4 ms·
Wow, what utter fucking bullshit. It looks like the court just rubber stamped whatever the BSA submitted. They actually say it's copyright infringement to cop
by jrockway 16y ago
Wow, what utter fucking bullshit. It looks like the court just rubber stamped whatever the BSA submitted. They actually say it's copyright infringement to copy a program into RAM to run it.
Mind boggling.
- mquander 16y agoYour remark is utter fucking bullshit; it's clear that is not the basis of this case. The decision explains clearly that Blizzard cannot put arbitrary conditions on a user's license to copy the program into RAM, so Glider is not liable for doing so against Blizzard's preference. First, although WoW players copy the software code into RAM while playing the game, Blizzard’s EULA and ToU authorize all licensed WoW players to do so. We have explained that ToU § 4(B)’s bot prohibition is a license covenant rather than a condition. Thus, a Glider user who violates this covenant does not infringe by continuing to copy code into RAM. Accordingly, MDY does not violate § 1201(b)(1) by enabling Glider users to avoid Warden’s interruption of their authorized copying into RAM. (from earlier) A Glider user violates the covenants with Blizzard, but does not thereby commit copyright infringement because Glider does not infringe any of Blizzard’s exclusive rights... Were we to hold otherwise, Blizzard — or any software copyright holder — could designate any disfavored conduct during software use as copyright infringement, by purporting to condition the license on the player’s abstention from the disfavored conduct.
- orangecat 16y agoThey actually say it's copyright infringement to copy a program into RAM to run it. Thanks to incredibly idiotic rulings like MAI v Peak, it pretty much is.
- tzs 16y agoWhat is idiotic about MAI vs. Peak?
- orangecat 16y agoThe idea that loading a program into RAM for the purpose of executing it counts as a "copy" is as silly as the idea that you copy a book by reading it since its information is transmitted to your optic nerve and memory.
- tzs 16y ago17 USC 101 defines copies thusly: “Copies” are material objects, other than phonorecords, in which a work is fixed by any method now known or later developed, and from which the work can be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated, either directly or with the aid of a machine or device. The term “copies” includes the material object, other than a phonorecord, in which the work is first fixed. and defines "fixed" as: A work is “fixed” in a tangible medium of expression when its embodiment in a copy or phonorecord, by or under the authority of the author, is sufficiently permanent or stable to permit it to be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated for a period of more than transitory duration. I don't see how the court could have NOT found that a program in RAM is a copy. It's fixed. It can be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated from RAM. It would be possible to change the law to make it so that loading a program into RAM is not a copy, but then you'd have to have some kind of unnatural definition of copy. It makes far more sense to recognized a program in RAM as a copy and then make it so that copy is not an infringing copy (and that would be 17 USC 117, which says it is not infringement for the owner of a particular copy of a program to copy it to RAM to run the program).
- chc 16y agoThe code in RAM is transitory — more so than the brain-copy in a person with eidetic memory. Unless we're talking about RAM disks, its whole purpose is to be a transient, noncanonical representation of the actual on-disk program.
- tptacek 16y agoBeyond the distiction 'mquander drew, note also: the court acknowledges you haven't violated copyright by copying a program into RAM if you own the copy of the software. However, Blizzard went way out of its way to ensure that it had licensed the software, not sold it, with the result that it retained control over the precise nature of any copies you made, temporary or otherwise. Then, like 'mquander points out, the court gutted any value Blizzard got out of controlling the right to make temporary RAM copies of the software.