3 ms·
>Mathematics treats of the relations of all sorts of things considered as quantities, namely, as equal to, or greater or less than, one another. This was not a
by whatshisface 7y ago
>Mathematics treats of the relations of all sorts of things considered as quantities, namely, as equal to, or greater or less than, one another.
This was not actually true when this book was written: Euler's formula was discovered in 1748, which I would consider evidence that complex numbers were broadly "around" at least a century before 1898. Complex numbers are not ordered, (for example, is 1 less than or greater than i?), so this claim about math isn't right.
>But, as we have seen, Logic does not investigate the truth, trustworthiness, or validity of its own principles; nor does Mathematics
It does now!
>As a Regulative Science, pointing out the conditions of true inference (within its own sphere), Logic is co-ordinate with [...] (ii) Æsthetics, considered as determining the principles of criticism and good taste.
It is funny now that people would study up on logic so they could prove to their colleagues whether or not the latest production at the local theater was any good.
- JasonFruit 7y agoYour comment seems determined to take the least charitable possible interpretation of the material from the first few pages of the book. I'm sad that you chose not to engage with the value it could provide.
- whatshisface 7y agoLeast charitable? There's no way that the author could have been expected to anticipate how logic would develop over the next century, I'm just looking at it from a modern perspective.