them missing all their 2020 EU targets, and the prospect of ever bigger €??bn fines on the way to 2030 targets... Still, the whole plan is reasonably well thought out. They have considered that the need to retrofit most existing buildings to bring them to acceptable standards, they are suddenly keen on community heat and power, and that business will be reluctant participant and so on. Going from 30% to 70% renewable, and closing all coal and peat in ten years might be a challenge, but it's in the plan. A couple of glaring holes around plastic and agriculture, but a bloody good start.
- scirocco 7y agoHow about veteran cars?
- wongarsu 7y agoveteran cars are not new petrol or diesel vehicles, so they are not impacted.
- handelaar 7y agoArticle says the opposite. Cars without an NCT are not permitted on the roads, and they won't be able to get one any more.
- clouddrover 7y agoDo an electric conversion. Here are two examples: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-06-16/vintage-rolls-royce-converted-to-electric-vehicle/9869888 https://www.abc.net.au/news/2018-06-16/vintage-rolls-royce-c... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PREftlfZuXA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PREftlfZuXA
- scirocco 7y agoRather not be alive to see air-cooled, rear-flat-engine Porsche 911's from the 70s go electric
- clouddrover 7y agoIt'll happen eventually. Allow the Porsche Taycan to make up for it: https://www.automobilemag.com/news/2020-porsche-taycan-turbo-ev-electric-ride-review-photos/ https://www.automobilemag.com/news/2020-porsche-taycan-turbo...
- vr46 7y agoGood, and I'm also not sure that EVs are the answer anyway, because I don't think cars are the answer.
- mikorym 7y agoIs it just my misplaced optimism, or are many countries suddenly now 'aware' of our climate change issues?
- travisoneill1 7y agoThey are aware that a shift in the car market is happening. Therefore they can legislate that this thing that is already happening must happen and claim credit when it does.
- Proven 7y agoGenius move! This isn’t much different than budget deficits - create a mess now and let future generations deal with the problem. Effectively it’s nothing but a new tax.
- crististm 7y agoBureaucratic banning of technology is the beginning of the downfall of civilization.
- de_watcher 7y agoWell, those things stink. If you like smells then we maybe should unban the bureaucratically banned pooping on the streets.
- a_paddy 7y agoI appreciated when they banned lead pipes for water.
- crististm 7y agoI guess we have usable alternatives to lead pipes. For electric cars let's see where is the externalization of emissions.
- Gravityloss 7y agoIreland has some excellent wind resources. They already seem to have over 4 gigawatts of nameplate capacity.
- crististm 7y agoSo will China or India follow suite?
- m463 7y agoI can't help think Tesla instigated all this kind of stuff.