6 ms·
> One perhaps surprising trend is the excommunication of escalators, which were long considered luxurious amenities. “The idea of getting on escalators like you
by crazygringo 7y ago
> One perhaps surprising trend is the excommunication of escalators, which were long considered luxurious amenities. “The idea of getting on escalators like you did in the 1950s and ’60s is not happening,” said executive Bert Dezzutti of Brookfield Office Properties. “People desire to move around and be untethered. You’re not using lazy old escalators anymore.”
I never though about it before but that actually is a fascinating cultural shift.
White-collar workers today spend so much time sitting, and are so conscious of health and wanting to be active, that escalators aren't a luxury -- they're the antithesis of a healthy lifestyle.
If buildings necessarily express the values of the people in them, well values have changed. It's the age of Fitbit and walking around dense city centers and walking up stairs -- not being sedentary and driving and just standing on an escalator.
(While elevators are still mandated for disabilities, which escalators were never good for anyways.)
- steve19 7y agoI will belive that when I see workers walking up stairs, not just the type A's looking at their Apple Watch step counter, instead of escalators ;) I think its mostly landlords wanting to look like office buildings not retail space. YouTube is quite proud of the employee-only slide they have between two floors (might be gone, haven't visited in a couple of years)
- crazygringo 7y agoI think, like many fitness things, it's actually as much of a discipline thing as anything else. When we're confronted with an escalator next to stairs, we take the escalator out of laziness, even though we wish we didn't. But we'd actually prefer there not to be an escalator at all, so we'd have to walk. Same thing as when you choose not to keep snacks at your desk because you know you'll eat them. We prefer an environment that nudges us in the right direction, precisely because we don't always have the discipline we wish we had.
- clairity 7y agoi actually prefer a wide escalator so i can walk up/down (and around the standers) and get both speed and a workout. =)
- notauser 7y agoI live in London, where escalator lane discipline is very good - mostly because if you fail to stand on the right you will get jostled by 80kg of fast moving commuter. It's a culture shock going to places where people stand on both sides blocking the way through.
- patrick5415 7y agoGuess I must be a weirdo. Given a set of stairs next to an escalator, I always the stairs.
- cheerlessbog 7y agoI always do this, it typically happens at airports, and I take pleasure in arriving at the other end faster as well. I'm going to sit on a plane for hours why would I want to pass up the opportunity to get some meager exercise beforehand?
- icebraining 7y agoIf I'm going to sit in a cramped, poorly ventilated space, I'm doing everything in my power to avoid sweating beforehand, including taking the escalator.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- SenorSourdough 7y agoI also lean towards the stairs (or at least not just standing on the escalator), but in my experience it's like 80/20 or "worse" between people who go for the escalator vs the stairs. Of the escalator crowd though, there are a good chunk who prefer to walk rather than stand. Stairs are faster and better exercise than (standing on) escalators. I guess you can make the argument that walking up escalators is faster, but stairs are almost always wider and less congested, whereas getting stuck standing on an escalator happens all the time anywhere busy.
- _bxg1 7y agoYeah. To paint in broad strokes, the big cultural shifts from Boomers to Millennials seem to center around Boomers defining success and luxury very traditionally: maximizing ownership and indulgence, minimizing effort. Millennials have seen how unhealthy and wasteful those lifestyle choices are, and have largely freed themselves from the social pressures that drove them. Of course, all is relative. Millennials have invented their own type of shallow success-signaling (social media), excessive wealth signaling (focused on experiences - trips, food, etc. - instead of possessions), and avoidance of effort (delivery services and other gig-economy apps). Society changes, but people don't really change.
- kortilla 7y agoDelivery services and trips are indulgence and minimizing effort. The only noticeable difference between the two is the reduced focus on ownership, but that’s more likely related to the fact that millennials got screwed by the Great Recession more than them being oh so woke.
- caymanjim 7y agoThis anti-escalator movement sounds like complete nonsense to me. First of all, office buildings almost never have escalators. They never did, and they never will. When a company buys an old mall or movie theatre or something else that had an escalator, it doesn't surprise me that they might gut them and not replace them, but it's not because this generation doesn't want escalators. They didn't build escalators in offices in the 50s and 60s either. This is just retail space undergoing renovation.
- kevin_thibedeau 7y agoThey're an expensive maintenance chore. A broken down escalator drags down the whole property
- mdxchhcxdm 7y ago“An escalator can never break: it can only become stairs. You should never see an Escalator Temporarily Out Of Order sign, just Escalator Temporarily Stairs. Sorry for the convenience.” - Mitch Hedberg
- shmolyneaux 7y agoOne issue that isn't capture by that quote is that an escalator cannot be used while being repaired. If the maintenance person is away while the escalator is part-way through being repaired it's very reasonable to see a "Temporarily Out of Order" sign.
- masklinn 7y agoAlso escalators tend to be pretty bad at being stairs if you're not fit and healthy (and even then…), they usually have much higher steps and sharper edges than normal stairs, and are thus significantly less accessible when they're not operating.
- scarejunba 7y agoBART takes this philosophy truly to heart.
- rsynnott 7y agoI don’t think I’ve ever been in an office building with escalators. I think this is more just a result of them taking a shopping center, which usually has escalators, and turning it into an office, which doesn’t. They’re not really a practical way to get around; unless you have a rigid “stand to one side” rule (as on the London Underground) they’re slower than stairs.
- pessimizer 7y ago> White-collar workers today spend so much time sitting It would take a lot to convince me that white-collar workers of the past spent less time sitting.
- kortilla 7y ago>It's the age of Fitbit and walking around dense city centers What? Most people still don’t live in dense urban city centers. Look at LA and the Bay Area. Both are still dominated by driving.