4 ms·
>>Uber Eats and competitors including Stuart, a French app, and Glovo, based in Spain, said they were aware of misconduct. “We’re concerned because these are il
by sandworm101 7y ago
>>Uber Eats and competitors including Stuart, a French app, and Glovo, based in Spain, said they were aware of misconduct. “We’re concerned because these are illegal practices in which people are profiting from the vulnerability of others,” said Nicolas Breuil, global marketing manager for Stuart.
Pot. Kettle. Black.
Uber et al have for years argued that driver/riders are not employees. If they aren't employees then they are contractors. One of the basic definitions of contractors is that they may subcontract. To call subcontracting "illegal" is a stretch. It may be a violation of a clause in the contract, but it isn't a crime. Use of illegal labourers is a crime, but the simple act of having someone other than the original contractor deliver the food isn't.
If Uber wants to deal with a particular person and ensure that only that person handles the actual labor, Uber is free to HIRE that person.
- Kurtz79 7y ago"Use of illegal labourers is a crime, but the simple act of having someone other than the original contractor deliver the food isn't." Yes, and the issue is using illegal labourers, not the subcontracting itself.
- IloveHN84 7y agoIt should also be made illegal to pay so few fares to couriers. It's under the level of acceptance
- iraldir 7y agoI believe the (official) problem here is that the subcontracted workers can't be employed because they are underage, illegal immigrants etc.
- sandworm101 7y agoAs I said, using illegal labourers is a crime. But "profiting from the vulnerability of others" is the basis of Uber's business model. It's laughable to hear them complain about someone else sidestepping labour standards to pay people less than a minimum. I think they are just upset that someone has managed to shave profit from their system. Uber is jealous that it cannot access this ultra-cheap labour pool itself.
- Bakary 7y agoIt's not laughable because they aren't hypocritical but cynical. They know they can get away with this, and do.
- progval 7y ago> French labor law allows independent contractors to outsource to legal workers, but Uber Eats, Stuart and Glovo said they prohibited subcontracting.
- seanhandley 7y agoWhat about safeguards? Stuart's couriers need ID so they're legally accountable for their actions. To subcontract is to skip a background check.
- CamelCaseName 7y agoShouldn't the the contractor be responsible for running a background check on the sub-contractor..? If the sub-contractor fails, then the contractor is on the hook.
- eevilspock 7y ago> To call subcontracting "illegal" is a stretch. Legal does not equate to moral. The subcontracting going on here, illegal or not, is reprehensible because it is exploitative. On top of that the rent-seeking itself is morally bankrupt. It's extracting something from others essentially for free. I'm a socialist, but only the worst kind of capitalist or libertarian would think this is ok.
- C1sc0cat 7y agoEmploying those unable to work is probably a serious crime it certainly is in the UK - Gordon Browns cleaner had used a forged passport and he got fined about £10k