4 ms·
Taxing them to recoup carbon emissions would only reduce air travel, not eliminate all carriers. Say that it gets 5x or 10x more expensive, there would still b
by epistasis 7y ago
Taxing them to recoup carbon emissions would only reduce air travel, not eliminate all carriers.
Say that it gets 5x or 10x more expensive, there would still be flights, just far less common. And maybe then something like biokerosene becomes cost effective, driving down costs more.
- Spivak 7y agoJust want to throw it out there that your typical passenger airline operates at a 2.5% margin. Freight airlines are even less. That multiplayer is going directly to consumers. Nobody wants a world where we're paying $50 to ship a package, $1000 for a short flight, or their grocery bill to double since transportation is most of the cost.
- mikeash 7y agoA proper carbon tax would capture the externalities. If that results in a cost of $50 to ship a package, that just means we’re paying $50 now, but most of that cost is borne by other people who get no say.
- ergothus 7y agoA world where we have cheap shipping/flights but pay the same excessive total or more elsewhere to deal with the externalities isnt better, it is just shifting the misery around.
- Spivak 7y agoI don't disagree at all but shifting the costs of these externalities to individuals who really have no power doesn't really accomplish anything and is basically the definition of regressive. Telling someone who was living paycheck to paycheck before the change that their cost of living doubled and they should think of the environment is insane. So yes. Please shift the misery.
- epistasis 7y agoWe are already shifting the misery to people have no control of it, that's what an externality is. First, most carbon taxes I have seen proposed are revenue neutral, and give the money back to those with lower incomes or provide lower carbon options to people like transit. Though vehicle access and use has climbed in recent years in places like Southern California, it's not as though a carbon tax is an unavoidable expense, people always have other options. A doubling of the cost of living is just so far outside of the plausible realm as to be ridiculous. A $3/gallon gas tax is way higher than any carbon tax I've seen proposed, but even if the economy didn't adapt to it and optimize a ton, that's not enough for a doubling of the cost of living. The key is that we must change behavior, and change our carbon use. It's not enough to say "if we do this bad it will hurt this small group of people," we must say that and show how to mitigate that harm or show that it's greater harm than our current course of action. The status quo is not justified as a default option.
- xboxnolifes 7y agoNobody wants a world that is completely destroyed by poor ecological decisions either, but compromises have to be made one way or the other.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoThe point of carbon taxes is that it captures externalities. To use some real numbers, instead of "$50 a package"; a fully capturing carbon tax on gasoline would raise its cost between $1-$3 a gallon. People would scream, but the point is that WE'RE ALREADY PAYING $1-$3 a gallon for our CO2. It's just that it's not the driver that's paying, it's people in areas vulnerable to climate change and future generations.
- Spivak 7y agoI'm not saying we don't pay for it, but discouraging consumption by taxing usage directly at the pump or indirectly at the drill will end up doing more harm than good for our economy.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoHaving Florida sink into the ocean will do more harm to our economy than paying a couple dollars more at the pump.
- Spivak 7y agoSounds small when it's the price of a single fill up but $3/gallon would cost US drivers about $500 billion annually and that's before the second order effects of making basically every single good and service more expensive along with it. I mean losing Florida outright would cost $1 trillion annually so you got me there. As long as we keep half of Florida we're probably good though. Let that sink in. $3/gallon is about the same as losing the entirety of Ohio. There's a reason we fight wars over this stuff. I desperately want to be better to our environment but these kinds of 'simple solutions' can't possibly work in isolation. Reducing consumption sounds nice until you remember all the people whose lives depend on that consumption to live.
- bryanlarsen 7y agoIt's not a $500 billion loss. That $500 billion would be spent on something (consumer rebate, carbon sequestration, debt repayment, something). And government spending has second order effects too, estimated at about 1.75x for direct consumer rebates, less for anything else. So it's possible that the carbon tax would have a net positive on the economy. Even if it isn't a net positive by itself, the net effect will be a LOT less than $500B.