3 ms·
So you don’t want a smart TV but you’re okay with Roku - whose CEO said on an interview that their entire business model is selling user data, half the home scr
by scarface74 7y ago
So you don’t want a smart TV but you’re okay with Roku - whose CEO said on an interview that their entire business model is selling user data, half the home screen has an ad, and the hard coded buttons on the remote go to highest bidder?
Chromecast is sold by a business whose entire model is collecting user data and selling advertising.
Don’t get me wrong, I love my TCL Roku TVs - I have three. But let’s call a spade a spade. Also, my main one is setup to go directly to the HDMI port used by my AppleTV.
- Spivak 7y agoI don't think it's really about the data collection or whatever. The problem is that today, right now, you will get a much better experience with a dumb TV and a smart appliance than a smart TV. Like the software quality is better, you can mix and match devices, you get feature and security updates, the apps are better, you get support, the apps don't EOL when next year's model comes out. I don't really care if TV's bundle their software stack into the device -- clearly some people like them. It's the TVs that put ads on the input selection menu that go straight to my shitlist.
- scarface74 7y agoI agree. I wouldn’t get any smart TV besides one with Roku built in. As much as I despise the ads, Roku has a long history of supporting their devices as long as feasible.
- wlesieutre 7y agoI had a Roku 3, which was nice when I got it. Then they started patching ads in everywhere. I've since chucked it and sworn off the company. Apple TV is the only "smart TV" device that I'd trust to not patch in ads like that at this point. Similarly, it's the only one I trust to not be spying on me for data brokers.
- saagarjha 7y agoI’d trust them a lot more than my average TV manufacturer to keep their products up-to-date.
- rc_kas 7y agoAnd at least you leave yourself plenty of flexibility to change vendors if/when you want to.
- scarface74 7y agoBecause Google is never known to abandon products..... But, whether the TV is smart or not, as long as it has HDMI ports, it really doesn’t matter.
- hyperman1 7y agoAssuming it wont start to give popups because it is 6 months since the last update so will you please connect the ethernet cable.
- ilikehurdles 7y agoThere are a plethora of reasons to reject smart tvs outside of the privacy infringing angle. Roku devices can be found for well under $100. You can choose not to use your Roku, disconnect it, or buy a different device for small financial hit in comparison to buying a new TV. Back when we had TV-VCR combos, a significant segment of the population was educated enough to opt for the TV sets with fewer features, because we knew that when the VCR stops working, the TV stops working. When you want to upgrade the VCR, well then now you either get a new TV or have a redundant VCR you can't physically get rid of. Similarities apply with the Smart TV situation but the reasonable "non-smart" options are quickly being drowned out by the "smart" devices. For what it's worth, my setup is a dumb Samsung TV and an attached Apple TV. One HDMI slot is left open for the occasional thing I want to plug in that can't be streamed or mirrored (e.g. a playstation). I haven't used that other slot in over a year and it's nice not being forced to do so. I'll keep using this TV for years with the comfort of knowing that, a few years from now, I won't have to wade through menus of streaming services I don't use in order to watch something on an 5-8 year old under-resourced, internet-connected OS with a half-assed UX that stopped receiving software and firmware updates after its first or second year.