5 ms·
The Auto-Pilot iPad App
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoVery neat idea, but good luck with getting FAA approval. This will probably count for a whole new type of approach: an automated mostly-hands-free 0-0 landing. Even if it's just for an emergency, and even if you make all kinds of disclaimers and have folks sign all kinds of documents, you'd have better luck teaching monkeys to play in an orchestra than you'll have trying to use this legally in an airplane. Of course, you can always sell it and say it's for "demonstration purposes only" or some kind of silly shit like that. But still, anything to do with certificated airplanes has this crazy no-risk bar that makes it almost impossible to implement. There's a reason why planes work pretty much the same now as 50 years ago, even though technology has vastly changed. The industry and government regulators are almost (but not totally) impervious to change. Lots of lawyers filing lots of lawsuits for doctors who bent their Bonanzas have seen fit to that.
- spitfire 16y agoYou can legally test and use this on experimental-amateur built aircraft. Which is what Austins Lancair evo is.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- maigret 16y agoI agree with most of what you wrote here. One point I would like to add though is that there were massive amount of military investments that went into plane development during both world wars and the cold war, allowing complete new features. Also, it's not like no ones tries to bring new technologies on the market. But the number of planes sold is nowhere near the number of cars sold, for instance. So new investments are pretty risky. Look at the Dreamliner or the A380... Both delayed and still with major design issues. In the general aviation, a European motor maker introduced diesel motors for plane, which allows a much lower mileage, and an economic flight of even 2-props planes (see DA-42). There were so much technical issues that the company got bankrupt. It's not a compelling argument for new customers tempted to buy such a diesel plane. When you buy a plane, you don't want the company to go bankrupt in 3 years, so you take a Piper or a Cessna, even if these are massively inefficient. Finally, look at a C172 glass cockpit. The outside design may still be the same as it was 40 years ago (as is the motor, almost), but the cockpit is totally different, with brand modern software, complex GPS & autopilot capabilities, etc. Flying has become quite different in the last 10 years because of that.
- aberkowitz 16y agoI don't see why this software is written on an iPad when it could be implemented more effectively in the plane's own control system.
- spitfire 16y agoYou don't get to run apps on the planes EFIS systems. They're sealed, controlled units for /very/ good reason. Aircraft aren't like hacking on some webapp, you don't move fast and break things. You test, test, validate, prove, test then finally ground test. Then test in parallel in the air. then expand envelope, only then do you get to think about relying on it.
- aberkowitz 16y ago> Aircraft aren't like hacking on some webapp Exactly, so why do you want to have an iPad control an airplane? Wouldn't it make sense to add this to the EFIS systems so that the code is held to the same standards as any other flight system? The fact that a device can link directly to the plane's control system will lead to numerous, potentially deadly exploits.
- Groxx 16y agoSeems like the fact that a device can link directly to the plane's control system has lead to a potentially-very-useful development that wouldn't be possible otherwise. What danger is there in allowing things to connect? There's plenty of advantages, from making your own specialized sensor displays to making autopilot algorithms, but what's the disadvantage?
- aaronsw 16y agoI prefer Otto: http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1290293/ http://www.imdb.com/name/nm1290293/
- cmelbye 16y agoFrom the App Store Review Guidelines, 4.2 Apps that use location-based APIs for automatic or autonomous control of vehicles, aircraft, or other devices will be rejected Hmm...
- X-Istence 16y agoBut if it connects to the aircraft, it could use the aircrafts instruments, at which point it doesn't use the location based API's :P
- tzs 16y agoFTA: "Using the airplane's onboard satellite navigation data, the software finds airports within gliding range, assessing distance, obstacles, runway lengths and other variables. It issues commands to the plane's ailerons, rudder and elevator to steer toward the best option".
- bjtitus 16y agoLet's be honest here. How many times is this really a concern? Why would the FAA approve use of something like this and why would I install it when the chance of use is probably extremely rare? Seems like too much trouble than it's worth.
- mhb 16y agoHe's counting on the few sales made when people are willing to pay $50,000 for the app.
- spitfire 16y agoHave you seen the cirrus aircraft? Unskilled, but rich people are willing to pay > $500K for a plane with a parachute and a button that auto-rights them. The result is a 6x fatality rate compared with the average for general aviation. That's including some horribly twitchy aircraft in that average.
- aaroneous 16y agoThe envelope that ballistic parachutes provide a life-saving emergency resolution vs a well executed power-off glide is pretty narrow. The studies show that far too often it is abused by providing a false sense of security, encouraging pilots to take risks they otherwise wouldn't have.
- spitfire 16y agoYup. It doesn't help that they use the parachute to sell to nervous but status conscious celebrities/generic-rich-guys. The cirrus is a terrifying plane[1], whenever I see one coming I run for my life. You should too. 1. In the hands of a trained pilot, flown for the long range missions it's designed for it's a fine plane. But 90% of the people buying these things aren't well trained, don't have the experience and don't do the sort of flying appropriate to the Cirrus.
- aaroneous 16y agoIf the pilot of a small airplane experiences a medical emergency that leaves him incapacitated, this sort of device could mean the difference between life and death for anyone else onboard the plane (assuming their not pilots as well).
- spitfire 16y agoAustin is the author of x-plane, an FAA certified flight sim. It's the only sim that actually calculates lift and drag available to consumers. MS flight sim is just a joke relying on rubber-band type lookup tables. If there's anyone who can do it, it's Austin. However, relying on the ipads gps and gyros seems like a poor choice. I wouldn't trust the ipad to have the necessary precision to pull off a landing. If you could interface the ipad with onboard GPS/gyro's then I'm all for it. The ipad has a plenty fast cpu for this sort of thing. But then so does a 286. or a PCjr for that matter.
- jrockway 16y agoI think the iPad's GPS is just to find a nearby waypoint as a starting point for the automatic approach and landing. Once you have decided upon a route, it's a simple matter of tuning the aircraft's nav radio to the VOR or ILS. From there, you have the full precision that you would normally have on an instrument approach/landing. The innovation is that the passenger doesn't have to know what an instrument approach is. (I wonder if the code on the iPad gets the audio stream from the radio so that it knows it's tuned to the right channel.) As an aside, I've read on the X-Plane forums that X-Plane doesn't actually do a full simulation as you say it does. If you try to spin the default C172, for example, you can't do it, because the aerodynamics near the boundary cases are not calculated correctly. (Either that, or the spin recovery for a C172 consists of letting go of the controls and waiting, which is not what the manual says. But I have not tried it.)
- aaroneous 16y agoX-Plane uses blade element theory - essentially it breaks various flying surfaces of an aircraft apart and calculates the forces on each one of those parts to simulate how it could react. Not perfect, but better than the MSFS approach.
- sokoloff 16y agoA 172 will recover from an upright (non-inverted, non-flat) spin by simply centering the flight controls and waiting. Anti-spin inputs (power idle, center controls, opposite rudder, elevator down) make the recovery much quicker, but I was taught (and shown) that if you don't know which rudder to use to stop the spin, to just center the controls and the 172 will stop spinning on its own. Disclaimer: I'm just a pilot and not a CFI; if you go spin one into a smoking crater following procedures other than the book, don't blame me, etc.
- gte910h 16y agoI think this is actually against the license of the iPad's OS I predict it may get pulled from the store.
- maigret 16y agoIf that product doesn't get certified, there's probably an opportunity to integrate that feature in existing glass cockpits. I mean, why not a "Land Safely" red button on the passenger board? The reliable autopilot/GPS/software is already here and certified, + then you don't need an iPad for it!