4 ms·
This book predates many important developments of the 20th century. I'd say its value is nearly zero nowadays, except from a historical standpoint.
by andrepd 7y ago
This book predates many important developments of the 20th century. I'd say its value is nearly zero nowadays, except from a historical standpoint.
- dwheeler 7y agoI agree, this document is really only useful for historical development. However, it is useful for tracking down some history. I've been trying to track down this expression: "All men are mortal; Socrates is a man; therefore Socrates is mortal". It's often quoted, but no one gave me a source. Using this old book I managed to track it back to at least A System of logic... by John Stuart Mill, 1843, Book II Chapter 3 page 245. https://archive.org/details/systemoflogicrat01millrich/page/244 https://archive.org/details/systemoflogicrat01millrich/page/... The quote may be even older, but that was still a help. If anyone knows an older source, I'd love to know. But that at least helped. Anyway: while this document is only useful for its historical connection, as a way to investigate the history of logic it's interesting.
- tunesmith 7y agoWhat a great snippet of info to know, thanks for posting this. I often use that syllogism as an example for some visual logic software I'm writing.
- JasonFruit 7y agoI disagree. I think this sort of traditional, verbal logic becomes ingrained in the mind in a way that more modern logical systems don't. While we have a more rigorous, strictly correct understanding of logic now, its separation from the expression of ideas in a subset of natural language makes it harder to apply to one's day-to-day thought. I greatly value my early exposure to syllogistic logic and early Greek philosophy; I think it improved my reasoning and thereby my life.
- crimsonalucard 7y agoWhat would be the modern equivalent? If I want to study the bottom most foundations of mathematics, is logic the right choice?