4 ms·
> It is semantic nonsense to quibble about whether Ragtime is classical as much as it would be nonsense to quibble about whether D is in the set of {A,B,C}. The
by lmm 7y ago
> It is semantic nonsense to quibble about whether Ragtime is classical as much as it would be nonsense to quibble about whether D is in the set of {A,B,C}. They are all letters, and D has lots of qualities close to {A,B,C}, but it isn't in the set, maybe we could define the set {A,B,C,D} and say D is in that, but then we have a new set.
Our definitions should reflect the underlying reality; otherwise we will be mislead by them ( https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/FaJaCgqBKphrDzDSj/37-ways-that-words-can-be-wrong https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/FaJaCgqBKphrDzDSj/37-ways-th... ). "Do we refer to ragtime with this particular pattern of letters" is indeed an uninteresting question, but "does ragtime have as much in common with these other forms that we call classical as they do with each other" is meaningful and ultimately grounded in objective reality.
> ultimately we should look at Renaissance, Baroque, Classical, and Romantic as separate things and understand them separately.
Yes and no. "All models are false; some are useful". Of course baroque/classical/romantic have differences, and if you zoom in on any one you'll find further distinctions within that group. But all models are simplifications, and as long as that simplification genuinely corresponds to reality - there is a lot that baroque/classical/romantic have in common with each other in a way that they don't with, say, rock - then it's useful to group them together in a category with a name.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]