3 ms·
Maybe I'm giving people too much credit, and I'm sick of arguing about this because, in my mind, seeing a bunch of swastikas isn't going to make me anti-semitic
by nimrod3434 7y ago
Maybe I'm giving people too much credit, and I'm sick of arguing about this because, in my mind, seeing a bunch of swastikas isn't going to make me anti-semitic.
I even sometimes find it funny (especially when people draw the arms wrong); but maybe for others it really is just a way to spread their ugly hatred, and that's not at all what I'm trying to defend.
I think the problem with this argument is that we're both actually right, but only in certain situations.
- foldr 7y agoI think you are missing the point. If you ignore people vandalizing things with swastikas, then you enable anti-Semites. It doesn't make much difference how anti-Semitic the people drawing the swastikas are. It's still creating a hostile environment for Jewish people and emboldening people with extreme views. And, yes, I think you are indeed giving people too much credit.
- nimrod3434 7y agoExcuse me sir, but swastikas aren't just offensive to Jewish people. They gassed slavs too (among a multitude of other demographics), and in case you haven't realized: the nazis invaded Poland and created ghettos there. So no, this isn't just about Jewish people.
- foldr 7y agoI didn’t say that this was just about Jewish people. The context here is a Jewish mother writing about kids drawing swastikas on a desk in a US school. That behavior is not likely to be driven by anti-Slavic sentiment. You would indeed think that swastikas would be offensive to the people of any formerly Nazi-occupied country. And yet, Jewish cemeteries in (e.g.) France and Poland still get vandalized with swastikas and other Nazi-inspired graffiti. There is a growing far right movement in the US and Europe that’s anti-Jewish and broadly pro-Nazi. That’s the current threat, and the context in which a swastika is likely to be interpreted.
- klhjdfg98_dfjg 7y agoIt is just a symbol. No more, no less. If you get so worked up about it, you are only giving it more power. And just to Godwin this entire conversation, my grandpa's brother died in one of the camps.
- foldr 7y ago"Maybe the anti-Semitism will go away if we ignore it." That was the false hope of many broadly decent-minded people who were taken in by Hitler in the 1930s. I can't really think of a single instance historically where bigotry has gone away because people ignored it. Also, saying that the swastika is "just a symbol" with an account you created less than an hour ago is pretty trollish. Looks like you don't have the stomach to associate that statement even with your regular online handle?
- m9niskirt 7y agoSame person. Different account. You make a lot of assumptions and state them in a way that border on ad hominems. While I will get smth more permanent evetually, today is not that day. I no longer feel I should be responding to you or your arguments though. It reads like a script. Have fun.