3 ms·
Not really, I'm arguing that "it is theoretically possible for humans to build and program Turing machines to undertake human whole brain simulation" relies ent
by notahacker 7y ago
Not really, I'm arguing that "it is theoretically possible for humans to build and program Turing machines to undertake human whole brain simulation" relies entirely upon magical thinking. It's not so much a case of "we don't have the processing power", though we don't, as "there's no theoretical basis for assuming the human mind[1] has the capability to parse and understand the information content of a molecular structure so complex it contains the human mind within it in sufficient detail to program an accurate simulation of a human mind" (the real time stuff is moot, but since the whole point of a Turing test is a human can be convinced that another human is sat the other side of a terminal, an extended delay whilst the machine parses the complexity of "what is your name?" is a pretty hard fail).
I think it's pretty obvious there's a discontinuity between simulating mechanical responses of a nematode worm to stimulation of fewer neurons than I've lost typing this sentence and achieving AGI by human brain emulation, though we're finding the worm pretty tough. Nobody is arguing nematode worms have intelligence, for a start...
[1]obviously one could assume sufficiently powerful AGI could do it, but if the prior existence of AGI is a prerequisite for a particular approach to AGI, we can safely ignore it as a proof of routes to AGI.