4 ms·
Voting age and drinking age have been separated for decades and we’ve gotten used to it. I don’t see setting the marijuana age limit to be 25 to be any more/le
by paulcole 7y ago
Voting age and drinking age have been separated for decades and we’ve gotten used to it.
I don’t see setting the marijuana age limit to be 25 to be any more/less arbitrary. No need to bring sacred cows into this.
- TylerE 7y agoWhat do you hope to accomplish by this? History says again and again that banning something doesn't make it happen less, it just lets criminal elements profit from it.
- paulcole 7y agoI mean I’m not accomplishing anything. And honestly I don’t even hope for anything either! I’m just saying that some state setting marijuana age limit at 25 isn’t going to make people question drinking age, voting age, military age, etc.
- h0l0cube 7y agoThe prohibition movement is the usual example provided to support that theory, but historians and experts in the domain do acknowledge there was still an overall decrease in consumption of alcohol during prohibition. 'Courtwright’s The Age of Addiction has the statistics: “Per capita consumption initially fell to 30 percent of pre-Prohibition levels, before gradually increasing to 60 or 70 percent by 1933.” That suggests a 30 percent reduction, at a minimum, in consumption — although that was less than the initial effect, as people figured some ways around the law.' https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/6/5/18518005/prohibition-alcohol-public-health-crime-benefits https://www.vox.com/the-highlight/2019/6/5/18518005/prohibit...
- pmoriarty 7y agoBut was that reduction in use a result of Prohibition or of the moralistic anti-drinking attitude that was prevalent at the time? Even if Prohibition itself was responsible for the reduction in drinking, we must consider whether the overall effect on society was worth it. This effect included an enormous increase in organized crime, murders and other types of violence, and widespread corruption. American society as a whole decided that no, it was not worth it, and repealed Prohibition. The effect of the current war on drugs is arguably much, much worse than Prohibition ever was.
- h0l0cube 7y agoI recommend reading the article. It has compelling alternate hypotheses for the increase in crime. It also broaches the topic of the 'war on drugs', though I don't recall that it makes any useful comparison of modern 'harm minimization' strategies and prohibition.
- pmoriarty 7y agoI'm not sure how much practical effect such an age limit would have. Even at the height of the drug war, when cannabis was illegal in every state in the US, it was incredibly easy to get for anyone who wanted it. Now that it's effectively legal in many states, it's even easier to get. People below whatever minimum age limit might not be able to legally get in to a business that sells cannabis, but already plenty of underage drinkers get in to bars with fake ID's, and they could always get the cannabis from their friends, black/gray-market dealers, or just grow their own from seed. The Netherlands, where cannabis has been effectively legal for many decades, has a much lower percentage of youth who use cannabis than the US. It's just not considered cool there, as it's not forbidden as it is in the States. Often, the attitude among natives in general there is that it's something that mostly tourists or foreigners do. But in the US, forbidden fruit is going to look twice as attractive and taste twice as sweet. So setting a minimum age limit might have the paradoxical effect of making users out of more youth than would otherwise try it.