3 ms·
> Chopin, Liszt, and Beethoven were absolutely writing to put bread on the table, and absolutely did not play to the score as written. Is whether or not you pl
by mcv 7y ago
> Chopin, Liszt, and Beethoven were absolutely writing to put bread on the table, and absolutely did not play to the score as written.
Is whether or not you play the score as written an issue? How do we even know this about composers that predate recording technology?
I'm not wondering if maybe the advent of recording technology might be the source of the modern distinction between classical, pop and jazz.
Something that struck me from the bit you quoted from the article:
> > In general, a classical composer uses music to express his deepest emotions and experiences.
I think that might actually be more true of some forms of jazz and pop. Much classical music is very much an intellectual exercise, whereas blues and rock tend to be far more emotional. But again this varies wildly within each genre. Hardly a meaningful distinction.
There's a massive difference between pre-20th century classical music, which was very much the pop music of its day, and modern classical music, which is often far less accessible and more elitist. (Though there are still many beautiful and accessible modern classical pieces. Interestingly, many draw inspiration from jazz.)
- lmm 7y ago> Is whether or not you play the score as written an issue? It's a question discussed extensively in the essay, and one that the essay sees (ahistorically, but perhaps descriptively true in modern practice) as defining the distinction between classical and jazz. > How do we even know this about composers that predate recording technology? Accounts from people who saw multiple performances, evidence of composers reworking written pieces after experimenting during performance, composers' own diaries... > I think that might actually be more true of some forms of jazz and pop. Much classical music is very much an intellectual exercise, whereas blues and rock tend to be far more emotional. But again this varies wildly within each genre. Hardly a meaningful distinction. Yeah, agreed. Indeed I'd say pop often expresses the emotions that are most fundamental and deeply held (which by the same token are often the simplest and clearest).
- brobdingnagians 7y agoWhat most people call "Classical" music now is really an large umbrella term for instrumental art music written in tonal forms prior to the 20th century on a certain class of instruments and with vaguely homogeneous views on what music should be and includes Baroque, Classical, Romantic and a few others. It is semantic nonsense to quibble about whether Ragtime is classical as much as it would be nonsense to quibble about whether D is in the set of {A,B,C}. They are all letters, and D has lots of qualities close to {A,B,C}, but it isn't in the set, maybe we could define the set {A,B,C,D} and say D is in that, but then we have a new set. Pick a new word and move on in life. Or you can co-opt the word "Classical" and add new things into the label, but that would be different than what we are talking about. Is Beethoven Classical or Romantic era? His early works are Classical, his later works become more and more Romantic and he is basically the father of the Romantic era, but we have to take a more nuanced view of everything he wrote. He isn't "just Romantic" but was influenced and influenced a whole host of ideas and areas. We can define attributes of a class and maybe we can say that anything that walks and quacks is a duck, but it is all simply splitting hairs and re-definitions. It is useful to have classes of things and distinctions of things that look alike, because then we can hope to reason about them, but ultimately we should look at Renaissance, Baroque, Classical, and Romantic as separate things and understand them separately. In my view, one of the aims of a lot of classical music was to have highly structured music which could evoke a complex tapestry of emotion and ideals. It takes deeper understanding to get and appreciate a lot of art music ("music snobs"), but it was written for a _purpose_ and _ideal_, often ideological, religious, or emotional. Pop music is fun, lighthearted, easy to appreciate for most people and evokes feelings that we all know. But art music can be amplified by knowing the ideals and desires of those who wrote it. Beethoven's Eroica symphony has a complex background, symbolic and stylistic reasons for the way it is with the original desire to tribute Napoleon as a representative of Republican ideals (before he crowned himself Emperor... which made Beethoven erase that...). It is similar to appreciating why the Fairie Queene was written and appreciating the deeper symbolic meaning and cultural ideals, rather than reading the Hardy Boys or Nancy Drew as pleasant detective fiction. That's my take on it.
- lmm 7y ago> It is semantic nonsense to quibble about whether Ragtime is classical as much as it would be nonsense to quibble about whether D is in the set of {A,B,C}. They are all letters, and D has lots of qualities close to {A,B,C}, but it isn't in the set, maybe we could define the set {A,B,C,D} and say D is in that, but then we have a new set. Our definitions should reflect the underlying reality; otherwise we will be mislead by them ( https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/FaJaCgqBKphrDzDSj/37-ways-that-words-can-be-wrong https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/FaJaCgqBKphrDzDSj/37-ways-th... ). "Do we refer to ragtime with this particular pattern of letters" is indeed an uninteresting question, but "does ragtime have as much in common with these other forms that we call classical as they do with each other" is meaningful and ultimately grounded in objective reality. > ultimately we should look at Renaissance, Baroque, Classical, and Romantic as separate things and understand them separately. Yes and no. "All models are false; some are useful". Of course baroque/classical/romantic have differences, and if you zoom in on any one you'll find further distinctions within that group. But all models are simplifications, and as long as that simplification genuinely corresponds to reality - there is a lot that baroque/classical/romantic have in common with each other in a way that they don't with, say, rock - then it's useful to group them together in a category with a name.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- 0815test 7y ago> Is whether or not you play the score as written an issue? How do we even know this about composers that predate recording technology? Sometimes they pretty much tell us directly, e.g. in treatises which discuss performance. Other times, we can look at early recorded media to figure out what the style was. But there's no question that classical used to have a hugely important tradition of improvisation, which was only gradually lost throughout the 19th-c., as technical ability in performance was regarded as more important than well-rounded musical aptitude. It survives today, e.g. among organists, who are still trained in both performance and composition. > There's a massive difference between pre-20th century classical music, which was very much the pop music of its day Well, not totally true. On the one hand, by the 19th century, pop music did exist already, e.g. Stephen Foster's songs; on the other hand, it was not yet radically different from classical music, being published in sheet music form, for a musically-knowledgeable public. It would be hard to tell apart a Stephen Foster song from the 19th c., from a classical "arietta" or "canzonet", of the sort that even e.g. Joseph Haydn composed, by any inherent criteria. Classical music forms did vary widely in "intellectual" ambition ("arietta's" and "canzonet's" being on the low end, together with dance suites, "divertimenti's" and "cassations"), but for a long time that ambition wasn't regarded as incompatible with some degree of reasonably-widespread appeal - for something on the "high" end, consider symphonies, instrumental concerti or opera overtures.